Is Scarecrow's fear gas real?

Avatar image for redhood16
#1 Posted by RedHood16 (59 posts) - - Show Bio

I know that there is no drug that can make someone see and experience extreme hallucinations, like in Batman Arkham Asylum, but after watching the cartoon, seeing the films, and reading the comics, I HAVE to ask: Is there a type of drug/gas that is capable of exposing a person's fear(s)? Even if it is not EXACTLY like Scarecrow's gas, there could possibly be something realistic, due to the fact that Christopher Nolan's Batman universe relies on realistic things. So basically, if Nolan put Scarecrow's toxin in Batman Begins and The Dark Knight, surely there should be some realism in that, right?

Avatar image for batman_is_god
#2 Posted by batman_is_god (1192 posts) - - Show Bio

I think it would be possible in THEORY, as in Batman's cape in Batman Begins. That material does exist and could become rigid if a current went through it, but the part about a glove that can emit a current without killing the user is BS. So the cape works in THEORY, but it could not actually happen. I have no experience in pharmaceuticals, but I am sure you could find a way to justify the fear reaction. However, there would be limits in reality stopping it from becoming a weaponized aerosol. Let me know what you find.
Avatar image for redhood16
#3 Posted by RedHood16 (59 posts) - - Show Bio

thanks, I will.

Avatar image for lustwish
#4 Posted by Lustwish (537 posts) - - Show Bio

I think it is.  It is halucinagenic so...must be right? lol

Avatar image for lustwish
#5 Posted by Lustwish (537 posts) - - Show Bio

ill jump on that one too.....gotta be some evidence it could be real and does work. 

Avatar image for edamame
#6 Posted by Edamame (30285 posts) - - Show Bio

Interesting question.  There aren't any hallucinogens out there that are "terrifying".  Scarecrow's gas is just a stimulant. 

Avatar image for deadknight
#7 Posted by Deadknight (1042 posts) - - Show Bio

From what I've heard there are several hallucinogenic side-effects with almost any kind of hard-core narcotic, it probably just depends on the dose and the person it's used on. Maybe a bad form of MDMA (ecstasy) or LSD could get a particular person to experience some fearsome hallucinations.
Avatar image for jake_fury
#8 Posted by Jake Fury (21934 posts) - - Show Bio

I did a few ummmm.. "recreational" drugs back in the day that made me extremely paranoid.
Avatar image for redhood16
#9 Posted by RedHood16 (59 posts) - - Show Bio

Thanks, this is extremely helpful. Hopefully Christopher Nolan will one day respond to the question. LOL!

Avatar image for thecheesestabber
#10 Posted by TheCheeseStabber (8211 posts) - - Show Bio

there are drugs that cause horror like hallucinations but nothing for a personal fear as peoples fears are always changing or being confronted and fear is just a emotoion so there are probably drugs that make you afraid all the time but nothing pin poin accuarte like Scarecrows gas sadly...

Avatar image for foolkiller
#11 Posted by Foolkiller (191 posts) - - Show Bio

certain government funded programs are actually looking into the certain chemical/chemicals in the brain that cause fear. they're hoping to create some kind of weaponized version of this in case they ever need it. they are currently keeping everything top secret, but i do have some leads on what can cause fear symptoms.

Avatar image for nataliemartin
#12 Edited by nataliemartin (2 posts) - - Show Bio

I know this is a pretty old topic.. but a response anyway!

If someone were to ever create a 'real' fear gas, I would expect that it would have to come from the neurotransmitter within the brain that stimulates the 'fight or flight' response that we have when presented with danger. Specifically, a neurotransmitter/stress hormone called Norepinephrine. Norepinephrine, along with another neurotransmitter-- Epinephrine, are directly responsible for signaling that trigger to the brain. When released, blood pressure increases as well as heart rate, which releases glucose from energy stores within the body and also allows blood flow to skeletal muscles to increase.

As far as the hallucinations go, I would assume that the neurotransmitters would have to be sort of mixed with other hallucinogens that make us kind of flip out. LSD, for example. 

Anyway, yeah. That'd be my take on it. Isolating the trigger responsible for the chemical reaction of 'fear' in our brains, and mixing it up with a powerful hallucinogen like LSD.

Avatar image for innervenom123
#13 Posted by InnerVenom123 (29887 posts) - - Show Bio

Any "bad trip" would be the equivalent I assume. There is a reason people joke about LSD making the furniture want to eat you.

Avatar image for jimmyj
#14 Posted by JimmyJ (1 posts) - - Show Bio

I have theorized a way to make this 'gas'.  There are 2 main parts:
1) A herb or sage called 'Salvia Divinorum' is a recreation, legal drug that has been used for a while now. It causes a receptor in the brain called the 'D2 receptor agonist' to start a person subjected to salvia hallucinate. Salvorin A is the active ingredient within salvia and can be extracted through easy means. This chemical can some how be put into solution. When fully dissolved, you should find a way to vaporize the liquid salvorin A. After vaporisation, use air pressure to eject the liquid in a cloud like matter.   
2) The chemical Capsaicin is present amongst all hot chilli's and causes that burning sensation in the mouth. The capsaicin can be concentrated to different levels of heat measured on the Scoville scale. Capsaicin is found in pepper spray as the active ingredient. This can cause panic, claustrophobia, and people to flip out. Mix Salvorin A and capsaicin in a soluble liquid and vaporise it and eject it, and see what would happen when testing it on a person. As well as the induced hallucinations from the Salvorin A, the capsaicin would work with it to cause even more panic. Hallucinogenics can give people  bad trip, and when they start the bad trip, it is almost impossible to stop. They will see things that their sub conscious will put into their head. Using this formula in theory would cause an awoken nightmare. 
Thanks for reading.

Avatar image for scarecrow_number_2
#15 Posted by Scarecrow_number_2 (1 posts) - - Show Bio

I am just expanding on JimmyJ's post but I think if you mix Salvia, Shrooms and Capsaicin together it might work, Also maybe if you add some Nutmeg in there also, I am going to start Experimenting ASAP

I keep Ya'll posted :)

Avatar image for cormickco
#16 Posted by Cormickco (2 posts) - - Show Bio

@Scarecrow_number_2: Please do update on your results. I'd love to see if this 'gas' exist, even in a solid/liquid form. I also wonder if consuming this stuff actually works, or better yet, injecting. Imagine, You could literally scare the living shit out of someone...

Avatar image for cormickco
#17 Posted by Cormickco (2 posts) - - Show Bio

Okay. So after i spent a few hours researching i have found a way to create this 'fear gas' however it's only possible to do in a liquid/pill form which sort of impractical...

Avatar image for ram_reynoso02
#18 Posted by ram_reynoso02 (1 posts) - - Show Bio

could we share some notes..i've been doing some experimenting myself..i put the liquid agent in an atomizer..but i don't think the atomizer would do any significant damage because it only releases a small amount of the liquid agent..haven't really tested it on human subjects..just keeping my fingers crossed that i get robbed or something so i could try it out..:D

Avatar image for edwardwindsor
#19 Posted by EdwardWindsor (14563 posts) - - Show Bio

I did a module on drug action principles at university. I can tell you with 100% certainty know gases known to science at this point which are known to the general scientific populace ( maybe some dark agency/terrorist cell are working on biolical ware fare weapons somewhere) but no known gas will cause your to imagine you worst fears if enhaled absorbed in anyway. There are many types of gas that will cause visions but none that will always cause the same vision/effect across multiple victimes since they are subjective and dose related normally.

Avatar image for duke_nasty
#20 Posted by Duke_Nasty (1021 posts) - - Show Bio

I think I'd give it one try if it were real.

Avatar image for onemoreposter
#21 Posted by Onemoreposter (4335 posts) - - Show Bio

@RedHood16 said:

I know that there is no drug that can make someone see and experience extreme hallucinations, like in Batman Arkham Asylum

Incorrect. There are many.

Avatar image for Feartheliving
#22 Posted by FearTheLiving (7815 posts) - - Show Bio

Fear is produced in the brain I'm sure you could produce a gas that triggers that part of your brain. You wouldn't see strange creatures and what not but I'm sure you would still be pretty terrified.

Avatar image for jarradf
#23 Posted by jarradf (1 posts) - - Show Bio

There is one drug i can think of called Agent 15 or 3-Quinuclidinyl benzilate. Its kinda like the scarecrow drug but takes time to set in. It wont necessarily make you wet your pants in fear but i guess it could depending on what you hallucinate.

Avatar image for olivegrove
#24 Edited by OliveGrove (2 posts) - - Show Bio

If only there was some way to hormonally and neurally recreate, while in an otherwise 'awake' state, the experience of having a nightmare.

Avatar image for creepysocialsite
#25 Posted by creepysocialsite (1 posts) - - Show Bio

Myself and others have been gassed while at the Warren County Jail (Ohio). It caused extreme anxiety and confusion with other symptoms. This area of the country (southern Ohio) has much German lineage. The largest immigrant population in the U.S is German. Manipulating people's body chemistry is not clever. It is literally ape-like beings picking up substances from the earth's crust and putting it in someone else; all the while knowing it is so heinous you have to do it secretly.

"And mix not up the truth with falsehood, nor hide the truth while you know." (Holy Quaran 2:42)

"If you have to lie or hide the truth to get your way, what does that say about your way?" (Andrew Marr Haines)

Avatar image for dmtphobic
#26 Edited by dmtphobic (1 posts) - - Show Bio

The trips in Arkham Asylum were a lot like DMT trips, minus the elves [which weren't present in the game]. There's also a few substances [which I'm casually reading about not] that cause people to to be afraid.

DMT just alters your perception, but not your mood.

DMT + a fear gas = Scarecrow gas. You'll trip balls and be very very afraid.

Avatar image for joshmightbe
#27 Edited by joshmightbe (27412 posts) - - Show Bio

@redhood16: There are several drugs that make someone see and experience sever hallucinations, not to mention the millions of non medical or drug related chemicals that can cause hallucinations. Fear gas is probably one of the easiest of all comic book weapons to reproduce in the real world, if you could make an aerosol version of LSD you'd probably have something similar.

Avatar image for mohammedalkhater
#28 Edited by mohammedalkhater (209 posts) - - Show Bio


Avatar image for rossnrachel4ever
#29 Edited by Rossnrachel4ever (82 posts) - - Show Bio

Any psychotropic substance can make you see horrible things if you're not mentally strong enough to handle it. When you "trip" nothing you experience is out of your control, you just have to remember that. Believe me though, it's harder than it sounds.

Avatar image for travis_leans
#31 Posted by Travis_Leans (1 posts) - - Show Bio

Yeah bath salts

Avatar image for masterofrainbows
#32 Edited by masterofrainbows (1 posts) - - Show Bio

made an account just to answer with exstream fact's. no his gas is not real. but when a person gets scared a group of chemicals get produced in your brain and flow through your blood. using these exact chemicals at the right consistency and injecting them into the human body will make a person extremely approachable by fear if the person was sleeping during this time all there greatest fears would become reality in a dream I beleave these drugs could be real in the future since they are basic psychological chemistry. these drugs could be used in discipline or even torture.

Avatar image for mux
#33 Posted by Mux (1 posts) - - Show Bio

Well,slowly with my own research my cousin allowed me to extract (with help) the liquid which emits from 'fear' and trust me,it works a charm when the patient isn't suspecting it put back in...he was terrified for days...

Avatar image for tarsas
#34 Edited by tarsas (1 posts) - - Show Bio

i know this thread is old, but hypothetically, an anticholinergic could cause symptoms like fear gas does. they are found in flowers like foxglove and belladonna. there is also a kind of nerve gas that can occasionally induce extreme terror.

Avatar image for gr1m_r3ap3r
#35 Posted by GR1M_R3AP3R (1 posts) - - Show Bio

I don't know why it has to induce your worst fear, in Batman Begins, was Rachel's worst fear a freak riding an horse that can breath fire, no

Avatar image for Abishai100
#36 Posted by Abishai100 (1744 posts) - - Show Bio

Symbolism & Civilization: Absolute Quills

Actually, if Scarecrow simply put cyanide into Jell-O (in Gotham supermarkets), he'd still be the typical anti-social Scarecrow (a boogeyman), so there's nothing fundamentally necessary about the fear gax/toxin. However, you could, in theory, poison a city's reservoir with dangerous amounts of LSD (which would induce hysteria), so maybe Scarecrow's fear gas/toxin is more of a symbolic anti-establishment 'insult.'

Avatar image for Abishai100
#37 Edited by Abishai100 (1744 posts) - - Show Bio


Also, if you think about the fear gas as 'poison' instead of a 'weapon,' then conceptualizing poison as a material is pretty straightforward. I mean, a poison could most certainly be a gas (rather than pellets). However, LSD is a liquid, and cyanide (a poison) comes in pill form. Most likely, Scarecrow's fear gas/toxin is an allusion to LSD and an omen for taking dangerous amounts of LSD which would induce all kinds of hard-to-control hallucinations, so maybe Scarecrow represents not standard pharmacology but rather experimentation ethics. So in that sense, we're not supposed to take his toxicity as realism but rather as symbolism.

After all, isn't terrorism itself a kind of 'materialism poison?'


This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.