Rick Grimes vs Negan (Comic versions)

Round one

Rick still has his arm. No weapons. Morals on.

Round two

All out war version of Rick. Rick has his axe, Negan has Lucille. Morals off.

Round three

All out war Rick again. Rick thinks Negan has brutally killed Carl. Negan thinks Rick has broken Lucille.

Who would win each round and why?

Negan all rounds. The difference in strength is too much

@seagod: Don't you think Rick could just about kill anyone if they'd killed Carl? I think he'd be pretty pissed.

@hc03: Negan is just as bad when Lucille breaks

Negan comes out on top every single time they fight.

@rogueshadow: But Rick was never too bloodlusted in the fights. If carl died i think he would let out a side we've never seen before.

@hc03: he has

Yes he has, he went balls to the wall when he thought Andrea was dead and Negan still utterly punked him:

Or when Rick suspected Negan had killed Carl and Negan still wrecked him:

@rogueshadow: Really hate seeing protagonists just getting owned by the antagonist. Just doesn't feel right

TWD exists in a pretty realistic world though, Negan's like, what 6'5" and 250lb? All of it muscle. Rick's probably about 5'10", 160lb and only has one hand. I doubt even a professional fighter could bridge a gap like that. I like it, it keeps it real and reminds you that Rick is as vulnerable as anybody else and isn't going to win simply because he's the main character.

@seagod: Is that him dying?

Negan all rounds unless rick has prep he can't win

@rogueshadow: Do you think this will happen in the tv shows? Im not sure it will seeing as JDM isnt that much bigger than Andrew Lincoln

Yeah, I thought that myself, JDM is pretty scrawny to be honest, relative to his height he looks a lot skinnier than Lincoln. But I dunno, he lost to the Governor, though both were wounded. But TV Governor seemed tougher than TV Negan to me, we haven't really seen Negan do anything yet. On that note, the actor who plays Jesus is tiny, in height and weight, interested in seeing how do the scene where he takes Negan down (really hope they do, Jesus has been a bit of a let down for me).

Na.

@rabumalal: nah Negan is still alive but is going through some character development.

@rogueshadow: @seagod: I'm only some issues behind (after Negan loses), I know he is still around just thought he died to the new threat with the zombie-skin wearing people.

@rabumalal: nah won't spoil things for you though