Avatar image for gottheit
#1 Posted by Gottheit (3591 posts) - - Show Bio

Which one would America vote for president? I mean, which one better embodies America? And don't try throwing the curve ball with, "Supes is an Alien, he wouldn't count." Shush. For the purposes of this battle, that rule has been waived. It's anyone's ball game...So, who gets the keys to the Presidential Lawnmower? Who is cleaning up Bush's mess in '08? What would you do for a Klondike Bar?

Avatar image for ms__invisible
#2 Posted by Ms. Invisible (3331 posts) - - Show Bio

Mmm... Klondike Bar... NOM NOM NOM!

I think most Americans would probably choose Captain America just because he wears a costume which has American flag print.

But for me I reckon Captain America, only because he would want to make America a better place (and bless him for doing so). Superman would probably have a "Just leave it for someone else" attitude when it comes to this presidency stuff. It doesn't seem like Superman's style to go and be president and make it a better place that way.

Avatar image for terminal_velocity
#3 Posted by Terminal Velocity (594 posts) - - Show Bio

Captain America. Superman would be expected to lead the country and save the world all the time. It wouldn't be a good idea.

Avatar image for gottheit
#4 Posted by Gottheit (3591 posts) - - Show Bio

Hmm...good point, on both records. Superman is more of a world champion, whereas Cap doesn't go overseas all that much...still, I think it would be a close election...I mean, after all they are both American Icons...what if the third candidate was JFK? Then who'd win?

Avatar image for timekeeper
#5 Posted by TimeKeeper (1270 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman is a great hero, but Cap is a better leader, in my opinion.

Avatar image for lantern_prime
#6 Posted by Lantern Prime (12987 posts) - - Show Bio

Captain America is the better leader! And he'll beat Supes just like he beat Thor!

Avatar image for gottheit
#7 Posted by Gottheit (3591 posts) - - Show Bio

Wow, allright...so far, Cap is taking this one...but will he take Ohio? C'mon, people, let's rock the Vote like P.Diddy says, because when I think democracy, I think of him and everyone else from MTV...Jesus Christ that was built-in stupidity...I mean, what, do they think that because a bunch of hack excuses for musicians tell us to vote, that we're suddenly going to, like, flourish and become this beautfiul golden Utopia or something?! And, the funny thing is, it doesn't even matter. We go by f-king electorial votes...Bush vs. Kerry, and Kerry won. Like, Bush got the electoral votes AND the popular vote...the first four years he was in office, all we ever heard was, "Ahh, Bush is garbage, a box of tic-tacs would be better as a leader, blah blah blah, impeach Bush, yadda yadda yadda," then comes the perfect oppourtunity to throw his ass out on the street, and what do we do? We vote for him again...it's like I've been taking crazy pills! AAAARRRRGHGHGHGHGGGHHHH!!!

But, anyway...that it?

Avatar image for powerherc
#8 Posted by PowerHerc (86183 posts) - - Show Bio

Cap would be my choice in this hypothetical situation.

Avatar image for night_thrasher
#9 Posted by Night Thrasher (3820 posts) - - Show Bio

Cap would win b/c Superman is an ILLEGAL ALIEN

Avatar image for spidey_15
#10 Posted by spidey 15 (17883 posts) - - Show Bio

Cap!

Avatar image for lt1085
#11 Posted by LT1085 (3677 posts) - - Show Bio

Not a battle.

Avatar image for deranged_midget
#12 Posted by Deranged Midget (18346 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman isn't the leading type. He raises morale but doesnt have what it takes to lead a country, thus sticks to calling himself the Earth's guardian, champion, etc.

Avatar image for powerherc
#13 Posted by PowerHerc (86183 posts) - - Show Bio
@LT1085:
No?  How about a contest then?   
 
This is a hypothetical election.  As such it has at least two opponents running for office trying to win the majority of votes and hence defeat their opponent(s).  Elections have one opponent vs another opponent quite often and sometimes even more than that.  It seems reasonable to call it a "battle" IMO.
Avatar image for jojjimbo
#14 Posted by jojjimbo (2628 posts) - - Show Bio

cap.

Avatar image for progenitorigin
#15 Posted by progenitorigin (7563 posts) - - Show Bio

Cap, but of course.
Avatar image for finalstar86
#16 Posted by FinalStar86 (8650 posts) - - Show Bio

Supes, Cap should stick to being a soldier, Supes is a lot smarter then Cap is.

Avatar image for spiderguylll
#17 Posted by spiderguylll (619 posts) - - Show Bio
@Night Thrasher said:
" Cap would win b/c Superman is an ILLEGAL ALIEN "
Avatar image for fist_of_mandalore
#18 Posted by Fist_of_Mandalore (1906 posts) - - Show Bio
@FinalStar86 said:
" Supes, Cap should stick to being a soldier, Supes is a lot smarter then Cap is. "
But is Supes as tactically savvy. 
Avatar image for mercy_
#19 Posted by Mercy_ (94554 posts) - - Show Bio
@PowerHerc: Sorry, still not a battle.  
Moderator
Avatar image for supermandefender
#20 Posted by supermandefender (2170 posts) - - Show Bio
@Night Thrasher: lol yeah.
Avatar image for finalstar86
#21 Posted by FinalStar86 (8650 posts) - - Show Bio
@Fist_of_Mandalore said:
" @FinalStar86 said:
" Supes, Cap should stick to being a soldier, Supes is a lot smarter then Cap is. "
But is Supes as tactically savvy.  "
No, that is why Cap would be better as a soldier while Supes handled the political BS
Avatar image for fist_of_mandalore
#22 Posted by Fist_of_Mandalore (1906 posts) - - Show Bio
@FinalStar86 said:
" @Fist_of_Mandalore said:
" @FinalStar86 said:
" Supes, Cap should stick to being a soldier, Supes is a lot smarter then Cap is. "
But is Supes as tactically savvy.  "
No, that is why Cap would be better as a soldier while Supes handled the political BS "
Yeah, but I was thinking. Superman is stronger, faster, etc. So you would want him defending Earth, while Cap does the political stuff. I mean a president should be tactically savvy with war and other stuff in which Cap has the edge.
Avatar image for freefa11
#23 Posted by Freefa11 (2488 posts) - - Show Bio

Cap has a pretty distinguished military career, which tends to count for a lot in presidential elections. I also think people might be concerned about Superman's abilities making him clearly more than human and harder to relate to. A lot of people like the idea of a president who can still see the world from the perspective of the "little guy," which is why candidates coming from humble origins tend to mention it a lot, whereas rich-kid candidates never talk about how well off they were they're whole lives. Superman, despite his country upbringing, is basically a god compared to normal people, and any claims to being just one of the guys are going to sound incredibly pretentious. Cap, despite the SS serum, is still clearly a normal human being, with normal human abilities, vulnerabilities, and concerns. 
 
One strike against Cap though, is he's single (as far as I'm aware). Americans seem to like family men. Of course, if we're talking Supes and not Clark Kent, then nobody would be able to know about Superman's wife either. But then, that brings up another issue; Superman has a very hidden life that people are going to want to know about. I think most people probably figure his real name isn't "Superman," and they'll probably want to know who he is before they actually give him control of the country. 
 
Oh, and sad to say, but intelligence doesn't count for beans in American presidential elections.

Avatar image for deadcool
#24 Posted by Deadcool (6940 posts) - - Show Bio

The Cap...

No Caption Provided