Without a doubt I'd bring back K&Y's New X-Men and preserve most of the cast: Hellion, Dust, Rockslide, Mercury, Surge, Elixir, X-23, Anole, Pixie with cameos from the other students. Prodigy can show up eventually and bring along his buddy Speed.
My second choice would be All New X-Factor. I'd keep that cast, too, (i.e. Polaris, Quicksilver, Gambit etc) but I'd like to add Aurora to it. She rarely ever gets used well and Peter David is good at giving love to maligned characters. And imo Pietro and JM should hook up. haha
@poisonfleur: Well for me, the best comic out right now is Imperium from Valiant. So I suggest that. I would also suggest picking up the new Death Defying Doctor Mirage series from Valiant that started last month, and the Faith series that is about to drop. Pretty much anything you get from Valiant is going to be much better than the stuff that DC and Marvel is chugging out.
That being said, here are my other recommendations:
This is a Lovecraft style horror book that is amazing. Much better than Simone's Secret Six just because Avatar lets Moore have greater freedoms.
This just started, but it is quality for sure
Probably the biggest comic world building I have seen in a long time.
I Hate Fairlyand
This is really clever and creative
Really interesting Sci-Fi
Also amazing Sci-Fi
A Train Called Love
This is a raunchy comedy book, worth the money
Really interesting wiccan book.
We Can Never Go Home
Fun teenage adventure book that Bendis tried to get ANXM to be like (but failed horribly)
I never recommend Marvel or DC, since they are not doing so hot right now, but this is completely unique to the mold.
I have major nostalgia for this, since Spider Woman (1st volume), was the first full run I ever read (1-50).
@poisonfleur: Those are definitely not the only good titles. Black Magick is great. We Can Never Go Home, Providence, Mercury Heat, A Train Called Love, I Hate Fairlyland. Every single book Valiant puts out is gold. Paper Girls, Zoohunters, Darth Vader, Spider Woman, The Vision, InSEXTS, Dreaming Eagles, They're Not Like Us, Clean Room, Monstress, Plutona, Descender, and Red Thorn.
You just need to broaden your horizons outside of positive CBR reviews my friend.