I was surprised no one went with the New 52 Joker without a face. (That sentence reminds me of "Eyes Without a Face").

I think Buccellato's was the closest to New 52 Joker. Plus, it had Bat-bear. What surprised me was no one else did that!

I thought Nauck absolutely killed it. Hands down. Though Buccellato had the nice touch of putting the teddy-bear in a Bat-Suit. Still, gotta give it to Nauck.

Love how McKone dove straight in with a Sharpie.

@G-Man did you do one for NYCC?

@G-Man: I was hoping someone would draw a teddy bear wearing the Joker face skin.

Imho, Buccellato and Nauck win this challenge with the best ideas and drawings: A Bat-Bear and a knife to the throat. Nauck's bear looks pretty cool, too. Gomez comes in third.

Gomez took it to a dark place and I loved it

@Dbennett6684 said:

Gomez took it to a dark place and I loved it

Yeah, I don't think Ive ever heard of him, but I really like his style.

I think some of these new guys didn't know what to do. You guys should have told them to be as creative with the idea as possible.

I loved this

@G-Man said:

I was surprised no one went with the New 52 Joker without a face. (That sentence reminds me of "Eyes Without a Face").

Awesome, I love the Mystery Art Challenge, and Billy Idol.

this is awsome i actually almost as good as this guy

todd nauck destroyed this challenge.

@xtremekidx: With Spider-Man. http://www.comicvine.com/nycc-2012-mystery-art-challenge-spider-man-and-a-zombie/112-1969/

Todd Nauck was my favorite. I still do not like Dustin Nguyen art. He made Heart of Hush hard to read for me. Also, it looked like he was the only one that erased lines. Sean Galloway was terrible.

Oh no, Nauck's Joker has gotten a hold on Ted! On a side note I was impressed by how McKone just went straight to inks for his piece. For me, the win is a tie between Nauck and Booch, though I did like the darkness of McKone's and Height's too. Awesome works in general!

@mpierce2690 said:

I thought Nauck absolutely killed it. Hands down. Though Buccellato had the nice touch of putting the teddy-bear in a Bat-Suit. Still, gotta give it to Nauck.

Todd totally killed it on this one! I love these challenges. I had 2 ideas on this one. the one you see here and Joker with a teddy bear version of Harley. I'm sorry I missed the NYCC's Spidey and a zombie :(

Wow, you guys really burned threw all your open source music on this video hahah.

Loved the Teddy Bear with the knife trying to attack Joker and the last one that had Joker biting the bear. Awesome Artists!

@B_Heart: @B_Heart: Don't worry, I have more.

I love the mystery art challenges.

The music playing over Sean "Cheeks" Galloway's bit was quite frankly un-BEAR-able.

@G-Man LOVE these art challenge videos! And Tony, man, I still think your sketch books will be worth a LOT of money 10,15, 20 years from now! Hold on to them!!

meh on the first, second, third, and seventh. fourth alot better :D. fifth, guess its ok. sixth was funny.

I never watch these art challenges because watching pros draw reminds me of how I have zero artistic talent. Having said that this is a pretty neat feature. I'm surprised there are still artists out there who think the Joker should be rocking the Ducktailed hair. Great job Tony! Take a vacation or something you crazy guy.

needs more pineapples! lol

@Bestostero:

These are my favourite videos (:

Todd and Brian took this challenge i.m.o., loved the color brian put in.