In my opinion the best animated Joker performance is Mark Hamill's. But I'm torn between which performance is better "Mask Of The Phantasm" or Return of the Joker". I'd like everyone to rank every animated Joker performance including TDKR, Under The Red Hood and others.

My opinion

1- Mark Hamill

2- John DiMaggio

3- Michael Emerson

Feel free to bring up any others. I know I left some out including Young Justice and Brave and the Bold. Fell free to add them.

I think Hamill is top overall performance.

However, I think DiMaggio showed he would make a worthy successor with Under the Red Hood.

bump

Mark Hamil in his Justice League appearances remains unmatched. Wild Cards is probably my favorite. I also liked Kevin Michael Richardson (I might be the only who liked that Joker in general) and, more recently, Troy Baker.

Mark Hamill