Best Actor in a Lead Role - Comic Vine 2012 Movie Awards

Mark Ruffalo or Karl Urban

Karl Urban killed it

@k4tzm4n No offense, but how come you have Tony and Bruce there, but no Cap or Thor?

From the options given, I have to go with Robery Downey Jr. I can never get past the throat cancer voice for Bale's Batman.

And who voted Andrew Garfield as Peter? That casting was almost as bad as George Clonney Batman.

Karl Urban killed it

@k4tzm4n No offense, but how come you have Tony and Bruce there, but no Cap or Thor?

From the options given, I have to go with Robery Downey Jr. I can never get past the throat cancer voice for Bale's Batman.

And who voted Andrew Garfield as Peter? That casting was almost as bad as George Clonney Batman.

@k4tzm4n: Fair enough.

@TheCannon said:

@k4tzm4n No offense, but how come you have Tony and Bruce there, but no Cap or Thor?

From the options given, I have to go with Robery Downey Jr. I can never get past the throat cancer voice for Bale's Batman.

And who voted Andrew Garfield as Peter? That casting was almost as bad as George Clonney Batman.

Garfield did a fantastic job.

@inferiorego said:

@TheCannon said:

@k4tzm4n No offense, but how come you have Tony and Bruce there, but no Cap or Thor?

From the options given, I have to go with Robery Downey Jr. I can never get past the throat cancer voice for Bale's Batman.

And who voted Andrew Garfield as Peter? That casting was almost as bad as George Clonney Batman.

Garfield did a fantastic job.

LOL. You're funny.

@TheCannon said:

@inferiorego said:

@TheCannon said:

@k4tzm4n No offense, but how come you have Tony and Bruce there, but no Cap or Thor?

From the options given, I have to go with Robery Downey Jr. I can never get past the throat cancer voice for Bale's Batman.

And who voted Andrew Garfield as Peter? That casting was almost as bad as George Clonney Batman.

Garfield did a fantastic job.

LOL. You're funny.

Not a joke.

@inferiorego said:

@TheCannon said:

@inferiorego said:

@TheCannon said:

@k4tzm4n No offense, but how come you have Tony and Bruce there, but no Cap or Thor?

From the options given, I have to go with Robery Downey Jr. I can never get past the throat cancer voice for Bale's Batman.

And who voted Andrew Garfield as Peter? That casting was almost as bad as George Clonney Batman.

Garfield did a fantastic job.

LOL. You're funny.

Not a joke.

@TheCannon said:

@k4tzm4n No offense, but how come you have Tony and Bruce there, but no Cap or Thor?

From the options given, I have to go with Robery Downey Jr. I can never get past the throat cancer voice for Bale's Batman.

And who voted Andrew Garfield as Peter? That casting was almost as bad as George Clonney Batman.

i agree ASM sucked and andrew garfield was a horrible peter and spiderman. the only good thing about it was emma stone

@AllStarSuperman said:

@TheCannon said:

@k4tzm4n No offense, but how come you have Tony and Bruce there, but no Cap or Thor?

From the options given, I have to go with Robery Downey Jr. I can never get past the throat cancer voice for Bale's Batman.

And who voted Andrew Garfield as Peter? That casting was almost as bad as George Clonney Batman.

i agree ASM sucked and andrew garfield was a horrible peter and spiderman. the only good thing about it was emma stone

You've earned yourself a follow. Those are my exact thoughts.

RDJ, the only reason why I like the Iron man movies. Christian Bale is a close second.

Robert Downey Jr. - Tony Stark

Going with RDJ!!!

@inferiorego said:

Karl Urban killed it

This. Urban is about half of why I love Dredd (probably more than any other comic book movie this year), the other half being that it didn't feel the need to be some three hour epic.

I agree with putting Robert Downey Jr. in this category for Avengers, but I disagree with Ruffalo being here. This isn't a knock against Ruffalo. I thought he was great in the Avengers, but Bruce Banner was a supporting role, not a lead role in the film.

My vote goes to Andrew Garfield. I was suspect about his casting as Peter Parker, but I thought he completely nailed it. Amazing Spider-Man wasn't the best Spider-Man movie, but Garfield was excellent in it.

@kennyshat said:

@inferiorego said:

Karl Urban killed it

This. Urban is about half of why I love Dredd (probably more than any other comic book movie this year), the other half being that it didn't feel the need to be some three hour epic.

Pretty much sums it up for me.

@inferiorego said:

Karl Urban killed it

Robert Downey Jr.

Robert Downey Jr. is too old to play Tony Stark!!!!!! Everyone forgets that resemblance should be a key part of casting.

Christian Bale for me, hands down.

Karl Urban brought the Dredd I wanted to see to the screen, he gets my vote.

Karl Urban. He was a perfect Dredd.

@TheCannon: @inferiorego: Ooooohh is Mat going to take the Internet laughing at him?

I voted for Andrew Garfield, thought he was a great Spidey too bad the overall film was average :(

I really enjoyed Mark Rufallo's performance.

Ruffalo, followed by Garfield and Downey Jr.

Mark Ruffalo killed it as Hulk! Freaking awesome!@TheCannon said:

@k4tzm4n No offense, but how come you have Tony and Bruce there, but no Cap or Thor?

From the options given, I have to go with Robery Downey Jr. I can never get past the throat cancer voice for Bale's Batman.

And who voted Andrew Garfield as Peter? That casting was almost as bad as George Clonney Batman.

NOTHING IS WORSE THAN GEORGE CLOONEY! NOTHING! @TheCannon said:

@inferiorego said:

@TheCannon said:

@inferiorego said:

@TheCannon said:

@k4tzm4n No offense, but how come you have Tony and Bruce there, but no Cap or Thor?

From the options given, I have to go with Robery Downey Jr. I can never get past the throat cancer voice for Bale's Batman.

And who voted Andrew Garfield as Peter? That casting was almost as bad as George Clonney Batman.

Garfield did a fantastic job.

LOL. You're funny.

Not a joke.

He did do a great job as Spider-Man, and a pretty good job as Peter. Are you trying to say that because one thinks he did a good job, their opinion is a joke?

I vote Christian Bale.

Karl Urban was the most perfect incarnation of a comic book character I have seen since the Rocketeer. That scowl he wore on his face throughout the film was just beautiful.

For the people saying RDJ, I ask why. It was the same performance he gave twice before.

Christian Bale was good as Batman Great as Bruce Wayne

Robert Downy and Mark Rufalo were supporting actors ( It was an ensemble movie )

Andrew garfield was excellent in bringing a modern Peter Parker/Spiderman to the screen.

but

Karl Urbane became Dredd. Not once did I ever have a "He is acting" moment. He did it all with half his face covered.

Robert Downey Jr. FTW

RDJ, no question

Karl Urban

The Dark Knight Rises was a batman movie? I though it was all about "Robin".

Karl Urban!

Urban does it for me...

It's got to be Garfield, his Parker was perfect in every sense of the word.

I was going to vote Downey Jr., but Karl Urban was perfect as Dredd

i wish i could vote for Cage, but my karma would get crushed for doing that lmao

Wow no love for Nick Cage?

Mark Ruffalo managed to beat the odds and depict a wonderful Bruce Banner that stole the spotlight in the Avengers film. Him all the way for me.

Still waiting on an answer for my question: Why vote for RDJ or Bale, when they gave the exact same performance twice already? I'm not hating (RDJ is my man-crush), but what Ruffalo and Garfield brought to the table was new and excellent in their respective roles.

Loved Ruffalo's Banner/Hulk

Robert Downey Jr. - Tony Stark

I want to say Robert Downey Jr. but he's had 2 movies prior to perfect the character of Tony Stark though he had it down from the beginning. In the end I gave it to Karl Urban because Dredd could have been crap without him.

Christian Bale was such a badass character throughout Nolan's 'Batman' Trilogy.

Mark Ruffalo