why is this in the artists forums?

Back to the post at hand. Yes, John Dimaggio did a surprisingly good job as the Joker in Under the Red Hood, and would be a welcome successor to Mark Hamill

" Back to the post at hand. Yes, John Dimaggio did a surprisingly good job as the Joker in Under the Red Hood, and would be a welcome successor to Mark Hamill "

Dimaggio was good, he had a good Joker laugh but there were some moments I wasn't too sure of his Joker.  There's a lot to live up to with Mark Hamill who has really embodied the voice of the Joker, much like Conroy is the voice of Batman.  But I'll take Bender as Skywalker's replacement.

" @Emperor Gonzo Noir said:

" Back to the post at hand. Yes, John Dimaggio did a surprisingly good job as the Joker in Under the Red Hood, and would be a welcome successor to Mark Hamill "

(Thumbs up). I agree completely. I wouldn't mind if the Red Hood cast took over as the Batverse voices after Conroy and Hamill leave. "

Yeah, why not? He did a good job in UTRH

" @Caligula: Where should I post this? "

And thanks to all those who agree with me, i mean hey next he plays joker again just ask him to have a roller coaster ride with you see he could practice a crazy high laugh!

Mark Hamill is the definitive voice of Joker for me. 

Anyone else got a say, keep it coming!

He didn't do a bad job, but... (and there is a but) 
  
At times I felt him chanelling Ledger's Joker, whose version was way too somber for me; a deep menacing voice okay, but the face should reflect a bit of hysterics to temper Ledger's doom and gloom. 
 
Apart from the few moments where Heath showed up, I thoroughly enjoyed his portrayal 

I can see what you mean when you said that he was chanelling Ledger's Joker. I particularly heard it in the scene where he was eating chips in front of Black Mask.  
 
I think he's pretty good. He's no Hammil, but nobody can be as perfect as he was ;)

For the record dimaggio wasn't trying to be like anyone else's joker, he was trying to be his in joker like all those other actors were!

Abso-Freakin-Lutely
 
John DiMaggio so far has gotten the closest to be like Mark Hamill's Joker while at the same time making it his own.  With Mark Hamill retiring, he is the perfect person to go too.
 
Same goes for Bruce Greenwood, who is ON PAR with Kevin Conroy in my opinion. Kevin is still a great Batman voice and the voice I think of when I think of an animated Batman, but Bruce Greenwood has this solid snake thing going on that I totally dug. I actually (Don't send me so many hate messages) like Bruce Greenwood's voice just a tad bit more then Kevin Conroy's. 
 
But yes, I'd love to see John DiMaggio return...maybe in that new TV show, Young Justice.

For the record, I'd also like to point out that Neil Patrick Harris was an awesome Nightwing.... 
 
Thinking back, that whole movie was great in terms of voice acting :)

Now, How about Kari Wahlgren as charmcaster?

I don't mind John DiMaggio's voice for the Joker, but it's just not something I like. Mark still has the best Joker voice as well as laugh to me and it may be a while before anyone beats him out.

like she said once before, before john does joker again just take him on a roller coaster ride to practice his crazy laugh and he'll be even better. 
 
anyway back to your question on kari wahlgren as harley quinn... I think she'd be a great harley.

wait Mark hamill is retiring the Joker?........NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!

" Dimaggio was good, he had a good Joker laugh but there were some moments I wasn't too sure of his Joker.  There's a lot to live up to with Mark Hamill who has really embodied the voice of the Joker, much like Conroy is the voice of Batman.  But I'll take Bender as Skywalker's replacement. "

I've always been a huge fan of Mark Hamil's voice work as the Joker in Batman: The Animated Series but, John DiMaggio was also decent  as the Jokerin Under the Red Hood.  They're both good and I believe that DiMaggio would make a good successor to Mark Hamil.

I liked his voice in Under the Red Hood.

" For the record, I'd also like to point out that Neil Patrick Harris was an awesome Nightwing....  Thinking back, that whole movie was great in terms of voice acting :) "

 But yes, I'd love to see John DiMaggio return...maybe in that new TV show, Young Justice. "

No he did not did we'll. don't get me wrong his voice is okay but didn't have a perfect joker tone. I mean he suppose to be homicidal maniac and did not sound insane.

Absolutely. DiMaggio's Joker was the perfect mix of scary and funny. I'm surprised we haven't seen him again since UtRH.

John dimaggios the worst joker. They made him more like jack nicholson and Heath ledger. I just wish jack nicholson or hamill could voice as joker

I think he did really good in Under the Red Hood, so I agree with OP.