Could Beta Ray Bill work in the Marvel Cinematic Universe?

Avatar image for smart_dork_dude
Posted by Smart_Dork_Dude (3366 posts) - - Show Bio

Let me get this out of the way, I'm a major Thor fan. When it comes to Marvel heroes, he's always at the top of my list. As such I also love his supporting cast. Granted Bill isn't technically a part of it, but he's an ally of Thor's and without the Odinson he wouldn't even have Stormbreaker.

Now on to my main point. Could Beta Ray Bill work in a live action setting? I think they could do his look with practical make-up, provided they shorten his face some. I think with the MCU going more cosmic, that that means we can get into races like Kree, Skrull, and yes even Korbonites which are Bill's people.

I think it would make an interesting Thor sequel. Heck they could even reference Bill in Guardians of the Galaxy!

Avatar image for selinaky
#1 Posted by Selinaky (692 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm also a BRB fan, but somehow I can't imagine him in the films. I think people might get confused about him, and wonder why another Thor-like character is needed. Then again, they had War Machine in Iron Man 2. He'd need to be in Thor 3, and need a lot of screen time for Korbanites backstory, meeting Thor, getting Stormbreaker, fighting alongside Thor etc. I can't see it happening somehow... It would be awesome, though.

I'm curious about Balder, where is he?

Avatar image for thephoenx
#2 Posted by ThePhoenX (131 posts) - - Show Bio

@Selinaky said:

I'm also a BRB fan, but somehow I can't imagine him in the films. I think people might get confused about him, and wonder why another Thor-like character is needed. Then again, they had War Machine in Iron Man 2. He'd need to be in Thor 3, and need a lot of screen time for Korbanites backstory, meeting Thor, getting Stormbreaker, fighting alongside Thor etc. I can't see it happening somehow... It would be awesome, though.

I'm curious about Balder, where is he?

Feel the same! And (big) shame on me, I didn't even think about Balder when I saw the film!!! ;(

@Marvel Animation : Wake Up Guys!!!

Avatar image for selinaky
#3 Posted by Selinaky (692 posts) - - Show Bio

@ThePhoenX said:

@Selinaky said:

I'm also a BRB fan, but somehow I can't imagine him in the films. I think people might get confused about him, and wonder why another Thor-like character is needed. Then again, they had War Machine in Iron Man 2. He'd need to be in Thor 3, and need a lot of screen time for Korbanites backstory, meeting Thor, getting Stormbreaker, fighting alongside Thor etc. I can't see it happening somehow... It would be awesome, though.

I'm curious about Balder, where is he?

Feel the same! And (big) shame on me, I didn't even think about Balder when I saw the film!!! ;(

@Marvel Animation : Wake Up Guys!!!

Neither did I actually, then afterwards I thought 'Where was Balder?' haha. I wonder if he will be in any future films...

Avatar image for smart_dork_dude
#4 Posted by Smart_Dork_Dude (3366 posts) - - Show Bio

@Selinaky: I think it COULD work, if set up right. Thor: The Dark World is probably going to be set off earth entirely. They could have something that happens in that movie cause the cataclysm that destroys Bill's galaxy with him and his race leaving it as the post credits scene. I think it could be interesting and they don't NEED to make him like the comics where he has the EXACT same powers as Thor. I'm sure they could do it if they wanted too.

Avatar image for selinaky
#5 Posted by Selinaky (692 posts) - - Show Bio

@Smart_Dork_Dude said:

@Selinaky: I think it COULD work, if set up right. Thor: The Dark World is probably going to be set off earth entirely. They could have something that happens in that movie cause the cataclysm that destroys Bill's galaxy with him and his race leaving it as the post credits scene. I think it could be interesting and they don't NEED to make him like the comics where he has the EXACT same powers as Thor. I'm sure they could do it if they wanted too.

If they managed to make it work well I'd be very impressed. If done right it could be awesome, but as you said, I imagine the character would have to be a bit different than in comics. Would love to see BRB/ Thor team up against a villain!

Avatar image for jeanroygrant
#6 Posted by jeanroygrant (20442 posts) - - Show Bio

@Selinaky said:

I'm also a BRB fan, but somehow I can't imagine him in the films. I think people might get confused about him, and wonder why another Thor-like character is needed. Then again, they had War Machine in Iron Man 2. He'd need to be in Thor 3, and need a lot of screen time for Korbanites backstory, meeting Thor, getting Stormbreaker, fighting alongside Thor etc. I can't see it happening somehow... It would be awesome, though.

I'm curious about Balder, where is he?

Avatar image for powerherc
#7 Posted by PowerHerc (86171 posts) - - Show Bio

No.

He's to obscure, to odd looking and to similar to Thor in power.

Thus, it wouldn't make any sense to have him in a movie.

Avatar image for fodigg
#8 Posted by fodigg (6239 posts) - - Show Bio

If they had trouble bringing even Silver Surfer to cinema I think Beta Ray Bill would just be too weird. Which is a shame.

Avatar image for smart_dork_dude
#9 Posted by Smart_Dork_Dude (3366 posts) - - Show Bio

@PowerHerc: So you're saying that he shouldn't appear at all? I'd just be thankful if they had him show up. I wouldn't even care if they didn't give him Stormbreaker though lifting Mjolnir would be a must.

Avatar image for powerherc
#10 Posted by PowerHerc (86171 posts) - - Show Bio

@Smart_Dork_Dude:

Yep, that's what I'm saying.

Beta Ray Bill in a Thor movie is redundant.

Not to mention there are better characters to put in a future movie.

Avatar image for smart_dork_dude
#11 Posted by Smart_Dork_Dude (3366 posts) - - Show Bio

@PowerHerc: I see what you're saying, but isn't having War Machine in an Iron Man movie redundant? War Machine is just a grey and black Iron Man with a few extra weapons. I call his whole role in the movie fan-service since he wasn't even referenced in The Avengers.

Normally I wouldn't have brought this up, but with Marvel Studios going into Cosmic Marvel I couldn't help but think about the possibility of BRB making an appearance in a Thor sequel given how he IS a Cosmic character.

Avatar image for pyrogram
#12 Posted by Pyrogram (45407 posts) - - Show Bio

@Smart_Dork_Dude said:

@PowerHerc: I see what you're saying, but isn't having War Machine in an Iron Man movie redundant? War Machine is just a grey and black Iron Man with a few extra weapons. I call his whole role in the movie fan-service since he wasn't even referenced in The Avengers.

Normally I wouldn't have brought this up, but with Marvel Studios going into Cosmic Marvel I couldn't help but think about the possibility of BRB making an appearance in a Thor sequel given how he IS a Cosmic character.

I want BRB, I love him.

Avatar image for thegoldenone
#13 Posted by TheGoldenOne (38932 posts) - - Show Bio
@PowerHerc said:

No.

He's to obscure, to odd looking and to similar to Thor in power.

Thus, it wouldn't make any sense to have him in a movie.

Agreed.
Avatar image for powerherc
#14 Posted by PowerHerc (86171 posts) - - Show Bio

@TheGoldenOne: I'm glad someone else sees it the same way. Thanks!

Avatar image for thecannon
#15 Posted by TheCannon (20267 posts) - - Show Bio

Yes, it could work. I think Surtur should be in Thor 3, and I think going the EMH route could work.

Avatar image for the_thunderer
#16 Posted by The_Thunderer (3120 posts) - - Show Bio

@TheGoldenOne said:

@PowerHerc said:

No.

He's to obscure, to odd looking and to similar to Thor in power.

Thus, it wouldn't make any sense to have him in a movie.

Agreed.

Thirded.

Avatar image for thegodofthunder
#17 Edited by TheGodofThunder (693 posts) - - Show Bio

possibly http://www.figurerealm.com/viewcustomfigure.php?FID=39702

2676238-39702_1.jpg
Avatar image for omega_ray_jay
#18 Posted by Omega Ray Jay (8416 posts) - - Show Bio

I think its possible

Avatar image for deactivated-5791595859013
#19 Posted by deactivated-5791595859013 (1157 posts) - - Show Bio

Possible, but very difficult. BRB never made it as more than a niche fav in the comics and he would be extremely difficult to transition to film.

Avatar image for thorson
#20 Posted by THORSON (4500 posts) - - Show Bio

of course.

would be one of the first movie to show powerful entities.

Avatar image for thorson
#21 Posted by THORSON (4500 posts) - - Show Bio

@The_Thunderer said:

@TheGoldenOne said:

@PowerHerc said:

No.

He's to obscure, to odd looking and to similar to Thor in power.

Thus, it wouldn't make any sense to have him in a movie.

Agreed.

Thirded.

you all lack hope. such a petty... and tiny.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.