sleepbutnodream15's All-New X-Men #5 review

Avatar image for sleepbutnodream15

This series would be screwed without Immonen

I never really understood all the hate for Bendis, but I can see some of the reasons why people don't like him that much. He kinda ignores already established ideas, concepts, and characteristics of certain people for the sake of his own storytelling. For example, the scene where Wolverine confronts young Cyclops. Not only does he contemplate actually killing Cyclops, but he does it out loud, with none of the faculty really trying to stop him, and in front of all the students. In fact, there's a moment where he asks for the student's vote as to whether he should kill Cyclops. I felt like this part kinda destroyed all the development to the character that guys like Jason Aaron and Rick Remender wrote. In UXF Wolverine felt a lot of regret for being involved in young Apocalypse's killing. Then, he really felt the weight of all his murders when he had to off his own son. These two events should have had an enormous effect on him, that's what Remender wanted. Jason Aaron's WATXM established Logan as a more responsible man that was over his animal days. He became a character that was almost a good role model to his students (or at least, as good as Wolverine is gonna get). Anyway, that part was really stupid. I'm just gonna try playing it off like it was a heat of the moment kinda thing for Wolverine for future readings. Also, when Beast said he wants Cyclops to "take his shame to the grave" also bothered me. Does Beast really think that little of Scott that he would rather him die with shame than redeem himself while he's alive? Him and Wolverine have been written as huge hypocrites for the last year, and not just by Bendis, but by almost every writer at Marvel. That really needs to be fixed. I like the idea of Cyclops running around as a sort of villain/anti-hero/revolutionary in the eyes of the other heroes, but I hate the massive amount of contempt he's being shown by every character, mainly the ones who have their own checkered pasts. Oh, I can't forgot, it seems like we might be adding young Jean Grey to that 'elite' group of hypocrites. After she has that beautifully drawn splash page where she sees everything that happens to her in the future, she gives young Scott the cold shoulder. So, she basically gets mad at him because he kills Xavier in the future (I'm assuming that's why she was mad), but completely forgets that their also parts of her life where they fall in love, get married, raise a kid, lead the X-Men and X-Factor, and everything else that's happened in the last 50 years of X-men continuity! Perfect...Hopefully in the next issue, this is justified, corrected, and/or explained.

Overall, despite my previous paragraph consisting completely of complaints, I didn't hate this issue or this series. I actually like this series and the idea of the old x-men coming to the present. I enjoyed the scenes where Beast and Jean were in present Beast's memories. All of it was good. This series is decent. I just wish Bendis would do some more research on certain characters in order to understand them a little better and to get their voices down. He shouldn't be taking such liberties, regardless how high up he is on the Marvel Pyramid. However, it doesn't seem like anyone else at Marvel is doing anything to fix or explain Wolverine and Beast's hypocrisy. Get to it writers!!! Lastly, I definitely cannot forget how amazing Stuart Immonen's art is. Every page is so well done. Like I mentioned before, that splash page with Jean Grey learning everything about her future self was perfect. His art itself, makes these issues worth buying.

Other reviews for All-New X-Men #5

    Jean's Future Flashes Before Her Eyes 0

    Although not necessarily the best series in the Marvel NOW! relaunches, it has been the one that I've been most interested in, and the one that I look most forward to reading. Brining the original X-Men to the present has turned out to be the best thing in this series, and it's that that keeps me coming back each issue for more.PlotThis issue sees the younger Beast attempt to save his future self, using Jean Grey's new telepathic powers to allow the future Beast to help him. Meanwhile Cyclops at...

    10 out of 10 found this review helpful.

    Exactly what I wanted also 100th review :) 0

    First off YES!!!! I did not think I was going to make it to 100 reviews but well here it is thanks to everyone who helped me get to this and recommended my reviews thank you Tomlikesfries, Thanosrules, Haydenclaireheroes, DarkNoldor and Johnkmccubbin thank you so much for recommending my reviews I am very grateful and anyone else who has ever recommended them thank you! Now you’re probably wondering why this is my hundredth review well ever since this issue had been announced I could not wait to...

    6 out of 6 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.