“I ACCUSE!” The Earth-Two Batman speaks from beyond the grave, as his journal accuses the JSA of helping Hitler during World War II in “I Accuse!” and “Witness for the Persecution!” Featuring appearances by Superman, Starman, Wonder Woman, the Atom, Hawkman, Green Lantern, Robin, the Flash, Wildcat, Doctor Fate, Hourman, Dr. Mid-Nite, Johnny Thunder, the Huntress and the Spectre. Infinity, Inc. has a cameo.
- "Chapter One: 'I Accuse!'" written by Roy and Dann Thomas, consultant Rich Morrissey, penciled by Rafael Kayanan, Rich Buckler (pages 4, 6-7) and Jerry Ordway (page 12), inked by Alfredo Alcala and Bill Collins, colored by Adrienne Roy and lettered by David Cody Weiss.
- "Chapter Two: Witness for the Persecution!" penciled by Rafael Kayanan and inked by Alfredo Alcala.
- "Prologomena" one column text piece on the inside front cover by Roy Thomas.
- "A Skeleton Key to 'America vs. the Justice Society' #1" two page text piece on the inside front and back cover by Roy Thomas.
- Back cover is a reprint of the cover to All-Star Comics #4.
- Most characters have cameo flashback appearances.
- Jimmy Olsen of Earth-2 appears.
- On page 40 panel 2 Helmut Streicher is mentioned but is not seen.