Avatar image for higher_evolutionary
#1 Posted by higher_evolutionary (2128 posts) - - Show Bio

in my opinion Ed McGuinness is far better in his art hardman everyone looks kinda wierd and smurky
i'd prefer Ed McGuinness doing the art for hulk

Avatar image for movieartman
#2 Posted by movieartman (1886 posts) - - Show Bio

ed is the better of the 2 
but id really prefer that Carlo Pagulayan was the continule artist on it more than both of em  
his work on Hulk #34 came out yeasterday was fantastic

Avatar image for sc
#3 Posted by SC (17040 posts) - - Show Bio

Eh depends really. The tone of the story. Darker, grittier, more emotional stuff? Hardman. Ed for the bright, fun, loud stuff. 

Moderator
Avatar image for higher_evolutionary
#4 Edited by higher_evolutionary (2128 posts) - - Show Bio
@movieartman: yeah his work on 34 sure is amazing
 
side note: does anyone know why am i limited to 5 posts a day ???
Avatar image for sc
#5 Posted by SC (17040 posts) - - Show Bio
@higher_evolutionary:  
 
Ah sorry about that. Its a spam prevention rule/limit. Once your post count is higher or after a day or two, you should be able to post without floodgate. 
Moderator
Avatar image for panelbomber
#6 Posted by Panelbomber (37 posts) - - Show Bio

Have never been much of a fan of Ed McGuiness, characters are a bit too ripped and bubbled for my taste. Hardman has nice classic super-hero artwork.

Avatar image for maki_p
#7 Posted by Maki_P (296 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm in love with Hardman's art in Hulk, it's so pretty and artistic, specially in the Omegex arch. Rulk looks kinda huggable under his pen, and I love it

Avatar image for powerherc
#8 Posted by PowerHerc (86171 posts) - - Show Bio

McGuinness for the win!

It's not even close.

Avatar image for kingoftheworld
#9 Posted by kingoftheworld (341 posts) - - Show Bio

Hardman.

Avatar image for fredexmuia
#10 Posted by FredexMuia (8 posts) - - Show Bio

Ed is way better than hardman

Avatar image for catpanexe
#11 Edited by CATPANEXE (9505 posts) - - Show Bio

Hardman for Red (I love that they're taking it seriously enough to even try and phase out the Rulk moniker). McGuinness is larger than life and iconic, but in this case Harman's art give the character the serious tone it sorely needed to redeem it, so it works. Maybe this is also because of the writing it's compounded with adding to the effect, I'm not sure.

Avatar image for thegoldenone
#12 Posted by TheGoldenOne (38932 posts) - - Show Bio
@SC said:
Eh depends really. The tone of the story. Darker, grittier, more emotional stuff? Hardman. Ed for the bright, fun, loud stuff. 
Avatar image for degraaf
#13 Posted by DEGRAAF (8400 posts) - - Show Bio

any pictures to judge off of?

Avatar image for Trodorne
#14 Posted by Trodorne (2770 posts) - - Show Bio

@Panelbomber said:

Have never been much of a fan of Ed McGuiness, characters are a bit too ripped and bubbled for my taste. Hardman has nice classic super-hero artwork.

This

Avatar image for wavemotioncannon
#15 Posted by WaveMotionCannon (7473 posts) - - Show Bio

Ed FTW

Avatar image for micahparadise
#16 Posted by micahparadise (783 posts) - - Show Bio
3420035-3731361581-HULKT.jpg

Definitely Ed McGuiness. He brings the SUPER to super heros with his exaggerated muscles and fun feel

Avatar image for jake_fury
#17 Posted by Jake Fury (21939 posts) - - Show Bio

Hardman for me and by far. Not a fan of EM's work.

3420326-9404414041-141642.jpeg

Hardman needs more mainstream work.