mtharman's Red Skull #1 - Incarnate, Part 1 review

    Avatar image for mtharman

    The Red Skull, Nazi and puppy savior


    With Captain America: First Avenger hitting theaters by the end of this month, I would say that the start of Red Skull’s first limited series couldn’t hit the shelves at a better time.

    Nazi, murderer, and perfectly designed to be the most evil incarnation ever produced by Marvel Comics, Red Skull is a villain that does deserve to be recognized as Marvel’s first villain and possibly the most evil comic villain ever produced into comics. It’s obvious how Red Skull’s built character does force both artists and writers into a state of limitations because of his unique display cruelty that hides behind the Nazi symbol and surpasses the basic characteristics of comic-book villainy. Even though the anticipation that I had with this first issue of Red Skull’s blood-stained past did fulfill my expectations, there was one concept of this story that I felt to be on a start for redundancy.

    With famous villains such as Magneto, Dr Doom, and Kingpin, we see how their dark histories display them as men who are entirely not at fault for what they’ve become. Histories that are far more different from the Red Skull’s who rather see the world burn for the hatred that he developed during his childhood. Unlike the other villains who developed into their villain roles because of survival, revenge, and petty competition, Red Skull had no excuse for his evil acts beside the sheer enjoyment of bloodshed and murder. For Red Skull, I would say that he was an honest villain because of how he never relied on any excuse for his actions and how he came to be. Until reading this issue, you get to see the stepping stones of Johann Schmidt being forced into becoming one of Marvel’s most evil creations and possibly giving the infamous Red Skull an excuse for what he became.

    With both Marvel and DC usually giving the basic villain story that places them at a state of innocence, I would have to say that writer Greg Pak did successfully put some innocence into the Red Skull. Even though Red Skull was riding on a long blood-thirsty streak of carnage, from seeing how Marvel is forced into being limited on how they should display this villain, I would say that this attempted tear-jerking issue does tone Red Skull’s character down a bit to where he could be more understood.

    Without hesitation, I can easily say that Red Skull surpasses the perfect villain, which also isn’t a good thing seeing how Marvel has to limit his display of character. With this issue I would have to say that the “presumed” goal of having a better understanding of this blood-thirsty madman does fulfill itself. For both die-hard Red Skull fans and those who possibly are curious about him, I would say that this issue does present itself to be off on a great start.

    Other reviews for Red Skull #1 - Incarnate, Part 1

      Genesis of a Mad Man 0

      Red Skull is one of those villains that, although he's considered legendary in the Marvel Universe as one of its greatest villains, I honestly have trouble accepting him outside of the context of the war that created him.  That's a non-issue with Red Skull: Incarnate, as we see the coming of age of the man who would become Red Skull.  Whilst it's difficult to feel sympathy for someone who has done so much evil in his life, but thanks to a stellar first issue, readers can actually see the tragic ...

      2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

      A nice start to what could be a great series... 0

      If you've read Greg Pak's "Magneto: Testament" you already have a good idea what to expect from "Red Skull: Incarnate". It's a look into the past of arguably Marvel's most evil villain. In the Afterword, Pak states that this book "tells the story of a boy who becomes a monster". The first issue sets up this idea nicely.  Pak has no problem setting up the period on his pages and you can already tell a wealth of research went into the story. While Pak goes light on the dialogue, he artfully relay...

      1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.