I've been going round the character friends sections doing some editing and I noticed that a lot of the time people's family members are listed as friends without them ever meeting. For instance, the Boba Fett friend page had Cassus Fett as a friend despite the fact their are thousands of years between them. I deleted the friend listing because of this but I was wondering if that was the right thing to do.
Character Friends Question
Oh this is a good example, remember in the Dream Eater Saga when Samantha Darren and Baba Yaga teamed up? That doesn't make them friends.
How about alternate universe/non-canon friends/enemies. Do they count?
For instance: Galen Marek is currently an enemy of Luke Skywalker but the only time they ever confronted each other was in the non-canon ending of Force Unleashed.
@guttridgeb said:
How about alternate universe/non-canon friends/enemies. Do they count?
For instance: Galen Marek is currently an enemy of Luke Skywalker but the only time they ever confronted each other was in the non-canon ending of Force Unleashed.
Non-canon stuff should probably be left out.
And in regards to Star Wars, they should definitely be left out.
@JediXMan said:
@guttridgeb said:
How about alternate universe/non-canon friends/enemies. Do they count?
For instance: Galen Marek is currently an enemy of Luke Skywalker but the only time they ever confronted each other was in the non-canon ending of Force Unleashed.
Non-canon stuff should probably be left out.
And in regards to Star Wars, they should definitely be left out.
As per the wiki guidelines that we established for Star Wars characters, I think if it is in the EU and considered canon, then it is ok, but as long as it is only something that the reader would actually need to know about the character. Like imagine if Luke never met Darth Vader in comics (I don't know maybe he hasn't) then it is ok to list him as an enemy. That is to say if you are tagging an enemy (or friend) it better be pretty important to the character's history if it doesn't appear in comics.
@RazzaTazz said:
@JediXMan said:
@guttridgeb said:
How about alternate universe/non-canon friends/enemies. Do they count?
For instance: Galen Marek is currently an enemy of Luke Skywalker but the only time they ever confronted each other was in the non-canon ending of Force Unleashed.
Non-canon stuff should probably be left out.
And in regards to Star Wars, they should definitely be left out.
As per the wiki guidelines that we established for Star Wars characters, I think if it is in the EU and considered canon, then it is ok, but as long as it is only something that the reader would actually need to know about the character. Like imagine if Luke never met Darth Vader in comics (I don't know maybe he hasn't) then it is ok to list him as an enemy. That is to say if you are tagging an enemy (or friend) it better be pretty important to the character's history if it doesn't appear in comics.
I know. That's what I meant. If it's canon to the EU, it's canon to the overall Star Wars universe; the comics, movies, and novels aren't considered separate (... well... let's just say that for now. It's a simpler explanation)
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment