The Batman replaces Bruce in every Arkham game: Does he succeed?

Do you mean does he fare as well as Arkham Batman? Cause I don't want to spoil the end but...

Yes. He doesn't give up his identity either like a dumbass.

Yes, due to the fact that he has the best feats than every version of Batman except the comics.

No.

Arkham bats is superior to 2004 batman.

@ultrastarkiller: Not even to save his friends?

@dragonbellz: How exactly is Arkham Batman superior when 2004 has the best feats?

Mind Refreshing my memory ? Arkham batman was taking 20+ thugs at the same time and fought hundreds of Tanks,Helicopter,Heavily armed infantry,Super Villians and Drones in one night.

His feats even are more consistent than New 52 batman.

@dragonbellz: IRC, 2004 Batman feats were: Ragdolling a 10 foot Bane on Venom, was tossing around Killer Croc like it was nothing, through sheer strength he held his Batmobile using his grappling from falling off Gotham City Bridge, fought all of the villains he's encountered in the show 15+ at once, and utilized in tech: created different types of bat suits to counter situations, created a bat-bot to fight a extremely dangerous Bane on Venom (same goes with Joker on Venom,) created a new and improved Batmobile (I forgot what it did), and best of all only 3 people find out that he was batman, and that was Martian Manhunter, and these 2 guys that were basically trying to replicate Batman & Robin, while the whole world found out Arkham Batman was Bruce Wayne. It's been a while since I watched the show but there are more feats, those are the only ones I can think of on the top of my head.

He would have stealth-ed his way out of that easy situation

@ultrastarkiller: How would he win back Red Hood then?

@tifalockhart: he doesn't have to thats not his Robin. He'd just beat him up and lock him up

I always found the best feat from Arkham Bats was his feats of endurance. If The Batman can endure all of these without tiring, then sure.

Ehh . . . Don't think so.

@modernww2fare: I wont be able to answer this until I play all those games.

Basically each game is pretty much several BTAS episodes that happen over the course of one night, and he's more or less physically similar to BTAS Batman.

He clears all of them except Arkham City, only because he'd probably never find out about Joker's blood in the hospitals. Barring that, he'd do fine.