Avatar image for joshmightbe
#1 Posted by joshmightbe (27431 posts) - - Show Bio

Lethal injection and electrocution are pretty much the only methods of execution allowed in this country because most of the other methods are considered cruel and unusual but I ask why is instant decapitation considered less humane than the two methods currently employed?

Its pretty much an instant and nearly painless death where as both lethal injection and electrocution are said to come with great pain. Isn't a less painful method less cruel?

Avatar image for hbktimhbk
#2 Edited by HBKTimHBK (5731 posts) - - Show Bio

@joshmightbe: Electrocution has been a secondary method of execution for over 10 years, and that's only in a few states. Most states now don't use electrocution at all. Basically electrocution has been on the decline for a while because it's a pretty..I don't know how to phrase this eloquently but..bad way to die.

Avatar image for emequious_swerve
#3 Posted by Emequious_Swerve (1302 posts) - - Show Bio

It's pretty messy.

Avatar image for joshmightbe
#4 Posted by joshmightbe (27431 posts) - - Show Bio

@hbktimhbk: This was intended to cover lethal injection as well but the title was too long.

Avatar image for dr_harlequin
#5 Edited by Dr_Harlequin (755 posts) - - Show Bio

The guillotine was used against anyone who opposed the revolution of France...It was used for mass executions and anyone, no matter if they were innocent or not, were given the treatment of the guillotine. So the guillotine was a way of instilling fear in people...that's not really humane. The era of this device was even called "the reign of terror." I can see why we wouldn't want to recall that time in human history.

And I mean, I don't think anyone would want to have others be decapitated, either...

Avatar image for joshmightbe
#6 Posted by joshmightbe (27431 posts) - - Show Bio

@dr_harlequin: Not asking about how it was used, just saying the device itself is more humane because it offers a virtually painless death.

Avatar image for the_stegman
#7 Posted by The Stegman (36597 posts) - - Show Bio

All executions are inhumane.

Online
Avatar image for yokergeist
#8 Edited by Yokergeist (12483 posts) - - Show Bio

@joshmightbe:

Is that the one where you put your head in the hole and the blade comes down?

Avatar image for judasnixon
#9 Posted by judasnixon (11836 posts) - - Show Bio

@joshmightbe: Because it F-ing cuts peoples heads off...... Lets say you had to put your dog down, and the vet walks up and says "Sorry kid-o we have to cut Fluffy's head off. It's the humane thing to do." I wouldn't think you would say "Oh golly doctor vet guy thank you for cutting my dog's head off to save him through all the pain"........

Avatar image for joshmightbe
#10 Posted by joshmightbe (27431 posts) - - Show Bio

@supernategames: Yea but its like a split second and you wouldn't have enough time to feel it.

Avatar image for dr_harlequin
#11 Posted by Dr_Harlequin (755 posts) - - Show Bio

@joshmightbe: I'm just saying that it may not be used today because of it's inhumane history.

Avatar image for joshmightbe
#12 Posted by joshmightbe (27431 posts) - - Show Bio

@judasnixon: If it was quicker and less painful than what they use to euthanize them currently then it would technically be better.

Avatar image for joshmightbe
#13 Posted by joshmightbe (27431 posts) - - Show Bio

@dr_harlequin: So they're actually being less humane because it looks more humane? Well actually that makes sense considering what we know of American politics.

Avatar image for dr_harlequin
#14 Posted by Dr_Harlequin (755 posts) - - Show Bio

It's also probably also a cultural thing too, I mean we eat foods in our culture that shouldn't even be considered foods...like the ones that cause problems to our bodies. I'm sure there are other cultures that have different methods of execution, we don't use some because of our own cultural restrictions.

Avatar image for dr_harlequin
#15 Edited by Dr_Harlequin (755 posts) - - Show Bio

Also, are we talking about sentenced executions and euthanasia?

In that case, I don't want my relatives to be headless before we close the casket. The head is known to give one a self of identity, at least in some cultures. If that's gone, then you can really say that you've cut off their humanity.

Avatar image for joshmightbe
#16 Edited by joshmightbe (27431 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for xwraith
#17 Posted by Xwraith (34227 posts) - - Show Bio
Moderator
Avatar image for khan_noonien_singh
#18 Edited by Khan_Noonien_Singh (514 posts) - - Show Bio

I still think we should make Escape from New York a thing. Worked for the Brits way back when.

Avatar image for kyrees
#19 Posted by kyrees (12322 posts) - - Show Bio

it's a lot messier because of all the blood coming out of the stump.

Avatar image for yokergeist
#20 Posted by Yokergeist (12483 posts) - - Show Bio

Probably because it doesn't look humane or professional. A needle or a chair seem much more humane than a guillotine, even if it is more painful.

-$NG

Avatar image for dr_harlequin
#21 Posted by Dr_Harlequin (755 posts) - - Show Bio

@kyrees said:

it's a lot messier because of all the blood coming out of the stump.

Ew, what would they do with the heads?

Avatar image for kyrees
#22 Posted by kyrees (12322 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for dr_harlequin
#23 Edited by Dr_Harlequin (755 posts) - - Show Bio

@kyrees: Then what would they do with it afterwards?

Avatar image for kyrees
#24 Edited by kyrees (12322 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for mrdecepticonleader
#25 Posted by mrdecepticonleader (19685 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for wolverine008
#26 Posted by Wolverine008 (50927 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for jloneblackheart
#27 Posted by jloneblackheart (7425 posts) - - Show Bio

Because just like an ax, it doesnt always cut through in one chop.

Avatar image for joshmightbe
#28 Posted by joshmightbe (27431 posts) - - Show Bio

@jloneblackheart: Actually with the guillotine's design, so long as it's well maintained it pretty much always goes through in one shot. Its probably the most efficient methods humans have invented for removing a head and we as a species have invented a truly disturbing amount of methods to remove a head.

Avatar image for dr_harlequin
#29 Posted by Dr_Harlequin (755 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for russellmania77
#30 Posted by russellmania77 (17603 posts) - - Show Bio

Nobody ever said killing a person would be easy... well a few people have to they were mostly cerial killers

Avatar image for saintwildcard
#31 Posted by saintwildcard (19357 posts) - - Show Bio

All executions are inhumane.

What about death by snu snu?

Avatar image for dr_harlequin
#32 Posted by Dr_Harlequin (755 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for saintwildcard
#33 Posted by saintwildcard (19357 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for the_stegman
#34 Posted by The Stegman (36597 posts) - - Show Bio

@saint_rog_el: that's not an execution, that's a happy ending. ;)

Online
Avatar image for jeanralphio
#35 Posted by JeanRalphio (1886 posts) - - Show Bio

Dude this is grim.

Avatar image for khan_noonien_singh
#36 Posted by Khan_Noonien_Singh (514 posts) - - Show Bio

@joshmightbe: Lethal injection doesn't come with pain. You don't feel anything. You are put to sleep, then inject you with a paralytic to stop your breathing, then you are injected with something to stop your heart. You die without ever knowing it happened... aside from the knowledge that comes from laying on the table.

Avatar image for jedixman
#37 Posted by JediXMan (37798 posts) - - Show Bio
Moderator Online
Avatar image for jloneblackheart
#38 Edited by jloneblackheart (7425 posts) - - Show Bio

@joshmightbe: I guess key phrases are "well maintained" and "pretty much always." Any way, I always found hanging to be equally as effective as decapitation when done correctly.

Avatar image for thitiki
#39 Edited by Thitiki (4504 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for matteopg
#40 Posted by MatteoPG (1950 posts) - - Show Bio

Nobody ever said killing a person would be easy... well a few people have to they were mostly cerial killers

I think you meant "cereal" killers.

Avatar image for shootingnova
#41 Posted by ShootingNova (24936 posts) - - Show Bio

That's interesting. Kind of what I suspected but it seemed a little silly. That would probably hurt more than the electric chair, which shuts down your brain in the very first shock (although the shock itself might hurt for a brief moment). Sometimes injection can sort of kill instantly so there isn't always a great deal of pain. I suppose the guillotine might hurt a bit after all. I don't want to imagine a failed guillotine, though. LOL. Sounds a bit too gruesome.

Frankly though, the concept of public execution is inhumane in itself, as some people have said in this thread.

Avatar image for jedixman
#42 Posted by JediXMan (37798 posts) - - Show Bio

That's interesting. Kind of what I suspected but it seemed a little silly. That would probably hurt more than the electric chair, which shuts down your brain in the very first shock (although the shock itself might hurt for a brief moment). Sometimes injection can sort of kill instantly so there isn't always a great deal of pain. I suppose the guillotine might hurt a bit after all. I don't want to imagine a failed guillotine, though. LOL. Sounds a bit too gruesome.

Frankly though, the concept of public execution is inhumane in itself, as some people have said in this thread.

There's also rumors of people being conscious after decapitation, because of the blood and oxygen that still remain in the head. Those circumstances are debatable, though. However, the scenarios are rather creepy: in one, somebody picked up the head and it opened its eyes, stared at the guy, and then slowly closed its eyes when it died.

Moderator Online
Avatar image for khan_noonien_singh
#43 Posted by Khan_Noonien_Singh (514 posts) - - Show Bio

@jedixman: It is theoretically possible and considering how many people were put to death by guillotine, I am sure there were more than a few that lasted up to 10 seconds before dying.

Avatar image for shootingnova
#44 Edited by ShootingNova (24936 posts) - - Show Bio

@jedixman: That's pretty much what that link said. I've never seen one of those things and I don't plan to. LOL.

Avatar image for kuonphobos
#45 Posted by kuonphobos (5191 posts) - - Show Bio

@matteopg said:

@russellmania77 said:

Nobody ever said killing a person would be easy... well a few people have to they were mostly cerial killers

I think you meant "cereal" killers.

Seriously?

Avatar image for wolfrazer
#46 Posted by Wolfrazer (13618 posts) - - Show Bio

@matteopg said:

@russellmania77 said:

Nobody ever said killing a person would be easy... well a few people have to they were mostly cerial killers

I think you meant "cereal" killers.

Seriously?

It's a real thing! People are out to get the cereals! Killing cereal is wrong!

Online
Avatar image for matteopg
#47 Posted by MatteoPG (1950 posts) - - Show Bio

@matteopg said:

@russellmania77 said:

Nobody ever said killing a person would be easy... well a few people have to they were mostly cerial killers

I think you meant "cereal" killers.

Seriously?

... no, come on, it was obviously a dumb joke ;)