Avatar image for the_mighty_thor
#1 Posted by The Mighty Thor (7554 posts) - - Show Bio

vs

Avatar image for the_mighty_thor
#2 Posted by The Mighty Thor (7554 posts) - - Show Bio

i guess i will start this off thor

Avatar image for the_martian
#3 Posted by The_Martian (37399 posts) - - Show Bio

In the past I would say Beta Ray but the current Thor is stronger.

Avatar image for the_mighty_thor
#4 Posted by The Mighty Thor (7554 posts) - - Show Bio

Captain Mar-Vell says:

"In the past I would say Beta Ray but the current Thor is stronger."

really in the past i would still say thor

Avatar image for the_martian
#5 Posted by The_Martian (37399 posts) - - Show Bio

The Mighty Thor says:

"Captain Mar-Vell says:
"In the past I would say Beta Ray but the current Thor is stronger."
really in the past i would still say thor"
Beta Ray beat Thor in the past.
Avatar image for the_mighty_thor
#6 Posted by The Mighty Thor (7554 posts) - - Show Bio

the reason why i thought so cause i have this thor comic where thor fight beta and beats him up

Avatar image for kehop
#7 Posted by kehop (77 posts) - - Show Bio

why would beta beat thor in the past???

I say thor all the way

Avatar image for the_martian
#8 Posted by The_Martian (37399 posts) - - Show Bio

Why? The first time they battle I think it was for who would be owner of Thor's hammer. Beta Ray won but didn't feel right taking it from Thor so Odin made him a copy of it.

Avatar image for the_mighty_thor
#9 Posted by The Mighty Thor (7554 posts) - - Show Bio

Captain Mar-Vell says:

"Why? The first time they battle I think it was for who would be owner of Thor's hammer. Beta Ray won but didn't feel right taking it from Thor so Odin made him a copy of it."

well in this comic beta had stormbreaker and its issue 461 and i guess he was not trying to fight thor but thor kicked his ass

Avatar image for the_creator
#10 Posted by the creator (8561 posts) - - Show Bio

It was widely accepted that when they both went all out, that they were pretty much equal. This level of equality was further cemented by the creation of Stormbreaker.

All the handbooks list them as having powers so closely rated that there is little difference.

The only slight advantage that Thor may have would be greater knowledge of the best use of his hammer in a fight.

Avatar image for warlock360
#11 Posted by warlock360 (28181 posts) - - Show Bio

Beta Ray

Avatar image for crazy_spidey
#12 Posted by crazy spidey (3474 posts) - - Show Bio

bill he beat him the first time and he can do it again

Avatar image for blackestshite
#13 Posted by BlackestShite (248 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm voting BRB
 
He still is a top class brick, while Thor has been diluted and his beefcake strategy for fighting guys like Hulk or Sentry just exposed hoe badly Thor has gone to the dogs
 
He is no longer among the Marvel elite

Avatar image for strongestonethereis
#14 Posted by StrongestOneThereIs (7064 posts) - - Show Bio

They are equal in every way
But being the god of thunder
Thor should be able to usurp the power of the storm from Bill

Avatar image for erik
#15 Posted by Erik (32504 posts) - - Show Bio

That is a picture of Ragnarok. But Thor anyway. 

Avatar image for blake_wade
#16 Posted by Blake_Wade (10 posts) - - Show Bio

BRB, very close though. He had beaten Stardust, who is probably as powerful or almost as powerful as Silver Surfer. Just my opinion.

Avatar image for thegoldenone
#17 Posted by TheGoldenOne (38932 posts) - - Show Bio
Thor.
Avatar image for higher_evolutionary
#18 Posted by higher_evolutionary (2127 posts) - - Show Bio
@Blake_Wade said:
BRB, very close though. He had beaten Stardust, who is probably as powerful or almost as powerful as Silver Surfer. Just my opinion.
nooooooooooooooooooooooooo in the godhunter arc which you are refering to
 
it was clear SS hadthe upper hand
 
and stardust is like a mid level herald way below surf
Avatar image for ndm5
#19 Posted by ndm5 (500 posts) - - Show Bio

thor=BRB... cept thor can fall back onto warriors madness and has a option to use a god blast, so the slight majority goes to thor. 6/10
Avatar image for venomoushatred1001
#20 Posted by venomoushatred1001 (12464 posts) - - Show Bio
@TheGoldenOne said:
Thor.
Avatar image for wise_son
#21 Posted by Wise Son (1796 posts) - - Show Bio
Stalemate.
Avatar image for killemall
#22 Posted by Killemall (18928 posts) - - Show Bio

Classic version of both : beta ray bill wins, he did beat thor once in order to get the strombreaker 
Current Version: thor has got some major upgrade, although his powers fluctuate widely.. Current Versions thor wins.

Avatar image for sc
#23 Posted by SC (17240 posts) - - Show Bio

Just to clarify. When Beta Ray Bill and Thor fought, as in, not the first time, where Thor lost his hammer and reverted to Blake, but the time after? Odin rigged the fight so Thor would lose. Im not sure that's a good example to use as a reason Beta Ray wins, especially since the other times they fought Thor has won, and basically Marvel will always favor Thor a bit more (like how Hulk is strongest Hulk, and Surfer is strongest Herald) for all intents and purposes.  I think regardless this could go either way. Thor slight majority. 
 
    

No Caption Provided


No Caption Provided
Moderator
Avatar image for god_spawn
#24 Posted by God_Spawn (40802 posts) - - Show Bio

I'd say stalemate when it comes to term of physical abilities but I might lean towards Thor due to him having showed a wider array of powers than Bill

Moderator
Avatar image for royaldivinity
#25 Posted by RoyalDivinity (3384 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor.

Avatar image for dadivineking
#26 Posted by DaDivineKing (43285 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor got this.

Avatar image for lance_uppercut
#27 Posted by Lance Uppercut (23226 posts) - - Show Bio
@SC said:
Just to clarify. When Beta Ray Bill and Thor fought, as in, not the first time, where Thor lost his hammer and reverted to Blake, but the time after? Odin rigged the fight so Thor would lose. Im not sure that's a good example to use as a reason Beta Ray wins, especially since the other times they fought Thor has won, and basically Marvel will always favor Thor a bit more (like how Hulk is strongest Hulk, and Surfer is strongest Herald) for all intents and purposes.  I think regardless this could go either way. Thor slight majority. 
 
    
No Caption Provided


No Caption Provided
As an aside, those entries were wonky as hell. Surely there's no way to measure how altruistic someone is.  
 
Both have some obviously impressive showings, on different scales. As a character I prefer Bill, but Thor should come away with a majority. 
Avatar image for thesupremebeing
#28 Posted by TheSupremeBeing (260 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor 100%.Beta Ray Bill 100.001% 
Beta Ray Bill has a slight power edge but Thor would win by warrior madness but normaly he would get taken down after a long fight
Avatar image for sc
#29 Posted by SC (17240 posts) - - Show Bio
@Lance Uppercut:  Its fiction, they try to measure everything. Psst, I agree with you myself. 
Moderator
Avatar image for lance_uppercut
#30 Posted by Lance Uppercut (23226 posts) - - Show Bio
@SC: Except for penis length... 
 
Actually, that would be an awesome article for someone to write. 
Avatar image for sc
#31 Posted by SC (17240 posts) - - Show Bio
@Lance Uppercut said:
@SC: Except for penis length...  Actually, that would be an awesome article for someone to write. 
 
Emma wins. 
Moderator
Avatar image for capitolpunishment
#32 Posted by CapitolPunishment (2483 posts) - - Show Bio

The only chance Bill has is a plot device, Thor would walk away with the win 9/10 times here.

Avatar image for younggunna
#33 Posted by YoungGunna (2680 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor has shown more versatility 

Avatar image for killemall
#34 Posted by Killemall (18928 posts) - - Show Bio
@Lance Uppercut said:
@SC: Except for penis length...  Actually, that would be an awesome article for someone to write. 
for after all BRB is horse thor so he has to win on penis length!  biggest on earth should be hulk, remember what they say about guys with big feet.  
Avatar image for god_spawn
#35 Posted by God_Spawn (40802 posts) - - Show Bio
@SC said:
@Lance Uppercut said:
@SC: Except for penis length...  Actually, that would be an awesome article for someone to write. 
 Emma wins. 
Co-signed
Moderator
Avatar image for billy_batson
#36 Posted by Billy Batson (59731 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor. 

BB

Online
Avatar image for suiken_seiji
#37 Posted by Suiken_Seiji (523 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor. 
 
BRB has never beaten Thor on fair ground. 
 
The first time they fought. BRB knocked out Donald Blake, not Thor. 
 
The second time they fought. Odin had set the battle field. The battle field was favor of BRB, he had terrain advantage by a large degree. He knew the terrain inside and out, he even manage to sneak attack Thor. On top of this, the heat of the planet helped BRB revive faster than Thor. BRB barely won this fight. BRB acknowledges this and even admits to Thor, if it wasn't for the battle field, he would have lost. In fact, he goes further on to say, he would have lost if the fight was anywhere else. 
 
Thor also shows more versatility and power with the hammer than BRB does. 
 
Nothing beats the original when it comes to hammers.
Avatar image for baltoro
#38 Posted by Baltoro (1562 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor vs Thor Clone?  Smart moneys on Thor.

Avatar image for primepower53
#39 Posted by primepower53 (6064 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor

Avatar image for where4artthoucarlos
#40 Posted by where4artthoucarlos (305 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for gavinification
#41 Posted by gavinification (83 posts) - - Show Bio
@Killemall said:
@Lance Uppercut said:
@SC: Except for penis length...  Actually, that would be an awesome article for someone to write. 
for after all BRB is horse thor so he has to win on penis length!  biggest on earth should be hulk, remember what they say about guys with big feet.  
Big shoes
Avatar image for kingpin1
#42 Posted by kingpin1 (234 posts) - - Show Bio

Beta Ray Bill, I hate Thor and how Marvel push him so much. I love to see him get beat for the most part.

Avatar image for killemall
#43 Posted by Killemall (18928 posts) - - Show Bio
@gavinification: That's not all they say about big feet ;)
Avatar image for killemall
#44 Posted by Killemall (18928 posts) - - Show Bio
@where4artthoucarlos: Dude that pic is so misleading.. this is where BRB was trying to stop thor when he went mad, not trying to hurt him.. he did ask silver surfer to go easy.. later was defeated by thanos (no one was gonna ask him to go easy) so this fight is out of context man. no disrespect intended!
Avatar image for chomponthis12589
#45 Posted by ChompOnThis12589 (127 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor with Odinforce takes this.

Avatar image for jeanroygrant
#46 Posted by jeanroygrant (20442 posts) - - Show Bio

@ChompOnThis12589 said:

Thor with Odinforce takes this.

He don't need it.

Avatar image for nickthedevil
#47 Posted by nickthedevil (14908 posts) - - Show Bio

@jeanroygrant said:

@ChompOnThis12589 said:

Thor with Odinforce takes this.

He don't need it.

i'm going to go out on a limb here... and, stay with me... but i think... just think...

that you are a fan of Thor. correct me if i'm wrong.

Avatar image for jeanroygrant
#48 Posted by jeanroygrant (20442 posts) - - Show Bio

@nickthedevil said:

@jeanroygrant said:

@ChompOnThis12589 said:

Thor with Odinforce takes this.

He don't need it.

i'm going to go out on a limb here... and, stay with me... but i think... just think...

that you are a fan of Thor. correct me if i'm wrong.

Big Thor fan :D

Avatar image for buckshotwashere
#49 Posted by BuckshotWasHere (19541 posts) - - Show Bio

Majestic w/ Mjolnir wins.

Moderator
Avatar image for first_last
#50 Edited by First_Last (406 posts) - - Show Bio

Regular Bill beat Thor twice. No reason he shouldn't beat him with the extra power provided by Stormbreaker. The 2 min rule matters not. Its not like Thor was unaware of his own time limit. Odin supposedly rigging the 2nd fight is only speculation. There is nothing official stating Odin did anything. It's just popular opinion from fans nothing more. Also as far as official stats are concerned Bill beats him there as well.