logan or scott ?
I just found some old comic books and saw emma saying logan was the true jean's love
and why she had some thoughts of him ? like a sexual desire for him ?
Got confused a lot
at end jean loves really scott or logan ?
logan or scott ?
I just found some old comic books and saw emma saying logan was the true jean's love
and why she had some thoughts of him ? like a sexual desire for him ?
Got confused a lot
at end jean loves really scott or logan ?
@imfxlix: I agree
Also, Jean and Scott were best friends while Logan and Jean were opposites in many ways. So to me it was a different type of attraction.
IMO her "true love" was Scott.
I stopped reading x-men books some years ago (2010 I guess) so I'm probably kinda no idea on what is going on right now
in her appearences during the last years she has shown love to scott or logan ?
currently she still loves logan ? and what about scott ?
@jeanandscottlove: curious what you mean by currently
Scott and Jean were true loves.
Jean died repeatedly and got taken over by cosmic entities.
Scott was taken over by apocalypse and Jean refused to give him what he needed.
Enter Emma. Emma psychically manipulates Scott but also fills a void in his life that jeans emotional flippancy was causing.
Not super clear what happened next so don't quote me, but pretty sure jean dumps Scott then dies, may have hooked up with the midget. Emma becomes everything jean should have been and more. Pretty much like ten years of them having a badass and real relationship.
Enter the Phoenix, Emma has a psychic affair with namor. Scott steals her power, chaos chaos chaos. They break up. Scott dies. Emma Mia.
In the comics remember Logan Is 5'2 and hairy. Jean wouldn't give the midget a second look.
@killraven4334: Call me dumb but I really don't understand you at all
What exactally he "needed" ?
so did jean ever have sex with logan ?
And even after scott had a thing with emma did jean still love him or moved on from him to wolverine ?
I think she loved Scott, but was attracted to Wolverine.
Scott loved Jean / Jean loved Scott
Wolverine loved Jean / Jean liked Wolverine
Wolverine was just obsessive about Jean, although her attraction to him seemed purely base. She and Scott had an actually meaningful and deep relationship but writers and fans prefered situating her with Logan because they thought he was cooler than Scott, and thusly deserving of the girl.
@jeanandscottlove: why would I call you dumb buddy? It's a complicated situation. The real, adult jean, is dead and gone (for the moment) I can't say for certain that she never hooked up with Logan, but they were never together. As far as I know there might have been one psychic kiss. Emma was Scott's true love as Scott became the leader he was destined to be. The Scott of the early x men is long gone, it's arguable he died to apocalypse.
The Scott that returned set us on the path that lead to his presumed death.
@killraven4334:but what about jean's feelings ? did she love him till the end or moved on ? I just got confused cause
@ilostthekey: just got confusec cause while reading fatal attractions it's said jean loves logan
@jeanandscottlove: I think the issue is they both changed. I have no doubt that jean and Scott loved eachother to the very end. But just loving someone isn't enough, you have to be compatible. Emma understood Scott and his inner darkness better than jean ever could. It's why emma was the one to "fix" scott. Giving him full albeit temporary control of his powers.
Cyclops is Jeans true love. No question about it. Logan is a lust.
Kidchipotle sums it up pretty well.
I never read Fatal Attractions, but I can only assume that that was the way the writer interpreted their relationship. It doesn't make him right, or make it true, since the relationship existed before him. Wolverine is just someone she lusts after. I see Jean's perspective as like: if you were married and you loved your husband, but you ran into David Beckham you'd be attracted to him. But for Jean it isn't just a one off thing. Her Beckham is also her co-worker, and they're intimately involved on a daily basis. Wolverine also lusted over Jean as much as she did over him, but the reason they couldn't be together was because Scott was there, and Scott was a man she loved. Over time Wolverine's affections were made out to be more than lust, but it doesn't change the fact that Jean didn't reciprocate that sentiment.
@koays: Wasn't she about to bang him(Logan)?
@ilostthekey: "loved" ? in the past sense ?
@cobracommander: really ? so does this means she loved logan and sttoped loving scott ?
@jeanandscottlove: Yep, she's been dead for a while. Although Scott still loves her.
@jeanandscottlove: I don't get what you don't understand... And I don't mean that in a mean way. You're overthinking this. Everyone summed it pretty well!
@koays: Wasn't she about to bang him(Logan)?
but logan said no and it would never work out between us
@koays: Wasn't she about to bang him(Logan)?
but logan said no and it would never work out between us
After Cyclops was going through his "Post-Apocalypse/Celibacy" period
@masterofevil: Or maybe it's death...
@koays: No joke, whenever someone else has the Phoenix, Jean's in White Hot Room like "You're inside him/her, but ya STILL thinking of me!"
@koays: Wasn't she about to bang him(Logan)?
but logan said no and it would never work out between us
After Cyclops was going through his "Post-Apocalypse/Celibacy" period
lol no his looney toon period
Jean Grey's one true love is the Phoenix. Ya really can't keep them apart.
the phoenix loves jean not the other way around
@ms__omega: I approve of this.
I don't think there is such a thing as one true love, but I think Scott and Jean are a much better match.
@killraven4334: No Jean died and we seen a flash forward of the future when Jean returns to life and everything was decimated because Scott was heartbroken and couldn't lead the xmen so she pushed Cyclops to get with emma using her powers to do so
@kgb725: I mean if there was a retcon later or post event explanation than I wouldn't know about it. I'm just talking about how it happened as it happened.
@killraven4334: That's how it happened
@kgb725: maybe later on that's what they said. But I have every issue of x-men (not uncanny) and from cyclops return forward I am pretty much certain that as it happened jean was pretty pissed about it, and certainly not hoping he chose emma. But if I'm wrong please point out the issue and I'll reread
@kgb725: I'm not sure if we are talking about the same issue but I remember reading something like this, but at end we see jean and scott getting married (I odn't remember very well what happened so I'm not how they did get married there) could you please tell me what issue this happens ?
@killraven4334: really ? we see Jean pissed about the idea of scott choosing emma after she died ? could you tell me where this happens ?
@jeanandscottlove: Scott got with emma before jean died. I even posted a scan of jean attacking emma over it
@kcomicfan said:
Scott.
This and it is not even close.
@krleavenger: What do you mean by "it is not even close" ? do you mean Scott is not her true love ? could you explain ?
@jeanandscottlove: I ment Scott is her true love and Logan is not even close to him.
Phoenix is obsessed with jean.
Jean loved scott
Jean had feelings for logan.
Scott loved jean.
Emma admitted that scott wont be able to love her as much as he loved jean.
Emma is subtly obssesed with scott.
Jean and Scott have been involved with each other since the first launch of the X-Men comics. Wolverine and Jean have a flirty relationship but they wouldn't have a family kind of relationship. As much as I find the Scott and Jean relationship undeniably shallow, you still just see how much they care for each other. Jean Grey wanted to kill herself when Scott died died. She would rather die than live in a world without Scott. She cares about Wolverine and Wolverine loves her more than anyone (He loves Rogue, Kitty and Jubilee in a father-daughter kind of way) but these two will never get together. Some people tend to forget that the girl flirts with the bad boy, but they stay with the nice guy. Yeah, she will find the bad boy attractive but she wouldn't exactly want to spend her entire life with him. They want to spend their entire life with the nice guy who could give her a family life. The only time I ever saw Wolverine as a family man is in Old Man Logan (Which is a really excellent story arc!) but in none others. I will admit that Scott treats Wolverine like shit all because he is in love with his girl but he shouldn't be so harsh. However, Scott is Jean's true love, no matter how much you would hate the character (I do).
@jeanandscottlove: You have to be a troll at this point.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment