the_mighty_monarch's All-Star Western #16 - It's A Madhouse; Tomahawk, Part 4: Legacy review

Avatar image for the_mighty_monarch

Arkham Mansion: A Serious House In a Serious 19th Century

I really don't like this cover, it's generic, way too close up, and I'm just not a fan of Walter Simonson's artwork, especially in contrast to the other covers. It just sticks out like a sore thumb.

It feels like we missed an issue or something, because this one picks up presumedly weeks later, and Jonah Hex has already settled into a new status quo of depression and angst with a nurse taking care of him at Arkham's house. There's a definite hilarity to the interactions between the 'hard west man' Jonah Hex and the compassionate but strictly dutiful Constance. She sticks strictly to medical convention, but she's certainly not afraid to speak her mind to the boorish Hex. We really get a strong feel for Jonah when we finally see him in the one situation he can't fight his way out of. Constance is getting fed up with him, but you can see how much of his outbursts are covering up his overwhelming sorrow at being confined by his own body. We also see a surprisingly literate side to Jonah, reading entire books from Arkham's library in a single sitting to Constance's surprise. It lends to his detective skills later on as he quickly analyzes the expression of Mrs. Arkham's madness.

And of course in the halls of Arkham's mansion, we're finally treated to a vision of Arkham's bedridden mother. She's definitely not what I expected from the little offscreen appearances she's had leading up to this. Her room is incredibly unnerving, and she herself is a full vision of age-induced dementia. It's very interesting to see what changes Hex brings to her once he visits her for the first time, with the intent to put her out of her misery. She begins to walk and interact with people without yelling and screaming, a feat that will certainly shock Amadeus when he returns.

But interrupting this whirlwind of intriguing character interactions is the return of Mr. Hyde to wrap up this arc. This is another reason it feels like we're missing an issue. Not enough time passed between encounters, at least in terms of reading. Yes, weeks or months passed in comic time, but as readers this is the very next issue after Hyde broke Hex's leg and escaped to lick his wounds and work on his formula. This final battle is satisfying in and of itself, but in the context of the bigger arc, it comes very suddenly and too soon. It's also a fantastic expression of how the characters have grown during the ordeal of Hex's confinement, something we got to see very little of in its development. I'm not sure if Constance is going to stick around, because she appears to be a one time character, but it'd be a shame to put all her development to waste, plus she provides a fun and different foil to Hex. One way Gray and Palmiotti attempt to rectify the rushed story is the way Hyde uses his intellectual side to make keen observations about what must have occurred in the time he was away. As interesting as that was, especially giving such formality and analytical insight to a character who is essentially a brawler other half to a genius doctor, it doesn't fully justify the rushed buildup to the conclusion.

In Conclusion: 4/5

Despite my concerns about the lack of development between issues and the suddenness of the climax, the climax itself was very satisfying. This issue also had some of the most deep and intense character work yet, as we saw Jonah Hex outside his comfort zone of conflict for the first time, forced to introspect. The lost point is mainly to the dry 'history textbook' co-feature that is Tomahawk. It's FINALLY ending, I haven't even read it since the beginning, it just bores me so much every time I try.

Other reviews for All-Star Western #16 - It's A Madhouse; Tomahawk, Part 4: Legacy

    All-Star Western #16 Review 0

    ***SPOILER FREE REVIEW***The latest issue of Gray and Palmiotti's All-Star Western is another solid comic book by the writing duo, bringing both fun and interesting character development to this series.Gray and Palmiotti are known for writing fun comic books, and All-Star Western is certainly a fun comic book. While I've been a little disappointed by the current arc, this issue is a step in the right direction as we get action and character development. Since Jonah Hex is sidelined from the occu...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    Good, but not Great, Ending to Jeckyl/Hyde Story 0

    At the start of issue 16, we find that nearly a month has passed since the events that transpired in the last issue. Arkham is still committed, and Hex has been staying at Arkham's mansion, still recovering from the injuries (including a broken leg) he sustained in his fight with Mr. Hyde. In addition, we find that he has been drinking heavily and has slipped into a severe bout of depression as he remains confined to a wheelchair while his leg heals. A nurse (Constance) has been assigned to care...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.