imperiousrix's X-23 #7 - Songs of the Orphan Child, Part 4 review

    Avatar image for imperiousrix

    Do What You Want, 'cause a Pirate is Free!

      

       
    X-23 has been a series that I can't quite figure out if I like or not.  While I like Laura and want to know more about her, I really don't know where this whole thing is going.  Issue #7 is somewhat of a transitional point in the wayward story, is it an entertaining one? 

    On the High Seas 

    Laura and Gambit are attempting to secure passage into Madripoor, hopefully to find the head of the Weapon X project and stop him from restarting the accursed program anew.  However, in order to garner a ride to the troubled nation, they must attempt a rescue attempt of a police officer being held captive by pirates.  Fighting and introspection occurs (which seems to be par for the coarse with X-23). 
     
    But despite my snark, what X-23 does it does very well.  Marjorie Liu knows the character extremely, and that gives the comic a very solid core.  Her interplay between herself and her near polar opposite in Gambit is thoroughly entertaining.  The artist for this issue is Sana Takeda, and I feel like his soft manga styling fits perfectly for X-23.  In many ways, Laura is the grim protagonist of a manga saga, and Takeda's pencils felt like they melded great with Liu's curt story-telling.  I am also absolutely in love with the cover by Kalman Andrasofszky.  Sadly, nothing like this appears in the book, but it's still amazing. 

    Rough Waters 

    And what DOES appear in this book is probably its weakest point.  Again, this is a transitional story before Laura faces Daken in Madripoor, but whereas this could have been a pretty great exercise in creative story-telling (AKA putting the character in a situation unique from her norm), it turns out as just a tad underwhelming.  No sooner are Laura and Gambit confronting the pirate band than the encounter is over, the story concluded, and nothing feeling richer or better for it.  It's not a bad stand-alone issue, and you could easily pick this up for someone who doesn't follow the series and they could enjoy it, but it just feels like another example of X-23 missing the mark. 

    Buried Treasure 

    However, as much as X-23 can underwhelm, it is a fairly solid book altogether.  There's action, there's solid storytelling, and there's good art.  I still feel like this series has much more to offer that it's not showing, but I'm easing into Laura's introspective journey with Gambit. 
     
    X-23 #7 steals 3 stars out of 5.

    Other reviews for X-23 #7 - Songs of the Orphan Child, Part 4

      Shiver me timbers! 0

      Synopsis: Laura and Gambit take on pirates. What's Good? There are some interesting questions that popped in my head as I read this issue: Can Wolverine actually swim? How does Gambit get his hair to stick up like that? But besides that, Marjorie Liu takes the time to go back to making Laura more human in this issue. While this issue can be considered to be a filler before the Draken crossover, it has some good character development.  Sana Takeda really should do the artwork more often for ...

      7 out of 7 found this review helpful.

      Arc Conclusion!? 0

      Cover:   Not a big fan of the cover.  I take it that it's supposed to be a "pirate" version of Gambit and X-23, but it's just not doing it for me.  What I do like is how the X-23 is colored yellow.  I've always been a fan of when they change the color of the titles throughout the series, makes the issues look really colorful.  The Good:    As other reviewers have mentioned, as well as friends of mine, the art was extremely well used here.  For me, it took a little getting used to but it's a de...

      8 out of 9 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.