Captain America(2011) or Saving Private Ryan

Saving Private Ryan's a classic. Captain America: The First Avenger was rather... Bland in comparison to the sequel.

Captain America was the ultimate war film. Saving Private Ryan was just an excuse for Tom Hanks to make me cry again.

Hmm... An OK marvel movie vs a movie that inspired an entire video game genre... Hmm... Decisions decisions...

spite

The Spielberg one and it´s not even funny.

Lol

Saving Private Ryan is the greatest war film I've ever seen.

Well, to me, SPR isn't the greatest war film, but it worlds better a war film than Captain America. Love me some Cap, but no comparison.

Saving Private Ryan to me, by far.

Two completely different films. But I like Saving Pvt. Ryan much much better.

Wait what...? First Avenger was the worst MCU movie behind Thor and next to the second Avengers movie. Private Ryan is a classic. How is this even a discussion?

First Avenger is my favorite p1 film

But honestly SPR is a classic. Come on now.

Best opening 30 minutes to any movie ever

SPR. Cap 2011 is forgettable minus a few scenes

This isn't even a contest, SPR stomps.

First Avenger was good but not this good.

@jashro44: Should this get locked?

Do you want it to be locked?

My favorite part of Saving Private Ryan is the beach firefight. The rest of the movie/story is meh..

SPR

Saving Private Ryan.

I love Captain America, but SPR is the better movie by far.

Saving Private Ryan is one of the best war films created. And still stands the test of time. The best part of Captain America was the moment it ended.

These 2 films aren't even on the same level.

lol

I can't believe this is actually being asked.

Saving Private Ryan. I liked Captain America: The First Avenger but in my opinion Saving Private Ryan was better.

Cap, less morbid. Don't get me wrong SPR is obviously a much better film. But, that film is grotesque at times due to realistic violence. It's not a movie you can just watch while hanging out and eating some popcorn...

You can't compare the two.

SPR is the better film, but it isn't nearly as fun.

SPR easily.

Saving Private Ryan solos the MCU.

who voted Cap

TFA is one of the weakest MCU films out there. SPR is in an entirely different league.

Someone voted Captain America? lol

Classic films but Captain America had a trilogy of greatness, set up by his first film. The First Avenger is the better war film.

Whoa mismatch

Saving Private Ryan

Saving Private Ryan, as a war film, is a classic and is leagues better than The First Avenger, which was terribly slow although still a good comic-based movie.