Who was the worst writer to handle your favourite character

Dude LH and Hush are more than passable, they are very good(LH won Eisner and Hush was voted most favorite Batman story this year in CV) , also people forget about Dark Victory(it also won an Eisner), its pretty good and his Superman/Batman are one of the few non-JL Batman and Superman team up stories I've enjoyed. Nolan's movies were heavily influenced by Loeb's work. While I haven't read Superman For All Seasons, Catwoman : When In Rome, Spider-Man Blue or Daredevil Yellow, I've heard they were very good. People forget about his good works. Same with Miller, people forget about his good comics and only remember the bad ones, TDKR and Year One are classics, Sin City is awesome, I've also heard his work on Daredevil and Wolverine is great.

Agreed, the guy writes a great GL, Flash, Aquaman and even Superman but his Batman is terrible.

I've heard he dislikes Batman, so that may be the answer to his poorly written Batman.

Yeah it looks like he does. Btw @battle_forum_junkie how can anyone hate Morrison? He gave us the best version of Batman, Superman and JLA and his work on Flash is awesome.

Krul and Kreisberg on Green Arrow were pretty weak.

Tom Veitch - Superman. Read Superman: At Earth's End if you don't believe me. Actually just read reviews of it online.

Frank Millar - Batman. Sorry but All Star Batman and Robin is just atrocious writing and makes Batman a character I actively detest.

Dan Slott - Spider-Man. I'm not forgiving him any time soon for Superior Spider-Man.

Matt Fraction - Thor. I'd just gotten into Thor and Fraction's run kept me away until Aaron's God of Thunder.

@theacidskull: I seriously wanted to punch Batman in the face throughout the issue.

Are you dense? Are you retarded or something? Do you know who the hell I am? I'M THE GODDAMN BATMAN!

No, I think Frank Miller was being serious. That's what he considers badass and good writing at the stage he is in at his career.

@theacidskull:

Read Frank Miller's other recent works. He's now adopted an overly gritty style to his writing.

That's the thing, his writing is so overly gritty now, it's parody like. I can't stop saying I'M GODDMAN BATMAN!

@rustyroy: @battle_forum_junkie Loeb can work when continuity isn't involved.

The dude pretty much turned Wolverine from a mutant into a guy evolved from lupines, and made it so his entire life is a big conspiracy. As in everybody is in on it, working together to do whatever it is the big bad wanted them to do.

He treated the Ultimate universe like it was the 616. He pretty much S%$& on the characters. Then he killed off most of them.

He also has a tendency to mary sue Rulk.

I don't care if he wins an Eisner, the Nobel Peace Prize AND the CV fanboy awards. Fact is the masses don't vote for the majority of awards. A small select group does. So that point is moot.

My end of the day take is this. If you disrespect the medium you are working in, you are a hack.

Jeph Loeb is a hack.

Whoever did Allstar Batman.

@risingbean: His stories did win many fan awards which were voted by masses, I don't care if he wrote a few bad stories which I've never read, and I don't care what you think cause you pretty much said anyone who doesn't like your a opinion is a fanboy.

Frank Miller for any DC character that's not Batman.

@lvenger: Come on, I know ASB&R was bad but he did gave us two classic Batbooks, at least All Star is funny and seriously there are worse Batman writers.

Yup it was.

@rustyroy: Year One was good I'll give you that. But he is kinda overrated.

Brian Bendis took the Avengers and ran them into the ground for me. The stories weren't necessarily bad but turning the Avengers into a street level team was infinitely stupid. Opening up the roster to the entire Marvel Universe also watered down the entire idea of being an Avenger. My apologies to fans of Luke Cage, Iron Fist, Wolverine, Spider-Man and others that Bendis drafted but none of them were Avengers in the true sense of the word.

Apology somewhat accepted.

@wolverine08: *extends an olive branch*

To expand, I didn't mean it as an insult to those characters based on their lineages or backgrounds. Wolverine is one of my favorite characters but for me he is the ultimate outlaw. He's always been an outcast and just works better IMO that way.

Spiderman was the ultimate loner. Iron Fist & Luke Cage were street level heroes fighting for the common man. I like all of these characters but just don't think of them as Avengers and I never will.

@rustyroy: Um. No. I didn't say that anybody who disagrees with me is a fanboy. I said that I didn't care if he won awards that panels dictate. I can vote for A or B because the panel has said they were vote worthy, but not C because the panel doesn't think so? I don't care what he has won, I think his writing is generally bad because he disrespects the medium and fan of it.

As per fanboys, I made an example called the CV fanboy awards. I didn't say "You are a fanboy for disagreeing with me." I was trying to make a rule of three joke with the Eisner's and Nobel Prize being "legitimate" awards and the CV fanboy award being less so. Sorry you missed the punchline.

QFT Bendis Avengers books are unreadable now. I can't even go back to read the old events again

Everyone hates him now, how is that overrated lol?

Okay, I got it now.

@rustyroy: Kosher. So no hard feelings, I hope.

@risingbean: Yeah we're good.

@jake_fury:

I see where you are coming from. It was kind of weird to make everybody an Avenger despite their unique circumstances not being factored.

@wolverine08: Exactly.

It's racist if you like Black Panther and you aren't black...

lol, I'm sure most Black Panther fans are white

It's racist you don't like the only black guy that has ever written for Black Panther...

Huldin for making Wakanda a Mary Suetopia and ignoring Priest's better BP mythos.

Christopher Priest is the best Black Panther writer and he's black

I know, right? It honestly surprised me. But everyone's entitled to their opinions I guess.

I know. :(

Harley Quinn - Adam Glass and Matt Kindt are tied for their horrible work.

Batman - Kevin Smith,Tony Daniel,David Finch.
Spider-Man - Dan Slott
Wolverine - Brian Bendis

It was bad timing more than anything. Marvel started promoting the hell out of Deadpool right before Way's run started.

And they only started heavily promoting him because he came in higher in a character popularity poll than they expected.

Deadpool - Daniel Way

I'm adding this. (p.s. I don't know why but I read that in a very ominous Vincent Price-esque voice. )

Also,

Batman - Frank Miller (Year One is the exception. I love that comic.)

@dctv3363: LOL!

I love that! Have you seen this:

@dctv3363: Oh yeah I love anything Burton went to see his exhibit when it was in Toronto.

@br_havoc: He not only makes great movies, he makes some really nice artwork. I had no idea they had an exhibit for him though.

@dctv3363:Yeah they had it for the Toronto film festival. It was really cool having all of these art pieces and props from his movies told you little secrets of how he made certain movies and stuff like that. At the end I bought this huge and expensive book of all his sketches and things like that.

Did you hear he is making Beetlejuice 2 and Michael Keaton is coming back!