You go younger or older but if you were charged with the task of recasting Wolverine who would you pick to play him in a movie/tv show etc?

Maybe Ray Stevenson?

matt cohen

bruce villanche

Guy Pearce.

A Hugh Jackman look a like.

Tom Hardy

Go back to the guy who was Originally Cast as Wolverine. Dougray Scott.

John Goodman

Jackson was one of the very VERY few things i actually liked about the movies.

Peter Dinklage.

That's not sarcasm, I want it. I want it now.

Hugh Jackman.

Someone hairy and about his official height of 5'3, nasty voice, pugnacious not handsome. It'd never fly in movie land but it's what he's supposed to look like. Well i added the nasty voice

I thought they already cast him as Puck.

No one.

Hugh Jackman can be the only Wolverine. There is no one out there (A or B list wise) that can do the character justice.

Danzig. Though Danzig is too old now. And wolverine got taller..

Prepare to flame on, but if I couldn't have Hugh Jackman, I'd at least call Jackie Earle Haley and tell him to grow a beard then come in for an audition. I know he's a bit older, but at least he's like 5' 5", can pull off the growl as seen in Watchmen, and just kind of looks like an animal. With a beard and the proper hair and make-up, I'm intrigued.

Puck can go to hell.

Puck did go to hell:

Death

During a battle with the Collective, it appeared all the members of Alpha Flight were either seriously hurt or killed. Puck was one of the teammates to have died. Surviving member Sasquatch made a new team called Omega Flight to keep the legacy of his fallen team-members alive. Some months later, when Wolverine was brought to Hell by a demon whom, it was learned that Puck was in Hell with Logan. Why he was stuck here, and not heaven and whether this was because of a trick or that he was truly deemed not worthy of heaven remained to be seen.

Honestly, i see Hugh Jackman as Wolverine and i'd have a difficult time accepting someone else to play him unless he gave up the role himself. I hear a lot of complaints about his size and that he's too handsome to play him, but i don't agree. He makes Wolverine come to life on the screen imo.

@gallivant said:

Go back to the guy who was Originally Cast as Wolverine. Dougray Scott.

I like this option

Samuel L Jackson

Nicolas Cage.

BB

Someone actually short!

Colin Farrell. Man was born to play Wolverine

Zach Galifianakis

Robin Williams

That dude hairy

Liev Schreiber

on second thought, Jack Nicholson XD

I actually had thought of this before. If he was still in his 30-40's, I'd have said Jack Nicholson. He did play a werewolf once, so that's kinda close XD

Christian Kane From Leverage.

This, Hugh I believe is a great Wolverine. There have been some bad movies (origins,x3) but that was the writers, producers, directors...etc. He has played the part perfect (for a movie version).

Sam Worthington?

to me Hugh Jackman is the best wolverine. he will be hard to replace.

:p

This! Short?-check. Compact?-check. Plays a convincing badass?-definite check.

@amratheking: or Norman Reedus. He's pretty Bada** on TWD.