Comic Vine Review


The Punisher #5 - Blackout Review


Electro causes a massive blackout in Los Angeles and it's up to the Punisher to stop the Del Soles gang.

The Good

The latest volume of THE PUNISHER is slowly giving a little more depth to Frank Castle's new supporting cast, but honestly, this book shines because it highlights Frank doing what he does best. It's all about the anti-hero shooting very, very bad people and justifying why these terrible individuals deserve to be in Frank's crosshairs. It isn't really bringing anything new to the table -- this certainly isn't the first time Frank has been forced to face someone with powers -- it's just doing it all very well.

This time around, Nathan Edmondson kicks up the pacing as Dos Soles begins to execute its lethal plan. We get a swift reminder that the Howling Commandos are still hunting Castle and we see Sammy begin to change her ways, but really, this chapter's all about showing off Electro's powers and having Frank take aim at some goons. It may not offer too many new details about the A.I.M. plot, but the exciting pages turn this into a quick and incredibly enthralling read. Who doesn't enjoy seeing Frank fire at gang members or toss grenades at their cars? If you're one of those people, then I seriously have no idea why you're reading a Punisher book in the first place. On top of that, the cliffhanger doesn't promise anything new, but it's still completely thrilling and one of those moments that makes you beyond anxious to see what'll happen next.

I'm loving Mitch Gerads' pages. First and foremost, the focus on offering unique panels is more than transparent and it's most definitely appreciated. Little things like switching to the perspective of a nearby camera or showing the process of how Frank takes aim (as lightning cracks across the night sky behind him) and then switches to the view from his gun's sights is such an awesome and unique approach to the Punisher's world. The visuals are every bit as tactical as the vigilante himself and successfully make us appreciate Castle's methods. Lastly, pretty much every single scene with Electro generates some truly standout panels. They're vivid and full of spectacle, yet the colors never feel overbearing. Those panels are packed with energy. Oh, and isn't his cover ridiculously cool, too?!

The Bad

We know the gang is being manipulated, but it's still a little tough to swallow their plot. In a world where characters like Thor and organizations like S.H.I.E.L.D. exist, it's difficult to believe anyone could be crazy enough to think several united gangs could take over a major U.S. city and then hold their own against the variety of super intelligent and powerful heroes in the 616 universe that would come to remove them from power. We could chalk it up to arrogance and stupidity, but it's still a little difficult to accept. Also, a minor gripe: we're still being treated to a very, very slow burn with the Howling Commandos.

The Verdict

Edmondson and Gerads simply get the Punisher and continue to give us what we want to see. Sure, the story is moving a little slower than expected and a lot has yet to be answered or expanded upon, but they're producing a creative look at the way Frank Castle operates. The artwork is cleverly executed and, while it does move a few plot pieces forward, this latest issue basically exists to help us admire just how good Castle is at what he does. THE PUNISHER takes what we've come to expect from Frank and does it quite well. We've yet to really build a strong emotional connection to the supporting cast or get some of the finer details behind the villainous plot, but you know what? It's still a totally entertaining issue and oozes such a cool atmosphere. To top it off, the final page is guaranteed to make you pick up the next chapter.

Avatar image for manwithoutshame
Posted By manwithoutshame

I wasn't feeling this issue. This arc has been stretched to the limit in terms of length, and though I like ski mask look, overall I'm fairly unimpressed.

Avatar image for jonny_anonymous
Posted By Jonny_Anonymous

This issue was bad ass, I loved it.

Also I don't see a problem with the Howling Commandos, that's just a subplot being set up for the next arc, it's not like it needs to be resolved now.

Avatar image for beaconofstrength
Posted By BeaconofStrength

Great issue.

Avatar image for fenderxx
Posted By Fenderxx

Really enjoying this series !

Avatar image for millennium
Posted By millennium

will their plan some what makes since since 95% of the marvel heroes live, work and play in new york and rarely leave said city unless its to space

Avatar image for captainhoopla
Edited By CaptainHoopla

Good issue, I'm enjoying this series and this take on Frank so far. Looking forward to next issue, I'm wondering if the mag he's loading up at the end is the ammo Tuggs gave him last issue, likely Electro specials of some sort. I do hope the pace picks up a tad in the next arc.

Avatar image for ms-lola
Posted By ms-lola

This book keeps giving and giving. It's almost like a guilty pleasure with me because anyone who knows me would be shocked to discover me enjoying anything, even fictionally, with a no mercy vigilante. The story is tight, no stupid WTF moments to pull me out of it and as for The Howling Commandos, I think the pacing is just right. The amount of attention given to each member of the group intrigues me so I appreciate the slow burn.

Avatar image for ffstrat
Posted By ffstrat

Im a long time punisher fan but his personality seams a bit out of character at times. I get the sense pretty often that he is a happy go lucky Punisher that I have never seen before. I dont expect everyone to.hit the mark as perfectly as Garth Ennis but Im just not sure how I feel about this rendition yet. The art is good and its nice to see a super powered baddie for him to fight. I will continue reading this and look forward to see where this is all going. Im simply glad he has a solo ongoing to critique.