Darthmat

This user has not updated recently.

101 39 2 11
Forum Posts Wiki Points Following Followers

Darthmat's forum posts

Avatar image for darthmat
Darthmat

101

Forum Posts

39

Wiki Points

11

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

#1  Edited By Darthmat

I went around to the #1 issues and collected the average user ratings for each issue (if want to see/use it yourself, https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AgFr1G4U0am1dHI5WTJhZGhMalpGdnF4NGVKYnhWU3c&hl=en_US#gid=0 )

Ordered by rating and then by title (the mean, median, and mode were all 3.8.)

Aquaman 4.7

Batman 4.7

Animal Man 4.6

Action Comics 4.4

All-Star Western 4.4

Batwoman 4.4

Swamp Thing 4.4

Batwing 4.2

Green Lantern: New Guardians 4.2

Justice League Dark 4.2

Nightwing 4.2

The Flash 4.2

DC Universe Presents 4.1

Detective Comics 4.1

Green Lantern 4.1

Wonder Woman 4.1

Batgirl 4

Demon Knights 4

Supergirl 4

Green Lantern Corps 3.9

I, Vampire 3.9

Teen Titans 3.9

Voodoo 3.9

Blackhawks 3.8

Catwoman 3.8

Deathstroke 3.8

Grifter 3.8

Justice League 3.8

Red Lanterns 3.8

Resurrection Man 3.8

The Savage Hawkman 3.8

Birds of Prey 3.7

Frankenstein: Agent of S.H.A.D.E. 3.7

Suicide Squad 3.7

Superboy 3.7

Blue Beetle 3.6

Justice League International 3.6

Batman and Robin 3.5

Static Shock 3.5

Batman: The Dark Knight 3.4

Men of War 3.4

Stormwatch 3.4

Superman 3.4

The Fury of the Firestorm 3.4

Red Hood and the Outlaws 3.3

Green Arrow 3.2

Legion Lost 3.1

Captain Atom 3

Mister Terrific 2.9

O.M.A.C. 2.9

Hawk & Dove 2.7

Legion of Super Heroes 2.7

Avatar image for darthmat
Darthmat

101

Forum Posts

39

Wiki Points

11

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

#2  Edited By Darthmat

I would add a 100s of Years ago category and place Demon Knights and All-Star Western there.

As for Aquaman and Green Arrow there is no indication that those take place in the past (to my knowledge).

The Savage Hawkman takes place now because he's clearly been Hawkman before.

Fury of Firestorm I'd put between 5 years ago and now.

Why doesn't Catwoman take place now?

Teen Titans and Superboy definitely both take place now.

Batman: The Dark Knight, Wonder Woman, The Flash, Grifter, and Blue Beetle should all take place right now. In TDK, his villains already know him. As for the rest, DC said everything should be taking place at the same time.

Detective Comics seems to be in between 5 years and now because Joker seems pretty new.

BUT it's totally awesome you initiated this. :)

Avatar image for darthmat
Darthmat

101

Forum Posts

39

Wiki Points

11

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

#3  Edited By Darthmat

@The Poet said:

@Darthmat said:

I wonder if Joker looks like that now.

no, thats not the Joker...that was the "Gothem Strangler" or the "Dollmaker" according to their discription of #3

At the end of Detective, it seems like Joker is getting some patchwork done to him.

Avatar image for darthmat
Darthmat

101

Forum Posts

39

Wiki Points

11

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

#4  Edited By Darthmat

I wonder if Joker looks like that now.

Avatar image for darthmat
Darthmat

101

Forum Posts

39

Wiki Points

11

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

#5  Edited By Darthmat

@DeathpooltheT1000: My bad. But reading that sent me into a rage.

Avatar image for darthmat
Darthmat

101

Forum Posts

39

Wiki Points

11

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

#6  Edited By Darthmat

@Samimista said:

I don't think I can pick just 10 die hard Beatles fan right here.

QFT

This is an impossible list to choose. I couldn't even choose what my favorite Beatles albums is.

Avatar image for darthmat
Darthmat

101

Forum Posts

39

Wiki Points

11

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

#7  Edited By Darthmat

@nightwing91@Dernman

To my knowledge, Midnighter is able to analyze his opponents strengths and weaknesses, making him awesome at combat. He could have detected MM's vital points and hit him at the perfect spot.

Avatar image for darthmat
Darthmat

101

Forum Posts

39

Wiki Points

11

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

#8  Edited By Darthmat

@labarith said:

Meanwhile Catwoman 1 involves CW literally raping Batman. Yup.

Yes. Selina Kyle is physically capable of raping Bruce Wayne.

She seduced him. Seduction is not the same as rape.

That scene, by the way, was incredibly hot. Not just because Selina and Bruce both have perfect bodies, but because Bruce Wayne went through back-bending and mind-breaking training for years to be in complete control of himself. Despite that training, though, Catwoman defeated Batman him and caused his natural impulses to win him over.

How many people in comics have been able to defeat him so quickly and completely? In any contest. Not many. That's what made it so great. Just because it had to do with sex doesn't make her accomplishment any less significant, nor does it make her actions non-consensual.

Avatar image for darthmat
Darthmat

101

Forum Posts

39

Wiki Points

11

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

#9  Edited By Darthmat

@Dernman said:

@nightwing91 said:

Demon Knights

Storm watch kind of made no sense to me especially considering.

Martian Manhunter claimed Apollo was the most powerful person on the planet, right after Apollo punched him as hard as he could in the face and Manhunter didn't flinch. And then Midnighter using a nerve strike on Manhunter knocking him out.

QFT all of it.

Based on his personality and the conversations he has, Apollo hasn't really received any formal training or tried to enhance his powers. MM could have been talking about his potential, but he hasn't yet reached what he can. MM has years of experience, so he's certainly had time to become strong enough to take a hit like that. But Midnighter attacked him at a vital spot, Apollo just threw a heavy swing.

Avatar image for darthmat
Darthmat

101

Forum Posts

39

Wiki Points

11

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

#10  Edited By Darthmat

@cyberninjasaid:

Alan Moore already won 35 minutes ago.

@JediXMansaid:

Moore's beard solos.

I don't think there's any room for disagreement after that.