@ShootingNova: It might not be, but I noticed that on Wookiepedia's entry for Kallig's scorching lightsaber, it said that Kallig II also used it. But since that's Wookiepedia, who knows? Perhaps for simplicity's sake I'll specify that its Kallig's weapon in this fight.
@ShootingNova said:
What? Looks doesn't really mean anything, where is your proof they were not going all out? Why did Mace outlive his fellows? Because Sidious did not target him. He kept him alive for Anakin. He could have killed Windu before he could react:
Before Mace realizes what has happened, Kolar, Tiin, and Fisto have fallen to Sidious's blade.
--Taken from The Complete Visual Dictionary
So..... your argument doesn't work.
What do you mean looks don't mean anything? If character A is shown to be on the defensive for his entire duel with character B, then that suggests that character A is at least slightly inferior due to his being on the defensive the whole time. To say that looks don't mean anything is simply not true, although I will concede that in this scenario it is too ambiguous to say whether or not they're going all out. Because its debatable I'm going to withhold judgment on that scan.
And yet Mace lasted longer. Sidious went after Mace after killing the others. All four were surprised, and yet none of them lasted as long as Windu. They were surprised when Agen Kolar went down, and yet Saesee Tinn was killed in an instant before he could react while Mace Windu managed to hold his own, even after being "targeted" by Sidious. Sidious targeted all of them at some point or another because he was fighting all of them at some point or another. That said Mace doing better was likely due to the upgrade he received during the duel.
Also, this idea that he was "saving him" for Anakin comes off as ridiculous to me. Of course Palpatine does like his contrived schemes.
Finally, what story is that duel from? I never knew Saesee Tinn used a purple lightsaber. I thought the only known prequel-era Jedi who used purple lightsabers were Mace Windu and Ki-Adi-Mundi before he switched to blue.
Log in to comment