The Watchmen get beamed to the past by Dr.Manhatten to stop the vigilante controversy from happening later to come. Rorschach would never agree with this but lets say he did. Rorschach,Nite-Owl II,Comedian,Adrian Veidt,and Silk Spectre try to stop vigilantism. Rorschach,Nite- Owl II,Comedian,Adrian,Silk Spectre fight against Captain Metropolis,Hooded Justice,Nite-Owl I, Silloette,Mothman,and Dollar Bill not including other Minutemen because Comedian won't fight himself and Laurie won't fight her mom.

Gallery

@reversenegative:This is the past Nite Owl I doesn't know Nite Owl II

Watchmen stomps.

The Comedian w/ weapons and a experienced Ozymandias future selfs are superior to their past selfs and they both could play a psychological game on Captain Metropolis and Dollar Bill to show that they can cross lines that they can't. Nite Owl II has some gadgets that can turn the tables around and is more than capable to take out Moth Man. Silk Specter would do fine against Silloette since she had proper training under her mom. Rorschach could probably take on Hooded Justice but it'll be a blood bath since Rorschach is dangerous and Hooded Justice is incredibly strong for his size. Comedian can just snip him and anyone else out at a distance if need be.