I@serum said:
@JediXMan said:
@serum said:
why you deleted my post? ... the truth hurts .. Haa Haa Haaa ..
in the comics version cyclops wins .. but nobody respects the version of the comics .. film, television and video games, never respect the version of the comics and sell a thousand times more .. For this reason the comics version is obsolete and primitive
in theory, the comics is command.. but, in practice, nobody follows the version of comics.. for this reason the comics can not command and is not canon ..
I do not would spend my time reading a comic ...
I hope you do not delete my post . .the truth hurts .. but, you must respect the user messages
That's nice and all, but there's this little thing called "canon." As in, the source material. As in, the only thing that matters in debates as our friendly neighborhood mod has said. And if comics don't matter, then why did someone decide to make a movie or TV show out of them? And if the comics don't matter, then prey tell, why are you on a comics message board? Either accept it or leave. Now I suspect you will call me disrespectful as you did god_spawn. You've just met someone who does not care. Am I disrespectful? I don't try to be. But I'm not one to bend over backwards to avoid hurting someone's feelings. I state my opinions bluntly and without regret. EDIT: Oh I'm terribly sorry. You didn't say he was disrespectful, you said he was ungrateful. In that case, I have nothing to be grateful for. My post still stands.
The Comics, have importance .. Only to select the characters and the essence, then these elements are refined and improved to make it more realistic and interesting, more colorful, more exciting, a work of art, a show .. and sell millions of tons of millions (Smallville-series, Batman Arkham Asylum videogame, ps3, Spiderman-movie, Thundercats, cartoon, etc, etc)
The Comics is useful to select and edit content.
It is the essence and the idea written on paper .. is similar to a drawing of the architects to build a building .. The idea starts with the brain, then written on paper, then this idea materializes, light, sound, motion, graphics, emotions, and so on.
I see your point but the fact is that the battle fourm rules state when the OP does not state a specific universe we assume the default universes, and Cyclops and Wolverines default universe serial number is 616. The universe serial number for the video you posted is 92131, we are disscussing who would win in a battle in New york with 4 hours prep between the 616 versions of Cyclops and wolverine.
Now i understand and somwhat agree with your opinions that Animated and live action adaptions of the comics can often be supurior to the comics themselves, but if we were to debate with no regard for the comics we would get the Example below-
now In the cartoon X-men evolution Rouge does not have the power of flight but in the Orignal series she does, this means when debating who wins in say a battle between Rouge and Storm users cannot agree whether she can or can not fly. This is because while cartoons can be and often are a better source of entertainment then the comics they are not consistent because evrey cartoon series wants to tell it's own story about the said hero/heroine. It is because of this we do not usally include the cartoons movies and video games in our debates as they contain inconsistant information and facts about the characters.
im still editing i'll have time to fiinish soon.
If possible can all agree .. the creator of the topic should read the rules and versions of cartoon, movie or videogame .. the character can be of Smallville .. or perhaps cartoon X-Men 90's .. or perhaps evolution cartoon X-men .. or maybe Batman Arkham Asylum videogame version ps3 .. etc. .. this is determined by the creator of the topic ..
Log in to comment