Weiss Schnee (RWBY) vs Rin Tohsaka (Fate/Stay Night)

Rules

• Both are morals on and in character, but are determined to win.
• No prep or knowledge from either gal.
• Win by kill, ko, or incapacitation.
• Weiss gets feats from the show and manga and has standard gear. Feats can be seen here.
• Rin gets feats from the three main routes and also has standard gear. Feats can be seen here.

Which crystal wielding tsundere takes the cake?

Callouts!

Fate/Stay Night (And it's spinoffs):

@joewell@blackestnight93:@joewell911@garrettmana@just_banter@kbm

RWBY:

@joewell@terrortuga@pierpat@joewell911@indomitableregal@koays@just_banter

Feats (There are more in the OP)

Don't know anything about the other girl and am pressed for time at the moment but I'll definitely be keeping an eye on this.

Speed feats for Rin? Just checked her respect thread and can't find any speed feats. She seems to outclass Weiss in almost every aspect though.

But if she isn't bullet speed or above weiss can easily blitz her.

/\ This /\

Although my opinion is completely off of second hand knowledge of Rin as well. She seems like if she had the speed/acrobatics to keep up, she would win. I'm just not convinced she does from my second hand knowledge, which may be flawed.

Skip to about 1:09 in to see the start of the fight, but everything else before that is funny IMO. Shows some decent speed feats for Rin, and even some Durability ones. Her best durability feat IMO, is when she resists being flat out crushed by berserker in the "Fate" Route. Then uses all her Gems to kill him once (something that only a Ranked "B" attack in the VN can do). Granted, I've never watched RWBY (but it looks beautiful), but I'd say there is a contest as to the speedblitz argument, based on the video alone.

I don't watch Fate, but it seems like Rin might win, at least for now. Weiss seems like she'll have more feats by the next Vol. Weiss does seem to have the advantage in speed though.

Rin with Jewels should take this imo. Too much firepower for Weiss to handle

@paragonnate: @karitten: @tparks: Does the video above help any?

@joewell911: Ya, for sure. That's a lot more impressive then I was expecting. Hmmm. This would be a good fight. I'm kind of leaning towards Rin.

I know you made the thread, but who do you think would win? I'm curious to see your thoughts.

Glad I could swing a vote toward Rin! the queen of tsunderes!

@joewell911: Nice breakdown. Thanks.

Ya know, this would make an amazing CaV.

Anyone interested?

That or Neo vs Illya...

@joewell911: I'd go for that CaV

@blackestnight93: I'd back Weiss.

@joewell911: based on what, if I may ask?

edit: I will admit to my knowledge of RWBY being next to non-existent, apart from the posted video. I plan on watching the series once my exams are over

@blackestnight93: What do you mean?

I have my little analyst above and could defend my points much better in a CaV.

Only watched UBW, but I don't see Rin being much of a threat to Weiss.

@joewell911: I read your post. It said that you'd give it to Weiss because you have a soft spot for her, yet also say that it is too close to call. I'm confused as to which it is.

@blackestnight93: I could defend either side, basically. So it'd be based purely on who can represent their character better.

I don't want to give up exactly what I'd be defending her on for obvious reasons, but it's due to some of the things mentioned in that post.

@joewell911: All the same, if you're ever up for doing a CaV on Illya vs Neo, That'd be fun

@blackestnight93: Actually not sure if Neo would have enough feats just yet. After Volume 4 maybe, if she gets any screen time.

@joewell911: Alright. Like I said, before I get into any CaV involving RWBY, I'd like to try and actually watch some of it before I debate it.

Not sure about Weiss since I have little to no knowledge on RWBY but I checked up on those speed feats and I think it's safe to say; despite Weiss having the speed advantage, Rin has reacted to servants and would most likely react to Weiss' speed

bump

Oh man they're pretty equal except maybe in speed or versatility

Rin has no speed feats and summarily gets stomped.

Bump

Rin stomps.

Perceiving Servants (as trash and barely as she can) >>> Anything in RWBY