@keikrosskira said:
@echostarlord117: I agree with everything you say except the Saber forms. Sith themselves can learn any of the Saber forms,
Again, this depends on the source you're looking at. According to the Book of Sith, this is the case.
The Jedi teach six forms of lightsaber combat. This is excessive and a waste of time. There is no need for a Sith Lord to study any form that doesn't channel one's aggression. A battle should end quickly. At every moment, one should be assessing the ways to dispatch one's opponent — select the most direct method.
There are two key forms of lightsaber combat a Sith must master: Strong style and Fast style.
Star Wars: Book of Sith
Strong style is Form V, and includes both Djem So and Shien. Fast style is Ataru, although it specifies in the book that Form IV isn't as common among Sith as Form V is. It later states that Juyo is also taught, but is rare due to it's difficulty.
in fact till Windu made Vapaad form 7 was mostly just used by Sith so they actually had the advantage in saber forms for many years.
Why would knowing Form VII give you an advantage? Form VII is just as vulnerable as any other lightsaber form. In fact, it has an inherent weakness against multiple opponents and Form VI.
Also, the Jedi did have unrestricted access to Form VII during the Old Republic era. It was still relatively rare among Jedi because of it's difficulty to master, but the same was true for the Sith.
Yes i do agree Sith usually only use the aggressive forms, but that doesn't mean that they couldn't of been taught the others.
I never said they couldn't. This is obviously not true seeing as some Sith even before the Clone Wars era knew more than just Juyo, Ataru, and Djem So.
For example Exar Kun used form VI,
He was a Jedi, though.
Bane taught Zannah form III,
Once again, just because it was common for Sith to only know offensive lightsaber styles doesn't mean there aren't Sith that decide to study the other forms.
By the way, the quote I mentioned earlier was written by Bane. He was most certainly another exception.
but also look at Sidious he has mastered all 7 forms,
I should probably say that the Sith's restriction of lightsaber fighting styles seemed to have been basically eradicated by the time of Sidious and Plagueis. Once the Sith became less warmongering and more political, they didn't seem to care what lightsaber form you decide to study. Perhaps they figured out the strength of having a varied arsenal.
and the Jar'Kai sub variants of the forms.
I guess I didn't specify seeing as I didn't think it'd be necessary, but Jar'Kai was definitely not restricted among Sith. There're plenty of Sith that duel wield.
So Jedi actually for many years had less variety available to them, if only by one. Its just that most Jedi used the variety of the different forms more then Sith did usually do to the Sith nature of agressiveness.
Nah.
There was a time, though, that the Sith had something the Jedi didn't in terms of lightsaber combat and that was the double-bladed lightsaber. That slight advantage didn't last long, obviously, since Jedi have used double-bladed lightsabers since well before Revan's time.
Trying to mix them will only dilute the results (unless you're being penned by Drew Karpyshyn/Bioware).
That's what I always thought, but I guess it's just über cool to be a Force user that uses Light and Dark powers.
Log in to comment