Comic Vine Review


The Punisher #3 Review


It turns out Dos Sols has Electro on their side. Good luck with that, Frank.

The Good

We're just three issues in and Nathan Edmondson's THE PUNISHER continues to be a blast. The writer's take on Frank Castle is a little chattier than what we've seen in other volumes, yet the essence of the anti-hero remains and it's all delivered with some great pacing. If you've been reading along (if not, go read #1 and #2 now, silly), then you know this issue's going to deliver some big action. Thankfully, Electro's treated with respect and doesn't become a total jobber when he's against Castle. The dude's a powerhouse and it's often his arrogance/foolishness that gets the better of him, but he's still a big enough threat that someone like Frank should have a tough time with him. Edmondson clearly gets that and, in a random encounter, let's just say it plays out how it should. It's not that long of a battle, but it's most obviously just a taste of what's to come and still pretty exciting.

There's also a bigger action bit in the end and, along with artist Mitch Gerads' work, watching Punisher run and gun against goons is a thrill. It's something we've seen him do a thousand times before, yet the style and creative use of perspective makes each shot impactful. His handling of said goons when he needs answers is a disturbing yet delightful moment as well. Once again, it simply rings true to the character and gives you a reminder of who you're dealing with.

The main narrative is moving along nicely (without giving too much away), but what's particularly interesting is how the story is impacting Sammy. It definitely seems like Edmondson has bigger plans for her and continues to give her a little more depth in each issue. I think many of us can see the path she's taking a mile away, but regardless, it'll be interesting to see how it all plays out and nice to have a supporting character potentially take a bigger role.

As stated above, Gerads' has a great style for this series. When things get dark and the action kicks into gear, it's effective and brutal yet never over the top. There's several great perspective choices that really lend a more cinematic approach. I especially dig the idea of having a couple of panels from Frank's view as he's stuck in combat. It gives you a little taste of the intensity and rush he's experiencing. One thing I truly appreciate is how much detail went into the car's interior during just one of the panels. It would have been so easy to make the background one shade and we still would have understood what's going on, yet each little aspect of the car's dashboard was in place. You can't help but appreciate the little things like that because it serves to further immerse us into the moment.

The Bad

The story with the Howling Commands is making a very slow progression. It almost feels like we're randomly chiming in on them just to remind us they're still attempting to follow Frank. I know we're only on the third issue, but at this rate, it seems like they won't come into play until the very end of this plot or they'll be saved as the conflict for the next arc. Additionally, it felt like one part of the restaurant scene was blatantly giving away a plot device that'll come into play down the road.

While I adore much of the pencils and colors, the meeting between Castle and Tuggs had a pretty jarring contrast. My eyes really weren't a fan of the shade of blue being surrounded by a very vivid magenta.

The Verdict

Edmondson and Gerads continue to prove they're an appropriate fit for the character. Castle's blunt and vicious mission remains firmly in place, yet a likable supporting cast and some legitimate charm gives the volume a nice sense of balance. There's plenty that'll appeal to longtime fans of the character and just enough established to help make it a refreshing and appealing experience to those who think the anti-hero is too one-dimensional. There's a whole lot of potential in this volume and watching it all unfold is plenty of fun. Welcome back, Frank.

Oh, and when are we getting a Loot and Pizza Dog crossover?

Avatar image for allstarsuperman
Posted By AllStarSuperman

Cant wait to read, the first 2 were awesome

Avatar image for jonny_anonymous
Edited By Jonny_Anonymous

I really like the way they show Franks competency with firearms, he actually holds and uses them correctly instead of just doing a tactical unload from the hip.

Avatar image for tensta
Posted By Tensta

I´m happy so far. Can´t wait to read it

Avatar image for manwithoutshame
Posted By manwithoutshame

This issue was as solid as the first two but then halfway through begins one of the best action sequences featuring the Punisher I've read in a long time. Killer stuff.

Avatar image for longbowhunter
Posted By longbowhunter

Another solid issue. While I like Edmondson's take on Frank, I'm really digging the supporting cast.

Avatar image for maddpanda531
Posted By Maddpanda531

Loving this series so far. Can't wait to read this issue

Avatar image for MadeinBangladesh
Posted By MadeinBangladesh

eh. I'm kindof losing interest. It seems like another comic with too simple plot.

Avatar image for thespideyguy
Posted By thespideyguy

I love this series. The best part is that the wait between issues is nonexistent.

I need to go back and read the last volume.

Avatar image for grenadeflow
Edited By GrenadeFlow

Another great issue

Avatar image for captainhoopla
Posted By CaptainHoopla

I'm enjoying this book. I officially added it to my pull list today. I do hope none of the supporting characters get killed off soon.

Avatar image for dreamfall31
Posted By dreamfall31

Liking it so far, but I'm gonna wait a few more issues until I decide to add it to my pull list!

Avatar image for fenderxx
Edited By Fenderxx

One of the best marvel, now , now titles , really caught me off guard, as i was never a huge punisher fan, but man sold series so far!

Avatar image for tomlikesfries
Edited By tomlikesfries

Solid issue. Edmonson's take on the Punisher differs from most other writers' such as Rucka and Ennis. It's a lot more wordy and isn't as grim and dark. That's not bad, I actually feel like that's been happening a lot as of late with other characters like Daredevil, who has also been having more of light time in the hands of Mark Waid.

Avatar image for mixmastamicah5
Posted By MixMastaMicah5

The action in this issue was great. I like the tactical approach they're taking with the relaunch.

Avatar image for jdp180
Posted By jdp180

eh. I'm kindof losing interest. It seems like another comic with too simple plot.

Yeah well the Punisher has never been known for having complex stories.

Avatar image for MadeinBangladesh
Posted By MadeinBangladesh

@jdp180 said:

@madeinbangladesh said:

eh. I'm kindof losing interest. It seems like another comic with too simple plot.

Yeah well the Punisher has never been known for having complex stories.

HAve you read Greg Rucka's Punisher? Or Punisher Max?