• 79 results
  • 1
  • 2
Avatar image for degraaf
#1 Posted by DEGRAAF (8402 posts) - - Show Bio

I have been thinking about this for the passed cople of days and i cant figure it out. i know more aboout supreman than i do green lantern but to be chosen by the ring of the green lanterns you must have a pure heart and soul or something like that but when they talk about superman it seems like you couldnt get more pure so i will ask again,

why hasnt superman ever become a green lantern or any other color lantern for that matter?

Avatar image for nighthunter
#2 Posted by Nighthunter (29571 posts) - - Show Bio

he has been a green lantern

and I say he could easily be a blue lantern

Avatar image for djinn
#3 Posted by Djinn (864 posts) - - Show Bio

i really dont know about the dc comcis but it might be because superman is already very powerful and people are complaining about him beign to powerful and to give him a ring would make fans that think that not so happy, but i dont know


Avatar image for methos
#4 Posted by Methos (40531 posts) - - Show Bio
DEGRAAF said:
to be chosen by the ring of the green lanterns you must have a pure heart and soul

um.... no....

to be chosen as a ring barer of the Green Lantern Corps you have to show that you can overcome true fear and have pure Willpower....

there are a couple of other requirements like Honor and the ability to do the right thing, but the ability to overcome True Fear and Willpower are the two big ones

M
Avatar image for methos
#5 Posted by Methos (40531 posts) - - Show Bio

oh, also, the GL Corps already has a Sodamite called Daxam Yat... wait, no, a Daxamite called Sodam Yat.... he's basically a Superman clone anyway, he;'s just missing the personality lol

M

Avatar image for stormamazonpheonix
#6 Posted by StormAmazonPheonix (285 posts) - - Show Bio
DEGRAAF said:
"I have been thinking about this for the passed cople of days and i cant figure it out. i know more aboout supreman than i do green lantern but to be chosen by the ring of the green lanterns you must have a pure heart and soul or something like that but when they talk about superman it seems like you couldnt get more pure so i will ask again,

why hasnt superman ever become a green lantern or any other color lantern for that matter?"

Because that would make him, even more of an over powered retard.
Avatar image for sunman
#7 Posted by SUNMAN (7805 posts) - - Show Bio
StormAmazonPheonix said:
"DEGRAAF said:
"I have been thinking about this for the passed cople of days and i cant figure it out. i know more aboout supreman than i do green lantern but to be chosen by the ring of the green lanterns you must have a pure heart and soul or something like that but when they talk about superman it seems like you couldnt get more pure so i will ask again,

why hasnt superman ever become a green lantern or any other color lantern for that matter?"

Because that would make him, even more of an over powered retard."
best post on this thread
Avatar image for stormamazonpheonix
#8 Posted by StormAmazonPheonix (285 posts) - - Show Bio

Thanks for that, man.

Avatar image for bumnut
#9 Posted by bumnut (1847 posts) - - Show Bio
Methos said:
"oh, also, the GL Corps already has a Sodamite called Daxam Yat... wait, no, a Daxamite called Sodam Yat.... he's basically a Superman clone anyway, he;'s just missing the personality lol

M
"

"sodomite" that sounds so wrong lol
Avatar image for sunman
#10 Posted by SUNMAN (7805 posts) - - Show Bio
bumnut said:
"Methos said:
"oh, also, the GL Corps already has a Sodamite called Daxam Yat... wait, no, a Daxamite called Sodam Yat.... he's basically a Superman clone anyway, he;'s just missing the personality lol

M
"

"sodomite" that sounds so wrong lol"
*sigh* get your head out of the gutter
Avatar image for bumnut
#11 Posted by bumnut (1847 posts) - - Show Bio
SUNMAN said:
"bumnut said:
"Methos said:
"oh, also, the GL Corps already has a Sodamite called Daxam Yat... wait, no, a Daxamite called Sodam Yat.... he's basically a Superman clone anyway, he;'s just missing the personality lol

M
"

"sodomite" that sounds so wrong lol"
*sigh* get your head out of the gutter
"

*sigh* o.k. boss ;-)
Avatar image for atphantom
#12 Posted by AtPhantom (14434 posts) - - Show Bio

I believe they explained that with the fact that Superman is not native to sector 2814, and therefore cannot be a lantern in it. But since he lives on Earth he cannot be a lantern of the sector Krypton was in either.

I think this relatively makes sense.

Avatar image for strongestonethereis
#13 Posted by StrongestOneThereIs (7064 posts) - - Show Bio

Cause he doesn't need to be. He is powerful enough to smack around those green policeman.

Avatar image for degraaf
#14 Posted by DEGRAAF (8402 posts) - - Show Bio
Nighthunter said:
"he has been a green lantern

and I say he could easily be a blue lantern
"
i know they have shown him being a green lantern before but i mean like main conintuity long period of time type of green lantern
Djinn said:
"i really dont know about the dc comcis but it might be because superman is already very powerful and people are complaining about him beign to powerful and to give him a ring would make fans that think that not so happy, but i dont know

"
yea but that would make me think that they would want him that much more to have a suped up super being on their side with little to hurt him that much more.Methos said:
"DEGRAAF said:
to be chosen by the ring of the green lanterns you must have a pure heart and soul

um.... no....

to be chosen as a ring barer of the Green Lantern Corps you have to show that you can overcome true fear and have pure Willpower....

there are a couple of other requirements like Honor and the ability to do the right thing, but the ability to overcome True Fear and Willpower are the two big ones

M
"

lol yea thats why if you quoted the rest of it you would see i say "or something like that" and "that i know more about superman than i do green lantern" but all the requirements you listed superman has alsoMethos said:
"oh, also, the GL Corps already has a Sodamite called Daxam Yat... wait, no, a Daxamite called Sodam Yat.... he's basically a Superman clone anyway, he;'s just missing the personality lol

M
"
if that is the case i would like to see more of him.StormAmazonPheonix said:
"DEGRAAF said:
"I have been thinking about this for the passed cople of days and i cant figure it out. i know more aboout supreman than i do green lantern but to be chosen by the ring of the green lanterns you must have a pure heart and soul or something like that but when they talk about superman it seems like you couldnt get more pure so i will ask again,

why hasnt superman ever become a green lantern or any other color lantern for that matter?"

Because that would make him, even more of an over powered retard."

good point except for the fact that imo hes not a retard and it never hurts to have more powerAtPhantom said:
"I believe they explained that with the fact that Superman is not native to sector 2814, and therefore cannot be a lantern in it. But since he lives on Earth he cannot be a lantern of the sector Krypton was in either.

I think this relatively makes sense.
"
see this makes senseStrongestOneThereIs said:
"Cause he doesn't need to be. He is powerful enough to smack around those green policeman. "
yea but like i said earlier it never hurts to have more power


Avatar image for speedlgt
#15 Posted by speedlgt (2138 posts) - - Show Bio

well Hal jordan is a total prick maybe thats why hes a good gl cause he dont give a dam about anything so he does fear anything...superman has some fears like loosing his loved ones which seems to be a constant threat so maybe thats why the ring doesnt choose him.

But in terms of will power I say hes totally got that down hes been through alot and carried the weight of the whole universe and always come out on top so hes not running second place in will power to any gl.

Avatar image for stormultt
#16 Posted by Stormultt (5471 posts) - - Show Bio

hes already very powerful and a little overrated...yes Overrated so no he should stay original

Avatar image for methos
#17 Posted by Methos (40531 posts) - - Show Bio
DEGRAAF said:
if that is the case i would like to see more of him.

Read the Corps book then, he appears more in that with Kyle and Guy than anywhere else... though saying that, he hasn't really done anything aside from getting his ass handed to him by every lame villain that crosses his path lol

M
Avatar image for g_bandit
#18 Posted by G'bandit (13664 posts) - - Show Bio

Maybe they consider him a threat? I mean after all he is already incredibly powerful, you don't give more power to the already powerful, that's a freaking mistake!

Avatar image for degraaf
#19 Edited by DEGRAAF (8402 posts) - - Show Bio
G'bandit said:
"Maybe they consider him a threat? I mean after all he is already incredibly powerful, you don't give more power to the already powerful, that's a freaking mistake!
"
if its superman i think he would still be ok even with more power
Methos
said:
"DEGRAAF said:
if that is the case i would like to see more of him.

Read the Corps book then, he appears more in that with Kyle and Guy than anywhere else... though saying that, he hasn't really done anything aside from getting his ass handed to him by every lame villain that crosses his path lol

M
"
lol that is  pretty dumb if a person as strong as superman and green lantern gets his but kicked every fight
Avatar image for king_saturn
#20 Posted by King Saturn (220879 posts) - - Show Bio
I like Superman the way he is... but I wouldnt mine if he became a Blue Lantern... for a little while at least

lol
Avatar image for kid_deadpool
#21 Edited by Kid Deadpool (41 posts) - - Show Bio
King Saturn said:
"but I wouldnt mine if he became a Blue Lantern... for a little while at least

lol
"
nahhhh.


DEGRAAF
said:
"I have been thinking about this for the passed cople of days and i cant figure it out. i know more aboout supreman than i do green lantern but to be chosen by the ring of the green lanterns you must have a pure heart and soul or something like that but when they talk about superman it seems like you couldnt get more pure so i will ask again,

why hasnt superman ever become a green lantern or any other color lantern for that matter?"
..... because he's just not.
Avatar image for alexander_anderson
#22 Posted by Alexander Anderson (4306 posts) - - Show Bio

Because he's ridiculous enough as he is.

Avatar image for inferiorego
#23 Posted by inferiorego (25581 posts) - - Show Bio
Methos said:
"DEGRAAF said:
if that is the case i would like to see more of him.

Read the Corps book then, he appears more in that with Kyle and Guy than anywhere else... though saying that, he hasn't really done anything aside from getting his ass handed to him by every lame villain that crosses his path lol

M
"
Sodom is a big part of this months issue, I just finished it.
Staff
Avatar image for kataklysmo
#24 Posted by Kataklysmo (939 posts) - - Show Bio
What do they mean by true fear?

What is willpower to the GL corp?
Avatar image for dr__maxwell
#25 Posted by Dr. Maxwell (676 posts) - - Show Bio

Well isn't Mogo really close to where Krypton is/was as after Superboy-Prime was flown through Rao, or whatever the sun is called they landed on Mogo. So that explains why Kal has never been ofered a ring, as his sector already has one.
Kataklysmo said:

"What do they mean by true fear?

What is willpower to the GL corp?
"
Willpower is what allows the Corps to use their rings, no will, no cool shapes.
The Lanterns have to overcome the most frigthening moment of their life otherwise their rings won't work on yellow. or something along those lines

Avatar image for calvin
#26 Edited by Calvin (3583 posts) - - Show Bio

I think the most important think is that the Green Lantern Corps has their own agenda. Green Lanterns work for the Guardians, they have a system of rules they have to follow and they are placed where the Guardians want them to be. Superman do just whatever he feels it's right.


The Guardians gave the Ion powers to a guy with all the Superman's powers. The  Ion is the most powerfull thing a Green Lantern can have, or become, right?

So extra-power shouldn't be a problem to Superman, alsohe already showed the ability to use a Green Lantern Power Ring, and there are other Green Lanterns who don't work in their home planet, so I don't think Superman had to work in Krypton's sector, especially because Krypton don't exist!!!

Avatar image for degraaf
#27 Posted by DEGRAAF (8402 posts) - - Show Bio

i would just like to see him as a lantern

Avatar image for atphantom
#28 Posted by AtPhantom (14434 posts) - - Show Bio
DEGRAAF said:
"i would just like to see him as a lantern"
Read Batman: in darkest knight and Superman: Up up and away.
Avatar image for sunman
#29 Posted by SUNMAN (7805 posts) - - Show Bio
DEGRAAF said:
"i would just like to see him as a lantern"
your the only one
Avatar image for vance_astro
#30 Posted by vance_astro (89988 posts) - - Show Bio

BECAUSE HE'S SUPERMAN....duh.

Moderator
Avatar image for degraaf
#31 Posted by DEGRAAF (8402 posts) - - Show Bio
AtPhantom said:
"DEGRAAF said:
"i would just like to see him as a lantern"
Read Batman: in darkest knight and Superman: Up up and away.
"
batman in the darkest knight is just about batman w the ring right?

Superman up up and away does have superman in it as a green lantern?

SUNMAN said:
"DEGRAAF said:
"i would just like to see him as a lantern"
your the only one"
yea i highly doubt that
Avatar image for sunman
#32 Posted by SUNMAN (7805 posts) - - Show Bio
DEGRAAF said:
"AtPhantom said:

SUNMAN said:
"DEGRAAF said:
"i would just like to see him as a lantern"
your the only one"
yea i highly doubt that
"
find 20 people who want to see Supes as a GL
Avatar image for vance_astro
#33 Posted by vance_astro (89988 posts) - - Show Bio
Vance Astro said:
"BECAUSE HE'S SUPERMAN....duh."

Moderator
Avatar image for degraaf
#34 Posted by DEGRAAF (8402 posts) - - Show Bio

lol i dont know 20 people that like comic books.

Avatar image for geometry
#35 Posted by geometry (1243 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman isn't a Green Lantern, because that would really suck something major. Why would he need the ring? What more could he accomplish with it?

Avatar image for degraaf
#36 Posted by DEGRAAF (8402 posts) - - Show Bio

im not necessarily saying he should get one im just kinda wonderin why it was never offered.

also how strong of a green lantern would he be

Avatar image for the_social_moth
#37 Posted by the Social Moth (40 posts) - - Show Bio
StrongestOneThereIs said:
"Cause he doesn't need to be. He is powerful enough to smack around those green policeman. "
I heard that the ring could replicate kryptonite rays...if this IS true then there is some degree of effort
And, and dont attack me for it, Smallville had any continuity to the Superman main continuity, then there is the fact that he does doubt himself, but that happens to every hero one time or another...GL's use their will...superman's 'Will' is his fist
Avatar image for degraaf
#38 Posted by DEGRAAF (8402 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman was ment to be the Greatest Green Lantern of Them All and Be the leader or the Green Lantern Corps when The Guardians of the Universe passed on. It says it all here http://www.supermansupersite.com/1972.html

this might just be some writers view but i like this story alot and wish this was the beginning of the superman story

Avatar image for scarecrow4
#39 Posted by Scarecrow4 (478 posts) - - Show Bio

I think the reason is because Superman chooses not to be a green lantern just as Batman does; They don't feel they need the ring to help the greater good.  Superman has been offered the ring a few times just as batman has and he's turned it down every time because he simply does not want it.    

Avatar image for mrmiracle77
#40 Posted by MrMiracle77 (1673 posts) - - Show Bio

Here's another possibility: Green Lanterns are chosen from their respective world's native population.  Superman isn't from Earth originally, so he can't be the GL for sector 2814.  Furthermore, his home planet of Krypton is gone and therefore doesn't require policing by the GLC.  Or perhaps Krypton's sector of space has a planet with a more worthy inhabitant?

Avatar image for bonesboy08
#41 Posted by bonesboy08 (160 posts) - - Show Bio

he does get a lantern ring in the 853 century dc one million anybody (it hasn't been reconed as far as i know)?

Avatar image for nightfang3
#42 Posted by NightFang3 (12221 posts) - - Show Bio

BECAUSE HE'S SUPERMAN AND IT WOULD BE OVERKILL.

Avatar image for illituracy
#43 Posted by iLLituracy (13545 posts) - - Show Bio

LOL.

Avatar image for kentaxx
#44 Posted by Kentaxx (2405 posts) - - Show Bio

He was offered a ring, but he turned it down saying he didnt want that much power

Avatar image for mrdirector786
#45 Posted by MrDirector786 (44003 posts) - - Show Bio

In Up, Up, and Away, GL offered him his ring, but he was happy the way he was, though he eventually gets his powers back. If you're wondering how he lost his powers, he went through a red sun with Superman Prime to defeat him and lost his power in the process for a whole year because apparently he didn't want to be Superman but he wants to be Superman again during Up Up and Away. Just read Up Up and Away and Infinite Crisis.

Avatar image for 04nbod
#46 Posted by 04nbod (191 posts) - - Show Bio

because the guardians shouldn't be that stupid. But it doesn't hold up when they give daxamite's rings. Sure give the most powerful race a ring bearer and if he goes rogue prepare to be screwed

Avatar image for degraaf
#47 Posted by DEGRAAF (8402 posts) - - Show Bio

yea but lead is easier to find than kryptonite. THey could defeat daxem a ring if he didnt already kill him self

Avatar image for sidney
#48 Posted by Sidney (1373 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman has enough power. He needs to go back to pre crisis Superman were villians can actually stand a chance against him.

Avatar image for stefano
#49 Posted by Stefano (1280 posts) - - Show Bio

because he doesnt belong to earth's sector

Avatar image for matteopg
#50 Edited by MatteoPG (1950 posts) - - Show Bio

I believe they explained that with the fact that Superman is not native to sector 2814, and therefore cannot be a lantern in it. But since he lives on Earth he cannot be a lantern of the sector Krypton was in either.

I think this relatively makes sense.

Mmmh, it does.

Also, I think that Superman has to overcome a lot of doubts and disadvantages, but seldom actual fear. It's more suited for people who don't have a lot of power on their native worlds (with some exceptions), because they know how to rise up from the mass and face stuff others don't with no means.