1-10, 1 being your favorite

1. For Tomorrow

2. All Star Superman

3. Superman Brainiac

4. Superman Annual #11

5. Action Comics #775

6. Kingdom Come

7. Superman Birthright

8. Superman Unchained

9. Superman Red Son

10. Superman H'el on Earth

I also really liked Men of Tomorrow, Death of Superman, and parts of Superman Doomed a lot

*** I edited my top ten because I read some other's top choices!!!

My un-ordered top 50 list.

1. All-star Superman

2. What's so funny about Truth, Justice, and the American Way.

3. Superman: Earth One Vol 1

4. Kingdom Come

5. Birthright

6. Secret Origins

7. For All Seasons

8. Superman Unchained

9. He'l on Earth

10. For the Man Who has Everything.

1) Kingdom Come

2) All-Star Superman

3) Superman Red Son

4) Superman Unchained

5) Superman Birthright

6) JLA: Shogun of Steel

7) Death of Superman

8) Superman: For the Man Who Has Everything

9) JSA - Thy Kingdom Come

10) Superman Brainiac

1. All-Star

2. Action Comics #775

3. Red Son

4. Birthright

5. Superman (vol.2) #179

6. Superman & The Men Of Steel (N52)

7. Brainiac

8. Action Comics #800

9. For The Man Who Has Everything

10. Ending Battle

I don't think that Kingdom Come counts as a "Superman story" (more like JSA/JLA story), but if it did, it would be in the Top 4.

Whether it's JLA or Superman is kind of vague to me. Because while Shogun of Steel has the JLA Title, Superman as a Samurai and his alternate origins is overwhelmingly the main character in the story. That's the only reason why I count it as such. Kingdom Come seemed similar, just because so much focus and time is on Superman and what his supporting cast have to say to him.

@beerminator1: I agree kingdom come was awesome but I've always considered it a JLA comic with Superman in a lead role

@diehard200904:

The whole point of the story revolves around Superman.

His effect on the world, his disappearance, re-emergence and his eventual character development. The Norman McCay sub-plot is relevant only to give Superman his emotional closure.You can't get more Superman specific than that.

A good Superman story is every story that you think did the character justice. No matter how much Superman actually is in it.

Birthright my all time fav

then seconded by Superman Secret Identity

1. Superman: Secret Origin

2. Kingdom Come

3. Superman: Brainiac

4. Death of Superman/Reign of Supermen

5. Superman: Redson

I'm sad that I can only list 5. Clearly, I need to read Birthright...

1. Earth One: Volume 1

2. All-Star Superman

3. Red Son

4. Birthright

5. Secret Origin

6. Sacrifice

7. For Tomorrow

8. Speeding Bullets

9. Unchained

10. Brainiac