The same as the last thread- silver surfer is leading galactus to earth, a team is formed to stop him. Who wins?
Thor, Superman, Green lantern ( hal), Martian manhunter, wonder woman and magneto.
The same as the last thread- silver surfer is leading galactus to earth, a team is formed to stop him. Who wins?
Thor, Superman, Green lantern ( hal), Martian manhunter, wonder woman and magneto.
The team appear too powerful for Silver Surfer to win.
I suppose you could argue for Surfer to win based on technicality of how his powers work but I would be pretty surprised if someone with authority over these characters would really rank Silver Surfer as powerful enough to take on a team this powerful.
In short, theoretically it might be possible for Surfer to win but seem a bit far fetched given his normal portrayal.
This is of course assuming Galactus himself is not allowed to interfere. If he is then that becomes a different story.
@claymore1998: Arianrhod u r right.
@galactic_1000: thank you as always friend, you are very kind ^_^
Team stomps. Please stop these threads.
I'll do what I please, I appreciate your opinion but you don't have to answer.
This is of course assuming Galactus himself is not allowed to interfere. If he is then that becomes a different story.
Lol, no he definitely isn't allowed to intervene.
@breakingthrones: Haha sorry didn't mean to come off as aggressive. I meant the Surfer-wank in general has to stop.
@breakingthrones: ah okay then I stand by my original assessment. Theoretically we might be able to argue he wins but he does not appear powerful enough normally to take on all of them.
@breakingthrones: Haha sorry didn't mean to come off as aggressive. I meant the Surfer-wank in general has to stop.
Lol no worries but I'm not surfer wanking. I posted a thread before this in which I believed a team could beat him, most people disagreed so I improved the team. I'm trying to gage his power levels.
@breakingthrones: ah okay then I stand by my original assessment. Theoretically we might be able to argue he wins but he does not appear powerful enough normally to take on all of them.
Yeah I agree.
Typically he could solar drain superman but he might not get the chance with everyone else bombarding him. Magneto could create forcefields to shield them from his attacks- which are pretty damn strong. Superman can attempt to speed blitz him and surfer is susceptible to physical damage as proved when thanos beat him unconscious in several punches ( it would take clark much longer though). Thor can block and absorb energy attacks from him with mjolnir as well as keep him occupied with his own energy blasts. Martian manhunter can try telepathic attacks ( probably wouldn't work) and also attempt phasing, shape shifting etc.. Wonder woman can block his attacks with her bracelets and give him trouble with her sword, possibly even wrap her lasso around him, would he be able to phase through it or escape somehow? Green lantern can create shields and bombard him with energy blasts.
Another thing to bear in mind is that if SS phases or becomes intangible, superman can still hit him with heat vision as he has done it to phasers before ( not sure what it would actually do to SS though) it works on a molecular level.
All in all I think he is overwhelmed.
@breakingthrones: Fair enough. I think one on one Norrin has abilities that would allow him to overpower anyone here, perhaps Martian Manhunter might be the hardest for him. All on one though shouldn't really be fair.
At least in marvel, Surfer has lost against Thor both times when Thor has been bloodlusted. Norrin has also never actually beaten him before. So I think we both agree on the outcome. In fact looks like just about everyone does.
@breakingthrones: Fair enough. I think one on one Norrin has abilities that would allow him to overpower anyone here, perhaps Martian Manhunter might be the hardest for him. All on one though shouldn't really be fair.
At least in marvel, Surfer has lost against Thor both times when Thor has been bloodlusted. Norrin has also never actually beaten him before. So I think we both agree on the outcome. In fact looks like just about everyone does.
I think one on one surfer would beat any of them especially with his cosmic awareness.
superman - solar drain, Martian man hunter - resists his psychic attacks. Blasts him with cosmic energy. If he goes intangible he can replicate solar radiation and burn him on a molecular level. Magneto - he just phases through his forcefield and kills him. Green lantern he bombards him with cosmic energy, breaks his constructs or phases through and then kills him.
I think wonder woman and thor would be the hardest for him to beat.
Wonder woman - she can block his energy attacks but going all out he can travel much FTL and blitzes her and uses limitless cosmic energy.
Thor would be toughest but if surfer wasn't holding back he would bombard him with cosmic blasts, speed blitz him, phase etc.. he just has too much versatility and limitless energy where as thor doesn't and surfer can generate force fields to block some of his most powerful attacks which would also take a lot out of thor's life force.
@claymore1998: he beat him, i think they are even steven.If both are written corectly SS would take it everytime because of his powers(s).
@breakingthrones: He isn't putting down Hal that simple.Hal's blasts are as good as Norrin's if not better.He can also phase like Surfer and his constructs/autoshield has tanked Supernova like nothing
@breakingthrones: He isn't putting down Hal that simple.Hal's blasts are as good as Norrin's if not better.
But Hal is putting him down right?
@breakingthrones: He isn't putting down Hal that simple.Hal's blasts are as good as Norrin's if not better.
But Hal is putting him down right?
toss-up
aahahahaha yeah if you wanna argue this fanboy could shut your mouth up.Hal isn't going down that simple
@lemonsauce: yeah I'm a fanboy. But unlike you I know both of this characters capabilities.I never say my favorite character would beat someone who's more powerfull than him.When was the last time you've read Green Lantern issue ? pardon did you ever read a Lantern issue ? They're pretty close in every single department so it's a toss-up.
@breakingthrones: He isn't putting down Hal that simple.Hal's blasts are as good as Norrin's if not better.He can also phase like Surfer and his constructs/autoshield has tanked Supernova like nothing
hal and mmh can't take a no morals surfer,, its that simple.. It has nothing to do with how much their blasts are or anything like that. It has to do with what surfer can do to them... Now for this particular battle,, they have someone who could reconstitute surfer and that can bring them back from a bfr so the team itself has a good chance but those two do not...
@breakingthrones: He isn't putting down Hal that simple.Hal's blasts are as good as Norrin's if not better.He can also phase like Surfer and his constructs/autoshield has tanked Supernova like nothing
hal and mmh can't take a no morals surfer,, its that simple.. It has nothing to do with how much their blasts are or anything like that. It has to do with what surfer can do to them... Now for this particular battle,, they have someone who could reconstitute surfer and that can bring them back from a bfr so the team itself has a good chance but those two do not...
tell me what can Norrin do to Hal ?
@dorukesin1: Blast him to bits at super speed . For which Hal needs to *think* to react
@breakingthrones: He isn't putting down Hal that simple.Hal's blasts are as good as Norrin's if not better.He can also phase like Surfer and his constructs/autoshield has tanked Supernova like nothing
I hate to disagree but hal's blasts are not on the same level as surfer's. Surfer has a limitless supply of cosmic energy, Hal has a power ring that runs out of charge and can be broken ( as darkseid did) or his arm can be taken off. Surfer is faster and I'm not sure his auto-shields would react to someone that can travel to another galaxy in seconds. Surfer could blast through his shield's, it wouldn't take long.
Team
Thor has historically been a match for Surfer, add in all that help and the team has this in the bag 9/10 times.
@breakingthrones: He isn't putting down Hal that simple.Hal's blasts are as good as Norrin's if not better.He can also phase like Surfer and his constructs/autoshield has tanked Supernova like nothing
hal and mmh can't take a no morals surfer,, its that simple.. It has nothing to do with how much their blasts are or anything like that. It has to do with what surfer can do to them... Now for this particular battle,, they have someone who could reconstitute surfer and that can bring them back from a bfr so the team itself has a good chance but those two do not...
tell me what can Norrin do to Hal ?
absorb all his energy,,, take him to the astral plane,, atomize him,, heck he can take him on a journey through time... He is faster than hal...
@dorukesin1: when did Hals auto shields tank a nova ?
Team
Thor has historically been a match for Surfer, add in all that help and the team has this in the bag 9/10 times.
@lemonsauce: yeah I'm a fanboy. But unlike you I know both of this characters capabilities.I never say my favorite character would beat someone who's more powerfull than him.When was the last time you've read Green Lantern issue ? pardon did you ever read a Lantern issue ? They're pretty close in every single department so it's a toss-up.
If did, you wouldn't say Hal or J'onn could solo......
@dorukesin1: when did Hals auto shields tank a nova ?
@dorukesin1: .......what part of the OP says " pre crisis feats are allowed ?"
@ghostrider2: I suppose friend. While I do not agree with eventual outcome can't say I can disagree with your assessment. We seem to have very different appraisal of Norrin and what he is normally capable of.
I think a prudent course of action would be to agree to disagree though hopefully we get to debate again sometime soon. Perhaps next time we will find ourselves in the same side of the argument.
@dorukesin1: Blast him to bits at super speed . For which Hal needs to *think* to react
Hal got nanosecond reaction speed just like Surfer.Also on emergency situations his ring automatically dilates the time within a fraction of nanosecond(picoseconds) which even Norrin would look frozen
@breakingthrones: He isn't putting down Hal that simple.Hal's blasts are as good as Norrin's if not better.He can also phase like Surfer and his constructs/autoshield has tanked Supernova like nothing
hal and mmh can't take a no morals surfer,, its that simple.. It has nothing to do with how much their blasts are or anything like that. It has to do with what surfer can do to them... Now for this particular battle,, they have someone who could reconstitute surfer and that can bring them back from a bfr so the team itself has a good chance but those two do not...
tell me what can Norrin do to Hal ?
absorb all his energy,,, take him to the astral plane,, atomize him,, heck he can take him on a journey through time... He is faster than hal...
well Hal could also absorb his energy
Hal could also escape from Astral Plane with his will
Hal could also atomize him
Hal could travel in time and manipulate it
He isn't faster than Hal
@breakingthrones: He isn't putting down Hal that simple.Hal's blasts are as good as Norrin's if not better.He can also phase like Surfer and his constructs/autoshield has tanked Supernova like nothing
I hate to disagree but hal's blasts are not on the same level as surfer's. Surfer has a limitless supply of cosmic energy, Hal has a power ring that runs out of charge and can be broken ( as darkseid did) or his arm can be taken off. Surfer is faster and I'm not sure his auto-shields would react to someone that can travel to another galaxy in seconds. Surfer could blast through his shield's, it wouldn't take long.
One shotting Mandrakk(multiversal threat and beat Spectre)
Rookie Hal against Zero-Hour Parallax,he stalemated him for multiple pages,stated that their will power are equal and therefore they are on fairly equal terms.
Hal Jordan against an insane and deranged “Kyle Rayner” as Ion(Hand of God). He tried to talk him down, to calm him down and take him to get help, but “Kyle” gets enraged and attacked him, seemingly tryied to kill him. Hal one shotted him
also he took on Kyle as Parallax
one shotted Mongul
he blasted a hole through Amazo, who has the combined abilities of the Justice League (including Superman's durability).He was completely uneffected by Clark and Wally's blitz
@dorukesin1: when did Hals auto shields tank a nova ?
@dorukesin1: no he can't,, his energy is limited while surfer is borderline unlimited... He isn't as fast as Surfer either,,, and he can't escape the astral plane,, he dies there... I realize hal is your favorite character but he doesn't beat surfer... I would actually side with you if surfer was in character as it takes a ton to get him to react due to his nature but with him starting out of character, hal has no chance..
@dorukesin1: .......what part of the OP says " pre crisis feats are allowed ?"
it's from legends 1986 my friend.Not Pre-Crisis
@dorukesin1: You make some good arguments for Hal, I don't like surfer enough to provide a counter argument but if no-one else does I will later.
@dorukesin1: Something Hal did just the once and which since hasn't been shown to be something he or the ring is capable of even the time he actually er ...."died" , doesn't make for that great an argument
Based on one off showings Surfer sure can manipulate the Big Bangs energies itself to beat Galactus level beings
That aside GLs needing to " activate " their super speed , so to speak , to the point of even times John Stewart has his ring on auto fire , being unable to react to Superman , while otherwise having the ring pinched by the likes of Batman when not similarly amped , doesn't again, help the argument
Finally , when Hal actually explicitly has feats of trying to use the ring to keep up with his near light speed cousin and failing , when he gets left behind in the dust even when trying by Supes and Barry pushing it to another level , when he gets blitzed by Thawne on a day Supes is casually back handing him and saying their speeds are comparable ......no even with amped speed dude isn't as fast as the MFTL Surfer given his performances against the near light speed crowd
Other than that lots of out of context scans addressed to other people there . Keep it up . Just make sure you don't hurt yourself with all that stretching
@dorukesin1: Atomize Surfer? LOL!!! How the hell can you say you know both character's capabilities and not know Surfer has shrugged off Atomization? Hell Uni Lord tried it, and Surfer just put himself back together in no time.
@dorukesin1: I unfortunately have every single issue of the Legends mini and I can assure you nothing like that happens there
Heck Hal wasn't even involved in Legends IIRC
I'll bite anyway. Issue no?
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment