The Macho Man or The Undertaker?

The Taker.

Undertaker

Both were/are overrated.

In their primes, I guess Savage was better and I can do a better impression of him.

@thespoiler: who's the greatest wrestler you think?

I'd say it's either Kurt Angle or Ric Flair. I like Angle more, but I wouldn't argue with anyone who says Flair's better.

Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels, Chris Jericho, Austin Aries, & Chris Benoit are other strong contenders for me.

Savage

@thespoiler: and not Eddie Guerrero?

Anyways, taker overall. When I think of "overall" I include things such as character and personality. I love macho man to death , but in terms of character and personality, I have to give it to taker. The way he's been able to change his character and personality throughout the years was simply amazing

@mike_fowler: I always thought Eddie was overrated. Certainly a good talent, but not an all time great some make him out to be.

Undertaker @both

Undertaker above all, after that Ric Flair.

@thespoiler: really? Which part do you think was overrated? Character? In-ring work? Charisma? Etc Etc.

Macho

There's nothing specific I can point to, just him in general. He was fine on the mic, but he never really drew me in with his words. His ring work was good and he put on consistently solid matches, but none of them have ever stood out as classics to me.

The Phenom.

Taker for both, no disrespect intended to Macho Man.

vs Rey Mysterio, Halloween Havoc '97?

That's a good match, but one I always forget unless it's brought up, and the only part of the match I really remember is Eddie trying to take off Rey's mask. Just not really memorable enough to be a "classic" to me.

'Taker sweeps.

@thespoiler: what bout no way out against lesnar?

Also, what do you think was Ric flair'a best match?

@mike_fowler: Never saw the Lesnar match. May give it a watch at some point.

Flair's had too many great matches for me to narrow it down to one, but a few favorites off the top of my head include his match with Sting at the first Clash of the Champions, his Shawn Michaels match at Wrestlemania when he "retired", and pretty much any time he got in the ring with Ricky Steamboat.

@thespoiler: you should, definitely one of his best matches (and was the match he won the world title in, the pop he got was AMAZING)

So which match in your opinion had the biggest "spectacle" feel to it?