First, I must say this thread is gold.
But I have some thoughts about Cap's habilities. If you look at the other masters, most of them have trained their entire lives. Natasha is the top of the organization that can create children who fodderize SSR special agents. Elektra already fodderized professional fighters as a child. May studies martial arts since she was a kid. Barnes is training for almost a century. How much time Steve actually had to improve so much from that Brooklyn boy? If we count his time as a WWII soldier plus his modern missions, it wouldn't surpass five years. I think it's to much to put him as the very best master. His main feats involve his strengh and his shield in some way, and these are huge factors. Crossbones has never shown any good feats, and that armor only slowed him. It wasn't powered by any kind of electricity, it was just protecting metal, like Batman's mech suit. He wasnt stronger than Cap. That Iron Man feat is just PIS. Stark's suit was heavily nerfed, Steve had the upper hand mainly because of his shield and Bucky's metal arm. Fighting with Ultron was impressive, but again, he uses his shield and momentum all the time, and we don't know Ultron's strenght. He wasn't trying to kill him also. I feel that the best martial artist should be someone who doesn't trust in any weapon or power, and I just can't see Steve as a great master.
With that being said, I would rank the masters probably in that order:
- Stick
- Melinda May
- Matt Murdock
- Nobu
- Bobbi Morse
- Elektra
- T'Chala
- Grant Ward
- James Barnes
- Natasha Romanoff
- Giyera
- Steve Rogers
Haven't seen Doctor Strange, but The Ancient One should be somewhere up here by titles and implied feats, along with Gamora and Nebula.
Log in to comment