Comic Vine Review

58 Comments

Batman Eternal #1 Review

4

It all begins here. Because you can never have too much Batman (NEVER), the new weekly series is here and starts off with a bang.

The Good

There's some big and bad things headed to Gotham City. Batman can never be happy and Scott Snyder and James Tynion IV are setting things up to make sure that status quo sticks. The idea of a weekly Batman series seems daunting. We saw a glimpse in the recent BATMAN #28 and the first page guarantees a bad time for Bruce and Gotham.

One of the immediate nice things you'll notice is this series isn't going to be just about Batman. Sure, we all love the Dark Knight but he does have a few other books on the shelves. Seeing the Gotham City Police Department play a bigger role is a nice way to start out. You could even say the main character of this issue isn't Batman. It's no joke, things are getting shaken up. BATMAN: ETERNAL isn't going to be a throw away series. This is shaking up the Bat-Universe and it's going to be an exciting time.

Jason Fabok gives us a powerful intro to the series. There's a lot of big action and the characters look majestic. You'll find yourself pausing and hovering over each panel, taking in all the detail.

The Bad

Obviously with a weekly series, pacing will be a factor in the series. We can't get everything at once and this is setting up the series.

Part of the excitement in the developments in this issue were given away. We saw the "Thanksgiving" issue with a pretty big hint for what's in store for Jim Gordon. Also, seeing the Channel 52 spoiler in the back of all DC titles last week (and this week) takes away the intensity of the moment.

The Verdict

There have been some debating whether or not to get into the new weekly Batman title. If you're reading the Batman titles, you won't want to miss what is starting out here. Scott Snyder, James Tynion IV, and the others are ready to shake Gotham City to its core. This won't be a series you'll want to miss. The nice thing is it appears it won't simply focus on Batman. There are so many other great characters in the Bat-Universe as well and this could be a great way to give them the focus they deserve. This issue shows promise that the series will deliver deep stories and doesn't just try to entice you with gimmicks or insane explosions, although there are some really pretty ones here. Jason Fabok's art is killer here. It's a great time to be a Batman fan.

62 CommentsRefresh
  • 62 results
  • 1
  • 2
Avatar image for syncig
Posted By SynCig

I am so torn on this. I buy exclusively trades but I want to be able to experience this on a weekly basis. Batman is my favorite character and I love the Bat-family so this title has me all kinds of intrigued.

Avatar image for maddpanda531
Posted By Maddpanda531
Avatar image for syncig
Posted By SynCig

@maddpanda531: I'm probably gonna buy it on comixology after I get out of class

Avatar image for fil123
Posted By fil123

@syncig said:

I am so torn on this. I buy exclusively trades but I want to be able to experience this on a weekly basis. Batman is my favorite character and I love the Bat-family so this title has me all kinds of intrigued.

man same here, im a trades guy. But I downloaded comixology app just for this, worth it so far.

as a trades guy this series is perfect because I don't have to wait long to see what happens next (only a week)

Avatar image for the_stegman
Edited By The Stegman

Ugh...weekly, then again, it's Batman, so I have to do it.

Avatar image for lifeofvibe
Edited By lifeofvibe

im a trade guy but then i saw batman then i saw the price then thought batman and clan and then i thought all the hell with it im buying

Avatar image for allstarsuperman
Posted By AllStarSuperman

I am the party pooper, but the price for this alone is a gonna get expensive really quick.

Avatar image for syncig
Posted By SynCig

@fil123: Glad to hear you enjoyed the first issue. I'll be reading it later today. I am a trades guy only because of storage purposes. I don't have much room and it is so much easier and aesthetically pleasing to put trades on a shelf than to have boxes of issues sitting around.

Avatar image for manneffest
Posted By MannEffest

I'm going to trade wait… I can't afford another Batman title, especially weekly.

Avatar image for fallbrigade
Posted By fallbrigade

Enjoyed this. Personally, I'm not a huge huge fan of Fabok's art. It's pleasing to the eye, but everyone always looks so damn buff. Apart from that, I really enjoyed this and it felt like a great intro. So glad Bats' has a weekly, gonna be great!

Avatar image for theblueangel93
Posted By TheBlueAngel93

I seriously hope this doesn't become a necessary read to enjoy the main Batman series following Zero Year. I would love to pick this series up, but with it being both a weekly title and $2.99 per week...I just can't afford to keep up with that for 60 issues. v__v

Avatar image for manwithoutshame
Posted By manwithoutshame

I really liked this issue, and the direction the series seems to be going in. This was a better debut than last weeks Detective Comics IMO.

Avatar image for jonny_anonymous
Posted By Jonny_Anonymous

I hope to god that it's not Joker that in the book ends.

Avatar image for wolverine008
Edited By Wolverine008

I seriously hope this doesn't become a necessary read to enjoy the main Batman series following Zero Year. I would love to pick this series up, but with it being both a weekly title and $2.99 per week...I just can't afford to keep up with that for 60 issues. v__v

3751289-wayne.jpg

Avatar image for cerial442
Posted By cerial442

If I get this, I'll get it two months from now on Comixology when it goes down in price. I wonder how sales will go, a couple of months from now. Also if this is mandatory to catch everything up in the Bat Universe, why waste our time with Zero Year?

Avatar image for supbatz
Posted By SupBatz

Oh... I want to buy you so much. But I also want to have money for food... If only it were 1.99 per issue...

Avatar image for fallbrigade
Posted By fallbrigade

I seriously hope this doesn't become a necessary read to enjoy the main Batman series following Zero Year. I would love to pick this series up, but with it being both a weekly title and $2.99 per week...I just can't afford to keep up with that for 60 issues. v__v

I feel like it probably will. Snyder just mentioned that when he's done with Zero Year, this is the continuity he'll be coming back to.

Avatar image for silverpool
Posted By SilverPool

Why must I have to wait until December for this trade!!!?

Avatar image for theblueangel93
Posted By TheBlueAngel93

@war_killer said:

I seriously hope this doesn't become a necessary read to enjoy the main Batman series following Zero Year. I would love to pick this series up, but with it being both a weekly title and $2.99 per week...I just can't afford to keep up with that for 60 issues. v__v

I feel like it probably will. Snyder just mentioned that when he's done with Zero Year, this is the continuity he'll be coming back to.

Yeah I've heard him mention that, but Snyder also said that after Zero Year the next storyline he'll be doing is a short detective-style one before things start tying into Eternal. I just hope you can still enjoy Batman without having to read Eternal to understand everything that's doing on.

Avatar image for brione
Posted By Brione

I thought this issue was great. It didn't answer many questions that the Batgivings teaser left us with, but the action was awesome and I'm very intrigued by the story so far.

I think that the villain talking to Bruce in "The End" is either Hush or Lincoln March/Thomas Wayne Jr. I would be very surprised if it's the Joker. It didn't seem like the Joker's personality at all.

Avatar image for iaconpoint
Posted By iaconpoint

I'm excited about this. Was taking to a friend about the Spider-verse Sony is making and it dawned on us that more than any other character, Batman and his supporting cast could be a universe of their own, so I'm looking forward to all of that being explored.

Avatar image for captainmarvel4ever
Edited By CaptainMarvel4Ever

I would replace the word never, with always. Still it is his 75th year, so hpfully after this DC and WB will start to cut down on Batman.

Avatar image for lifeofvibe
Posted By lifeofvibe

@g_man: i just caught a glimps of the first page and i was like OH LORD WHAT HAPPENED!?!?

Avatar image for patrat18
Posted By patrat18

4.5/5

Avatar image for coleslaw893
Posted By Darth Coleslaw

I was heavily debating whether to wait for the trades for this series or not because of it being weekly, this is one of the cases I'm glad I didn't. I cant recall a more attention grabbing first page in recent memory.

Avatar image for syncig
Edited By SynCig

Just read the issue and I agree with the review. The art is excellent and the story has me intrigued for the future but it was definitely a set-up for what's to come. If the GCPD get a good portion of the spotlight like they did in this issue then I'll be very happy. Can't wait for all the Bat-craziness coming in this series.

Avatar image for righteous300
Posted By MrTummyTumms

Torn between getting this or waiting for N52: Future's End.

Avatar image for knightofthechronicle
Posted By knightofthechronicle

Really can't wait to get this. That first page? Completely and totally awesome!

Avatar image for jayc1324
Posted By jayc1324

This issue was awesome

Avatar image for kidchipotle
Posted By kidchipotle

I hope to god that it's not Joker that in the book ends.

@brione said:

I thought this issue was great. It didn't answer many questions that the Batgivings teaser left us with, but the action was awesome and I'm very intrigued by the story so far.

I think that the villain talking to Bruce in "The End" is either Hush or Lincoln March/Thomas Wayne Jr. I would be very surprised if it's the Joker. It didn't seem like the Joker's personality at all.

To be honest, I had assumed it was Catwoman since she was revealed to be the King Pin in issue 38.5

Avatar image for kidchipotle
Edited By kidchipotle

As people can tell, I am extremely critical of DC but this...I REALLY enjoyed this. Great stuff and looking forward to next week.

Avatar image for captainhoopla
Posted By CaptainHoopla

I'd love to read this. If DC had gone bi-monthly with it, I'd have found a way to make it work. Weekly though, no way I'm dropping four other books just to read this one. Props to DC for going with a $3 price though, that kinda surprises me.

Avatar image for brione
Posted By Brione

@arturocalakayvee:

It could be Catwoman, but she doesn't know Bruce's identity yet (maybe she will though) and I don't think that she's evil/crazy enough to burn down part of Gotham.

Avatar image for jayc1324
Posted By jayc1324

@captainhoopla: you can just wait until the graphic novel form of this comes out

Avatar image for grandharrier
Posted By GrandHarrier

I don't understand the bad. Because it's a weekly series? Or because it's a first issue (but a damn fine one at that!)

Avatar image for jwalser3
Posted By jwalser3
Avatar image for matteopg
Posted By MatteoPG

I looked at the first page and said: "Wow, I so know that this won't have any lasting ripercussion!"

Seriously, I was so passionate about superheroes like a couple of years ago, and then I noticed that they just do the same thing over and over and over... I can't get excited anymore.

Still, I am so happy, it opened so many more horizons for me, comic book wise. There are so many great original stories out there...

Avatar image for mak13131313
Edited By mak13131313

This was awesome!!!

Avatar image for obsidian_raindrop1
Edited By obsidian_raindrop1
Avatar image for hushofthewind
Posted By HushoftheWind

maybe the villain talking to Bats is a crazed out Dick Grayson after the events of Forever Evil.

Avatar image for brione
Edited By Brione

@hushofthewind

I hadn't thought of that. I hope not though because that would ruin Dick as a character, but it would make for an insane story.

Avatar image for dagmar_merrill
Posted By dagmar_merrill

I seriously hope this doesn't become a necessary read to enjoy the main Batman series following Zero Year. I would love to pick this series up, but with it being both a weekly title and $2.99 per week...I just can't afford to keep up with that for 60 issues. v__v

It's 52 issues, unless it is going on for more than a year now, which would be odd.

Avatar image for comedy_brosusa
Posted By comedy_brosUSA

ok, so I didn't read all of zero year(it was way too long and money consuming. I had that, my other DC titles, marvel titles, and forever evil+tie ins to buy) so can someone briefly explain what happened with Zero year and where Detective, Batman, and Eternal is taking off continuity wise? Thanks

Avatar image for knightofthechronicle
Edited By knightofthechronicle

All I'm saying is that Bruce's eyes in the first page looked yellow, which made me think of Scarecrow's fear toxin, but the flames might just be giving him that color. But considering Snyder and everyone else, it'll be someone new I'm sure.

Avatar image for maddpanda531
Posted By Maddpanda531

I won't be getting this until Saturday. It's painful, but I can twll by all of your reactions that it'll be well worth the wait.

Avatar image for the_tree
Posted By the_tree

@brione said:

I thought this issue was great. It didn't answer many questions that the Batgivings teaser left us with, but the action was awesome and I'm very intrigued by the story so far.

I think that the villain talking to Bruce in "The End" is either Hush or Lincoln March/Thomas Wayne Jr. I would be very surprised if it's the Joker. It didn't seem like the Joker's personality at all.

Agreed on Lincoln March. He was on the Chris Burnham variant to Detective Comics #27 for no apparent reason, but maybe it's actually to tie into what's going on here.

Avatar image for laabitres
Posted By laabitres

i hope they include batman inc characters in this

  • 62 results
  • 1
  • 2