Rey vs Luke Skywalker

vs

Rules:

Movie versions only

Both have lightsabers

Luke is ROTJ

Rey is end of EP 7 after beating the crap out of Ren

Luke.

Luke wins this.

Luke.

Luke.

Rey

Luke...

Lukee

Ends in...

Sigh...

Father/daughter bonding and parental conversations?

Luke easily

Reasons? Rey defeated Kylo Ren after all.

Why do you think so?

O.O

You do realise it's heavily implied she's his daughter, right?

@redzkz: Like, really?

@redzkz: ROTJ Luke defeated Vader; which is.....much better than anything Rey did. Fighting an injured Kylo Ren isn't really much of a feat - and the film clearly established that Kylo was weaker than Vader.

ROTJ Luke stomps.

Luke, of course.

She was five when her parents left her. I believe she should remember him if that is the case. Also Han or Leia could recognize her maybe?

Luke.

@redzkz: Just showed better skill and acrobatics, he solo'd Jabba's men in the sarlacc battle and contented with before defeating Vader. Noted by Yoda, Palps and Vader as being very powerful, showed ingenuity against the Rancor, so on and so forth.

Luke, but i'm sure they'll have great sparring matches in the next one and she might be able to beat him after more training.

Luke, not even close at the moment. Rey will get stronger though, but probably won't get to Luke's level

Luke. Rey had trouble beating a bleeding to death pansy who threw temper tantrums like a cartoon character.

@sirfizzwhizz said:

Luke. Rey had trouble beating a bleeding to death pansy who threw temper tantrums like a cartoon character.

LOL thank you! They could've handled his character better instead of making him a spoiled "sith" brat.

Luke cuts her to pieces

Luke

@eisenfauste: considering who his grandfather is, are you really surprised?

@dbzk1999: Vader during this era didn't act anything other than professional

Luke. He defeated Darth Vadar, who is much stronger than Kylo Ren. And Rey only defeated Kylo Ren because he was injured. And the fact that Rey is seeking Luke's training obviously means she's nowhere near Luke's level.

Luke is more impressive by RoTJ. ESB Luke might be a good match, but I think he can still win that.

@eisenfauste: I'm talking about anakin, not vader

@eisenfauste: I personally dont see anything wrong with the way they did his character. Ita different and vecause hes not an immediate badass. Everyone whines just as much as he does.

Luke stomps.

Lol Rey had one moment in the spotlight and suddenly people think he can take the guy he beat Vader. K

@nerdchore: Eh all he ever does is ignite his lightsaber and destroy equipment around him. Sure he's not a mature force user but does he need to be written as an idiot as well. On top of that all he and an imperial "moff" did was shout at each other. Moff's are extremely professional in all the past movies, on top of that they resign their command to the nearest force user. So now we have a whiny idiot force user and an unprofessional moff. Makes for an out of character dynamic that was pretty poorly written

luke is so pathetic, im tempted to say rey

Rey wins on the basis that she's a better character.

@wollfmyth209: Really... Daisy's performance was pretty weak tbh...

@wiese: Nah. I found both her performance and the character itself rather enjoyable.

@wollfmyth209: Because she's hot right?

@wiese: That only has like 25% to do with it... And she's not that hot. She's just sort of, pretty and nice to look at.

Luke stomps.

Luke

How? Her only character trait is that she's somehow good at everything and everyone loves her

@bullettimer: Only no, it isn't. Her being good at everything, which isn't even true, would be based around her being a powerful Force sensitive, as the Force allows for great innate talent and ability. Though for a person who isn't an expert, or even an above average Star Wars fan it would seem like she's a Mary Sue.

Luke spanks this untrained beginner.

@wollfmyth209:

She's undeniably a Mary Sue.

The Mary Sue wins.