• 86 results
  • 1
  • 2
Avatar image for erik
#1 Posted by Erik (32504 posts) - - Show Bio

Round 1: No weapons at all for Punisher, no claws or healing factor for Wolverine.

Round 2: Same as round 1 except now Wolverine also has no adamantium skeleton.
Round 3: In the jungle, no prep, standard equipment for both.
Round 4: All out in an abandoned city. 48 hours of prep for both.

All rounds are fights to the death. Let us get it on!
Avatar image for high_revolutionary
#2 Posted by High Revolutionary (3210 posts) - - Show Bio

Round one.  Wolverine.  Adamantium bones hurt (to punch).

Round two. Punisher's fighting style it lethal (ala Anderson Sylva) - Wolverine will just run his mouth as usual.

Round three.  Wolverine, easily.

Round four.  Punisher, easily.

What??  Big John McCarthy is reffing???

Avatar image for lunacyde
#3 Posted by Lunacyde (24446 posts) - - Show Bio

1. Wolverine
2. Wolverine....but close
3. Wolverine
4.Punisher

Moderator
Avatar image for logic_mark_iii
#4 Posted by Logic Mark III (2132 posts) - - Show Bio

Wolverine can win all of them. He is a better close combatant than Castle.

Prep...Beast make a virus lethal to humans or Storm send a tsunami the cities way.

Avatar image for claws
#5 Posted by claws (5266 posts) - - Show Bio

wolverine easily for all of them execpt for round 4 i'm not who will win there

Avatar image for erik
#6 Posted by Erik (32504 posts) - - Show Bio

No one else? I thought I made a pretty diverse setup here.

Avatar image for bioghost
#7 Posted by bioghost (1275 posts) - - Show Bio

logan
frank
depend if frank make a couple traps for logan
frank easily

Avatar image for donovan_montgomery
#8 Posted by Donovan Montgomery (5752 posts) - - Show Bio

Wolverine
Punisher, in the best fight of all 4
Wolverine
Wolverine, Punisher would get off some pretty spectacular hits but Wolverine would just shug them off with his healing factor. 

Avatar image for ferro_vida
#9 Posted by Ferro Vida (34318 posts) - - Show Bio

Wolverine
Punisher
Wolverine, unless Frank can pull something spectacular.
Punisher

Avatar image for blade_hunter
#10 Posted by blade hunter (1917 posts) - - Show Bio

wolverine would win all 4 rounds

Avatar image for erik
#11 Posted by Erik (32504 posts) - - Show Bio

In my opinion, the only round Frank has a reasonable chance at winning is round 4. I would still lean towards Wolverine though. 

Avatar image for the_scourge
#12 Posted by The_Scourge (5335 posts) - - Show Bio
Wolverine
Wolverine
Wolverine
Frank
Avatar image for telekineticsun
#13 Posted by TelekineticSun (359 posts) - - Show Bio

Wolverine wins all four fights... even without his healing and his adamantium skeliton wolverine will win the first 2 fights...hes a better fighter, hes an ex soldier of two wars,hes a cia trained agent and also trained as a samurai, hes a master as multiple forms of martial arts...
punisher was a soldier also but is still think wolverine has it in a fist fight...
and in the last 2 fights when wolverine has his powers ...its a no brainer... in the jungle or in an abandoned city no prep or 48 hours of it wolverine takes it becuase of his mutant ability and skills with the slashing. SNIKT

Avatar image for blade_hunter
#14 Posted by blade hunter (1917 posts) - - Show Bio
High Revolutionary said:
"Round one.  Wolverine.  Adamantium bones hurt (to punch).Round two. Punisher's fighting style it lethal (ala Anderson Sylva) - Wolverine will just run his mouth as usual.Round three.  Wolverine, easily.Round four.  Punisher, easily.What??  Big John McCarthy is reffing???"

wolverine is a master of all forms of hand to hand combat, he'll be able to deal with frank in a hand to hand fight.
Avatar image for darkzola
#15 Posted by darkzola (84 posts) - - Show Bio

Logan all the way to round 4. Then Castle with his prep time obtains Carbonadium, uses it in his bullets and job done.

Avatar image for erik
#16 Posted by Erik (32504 posts) - - Show Bio
darkzola said:
"Logan all the way to round 4. Then Castle with his prep time obtains Carbonadium, uses it in his bullets and job done.
"
There are only two carbonadium bullets left in the world and Bucky has them. There is no other carbonadium left. Wolverine hid the synthesizer. 
Avatar image for claws
#17 Posted by claws (5266 posts) - - Show Bio

why are all rounds fight to the death punisher cant kill him

Avatar image for erik
#18 Posted by Erik (32504 posts) - - Show Bio

Wolverine can die. Especially without his powers. 

Avatar image for claws
#19 Posted by claws (5266 posts) - - Show Bio

oh i read wrong

Avatar image for detective
#20 Posted by Detective (582 posts) - - Show Bio

Round 1: Wolverine
Round 2: Punisher
Round 3: Wolverine
Round 4: Punisher

Avatar image for erik
#21 Posted by Erik (32504 posts) - - Show Bio

How does Punisher win any of those rounds?

Avatar image for loganreme
#22 Posted by loganreme (1401 posts) - - Show Bio

Wolverine
wolverine
wolverine
wolverine

Logan has his animal instincts, he's a hunter, lethal combat skills and just too damn stubborn to die, regardless of his admantium and healing factor.

Avatar image for loganreme
#23 Posted by loganreme (1401 posts) - - Show Bio
blade hunter said:
"High Revolutionary said:
"Round one.  Wolverine.  Adamantium bones hurt (to punch).Round two. Punisher's fighting style it lethal (ala Anderson Sylva) - Wolverine will just run his mouth as usual.Round three.  Wolverine, easily.Round four.  Punisher, easily.What??  Big John McCarthy is reffing???"
wolverine is a master of all forms of hand to hand combat, he'll be able to deal with frank in a hand to hand fight."

Wolverine doesn't run his mouth, he let's his fist do the talking SNIKT......
Avatar image for detective
#24 Posted by Detective (582 posts) - - Show Bio

Punisher is a survivalist, the man dosent go down, and you give Frank 48 horus of prep (round 4) god knows what hes gonna do

Avatar image for blade_hunter
#25 Posted by blade hunter (1917 posts) - - Show Bio
Detective said:
"

Punisher is a survivalist, the man dosent go down, and you give Frank 48 horus of prep (round 4) god knows what hes gonna do

"
Wolverine gets Emma Frost 2 come in and metally turn Frank in to a little girl.
Avatar image for claws
#26 Posted by claws (5266 posts) - - Show Bio

okay wolverine wins the first round he is an better fighter
wolverine wins the second round to moving the adamantium would make him faster
wolverine wins again guns really wont do much
and i dont see how punisher could kill wolverine so wolverine wins there too

Avatar image for blade_hunter
#27 Posted by blade hunter (1917 posts) - - Show Bio
claws said:
"okay wolverine wins the first round he is an better fighterwolverine wins the second round to moving the adamantium would make him fasterwolverine wins again guns really wont do muchand i dont see how punisher could kill wolverine so wolverine wins there too"

Wolverine would be a his best in an abandoned city, Frank couldn't hide from him and wolverine would just hunt him down.
Avatar image for claws
#28 Posted by claws (5266 posts) - - Show Bio
blade hunter said:
"claws said:
"okay wolverine wins the first round he is an better fighterwolverine wins the second round to moving the adamantium would make him fasterwolverine wins again guns really wont do muchand i dont see how punisher could kill wolverine so wolverine wins there too"
Wolverine would be a his best in an abandoned city, Frank couldn't hide from him and wolverine would just hunt him down."
true
Avatar image for incredible_hulk_prime
#29 Posted by Incredible Hulk-Prime (1525 posts) - - Show Bio

I think Wolverine would win after all he has a hearing factor and is the strongest  man of the X-Men.If Punisher defeated Wolverine that would mean he can beat all of the X-Men.

Avatar image for batdance
#30 Posted by BatDance (2249 posts) - - Show Bio
erik said:
"How does Punisher win any of those rounds?"
48 hr prep! Frank gets out the BFGs and just RPGs Wolverine to death, IMO the rest of the battles Wolverine will win
Avatar image for jasraj
#31 Posted by jasraj (4923 posts) - - Show Bio

wolverine wins all 4 i mean
Avatar image for jasraj
#32 Posted by jasraj (4923 posts) - - Show Bio
@erik:
 he doesnt 
 
wolverine wins
Avatar image for d3athstroke
#33 Posted by D3athstroke (5115 posts) - - Show Bio

Round 1: Punisher (Without Healing Factor Adamantium Will kill Him)
Round 2: Punisher
Round 3: Wolverine
Round 4: Punisher

Avatar image for erik
#34 Posted by Erik (32504 posts) - - Show Bio
@D3athstroke said:
" Round 1: Punisher (Without Healing Factor Adamantium Will kill Him)Round 2: PunisherRound 3: WolverineRound 4: Punisher "
Adamantium did not instantly kill Wolverine and since Wolverine had the adamantium bonded to him by Apocalypse, he has not shown that this is the case anymore. When Wolverine still had the classic adamantium and lost his healing factor, it still took days for him to die. 
Avatar image for god_spawn
#35 Posted by God_Spawn (40488 posts) - - Show Bio

Im leaning towards logan on all 4 but Frank definitely has a chance at the 4th atleast.  
 
Logan 3/4 
Moderator
Avatar image for mrragepants
#36 Posted by MrRagePants (858 posts) - - Show Bio
Round 1: No weapons at all for Punisher, no claws or healing factor for Wolverine. 
I would vote for Logan but in a close fight. His edge would be his speed and adamantium bones, that will hurt Frank BIG TIME. Also, I read a comic where Logan and Hank (Beast) was sent in a prison where it dampens their mutant abilities, no HF for Logan there and he was owning every prisoner like b*tches. He also commented on two jobber villains (I forgot their names), who he said "In the outside they are nothing but in here where there are no powers and only H2H fighting, they are the best". I'm not saying Frank cannot reach that status in prison, but it's just awesome.

Round 2: Same as round 1 except now Wolverine also has no adamantium skeleton. 
If we say both are even in terms of H2H fighting, Logan would still have the speed advantage. But this will be a VERY VERY VERY close fight, it's so close I am also voting for Frank.

Round 3: In the jungle, no prep, standard equipment for both.
Wolverine, bullets got nothing on Adamantium + Healing Factor.

Round 4: All out in an abandoned city. 48 hours of prep for both.
Frank. I see him setting up traps and sh*t that will really mess up Logan. Logan won't benefit much from prep, he goes rambo often and relies heavily on his HF and bones.
 
 
I still find Frank more bad ass than Wolverine, guy doesn't even have any super powers and he's regarded as one of the best in MU.
Avatar image for deadpoolwins__
#37 Posted by deadpoolwins:) (135 posts) - - Show Bio

wolverine wins, because hes a better tracker, fighter, martial artist, he can heal, and has an adamantium skeleton. punisher has a gun. pwn

Avatar image for csimon
#38 Posted by csimon (2207 posts) - - Show Bio

Wolverine 4 the win in all 4 Rounds
Avatar image for mrragepants
#39 Posted by MrRagePants (858 posts) - - Show Bio
@deadpoolwins:) said:
" wolverine wins, because hes a better tracker, fighter, martial artist, he can heal, and has an adamantium skeleton. punisher has a gun. pwn "
What makes you say Logan is a better fighter than Frank? I would understand being a better tracker as his sense of smell is beyond human.
Avatar image for jasraj
#40 Posted by jasraj (4923 posts) - - Show Bio

wolverine wins all 4
Avatar image for fearmonger
#41 Edited by FearMonger (12 posts) - - Show Bio
  • Round 1: Wolverine, because he has an adamantium skeletal structure and far above normal human strength and endurance, I think his hand-to-hand combat is better than punisher is.
  • Round  2: Wolverine, even though Wolverines greatest weapons have been taken away from him. I think Wolverine is a better hand-to-hand fighter than the punisher.
  • Round 3: Wolverine, he has been through many wars and has accumulated massive amounts of battle experience. He has animal like instincts and army tactics.
  • Round 4: If its an all out fight with all abilities and equipment usable, and there is a 48 hour prep. If punisher can get adamantium bullets or weaponry, and plan out a battle strategy, then he will win. But I think Wolverine will win. If Wolverine has no regeneration and no adamantium, then he will lose in the end.

 
 
Note: I am not a Wolverine fan-boy. These are just my opinions lol xD.

Avatar image for angryvigilante
#42 Posted by angryvigilante (1866 posts) - - Show Bio

Logan
Frank
Too close to call
Frank

Avatar image for steverodgers
#43 Posted by SteveRodgers (770 posts) - - Show Bio

the punisher
Avatar image for deadpoolwins__
#44 Posted by deadpoolwins:) (135 posts) - - Show Bio
@MrRagePants:  2 reasons, 1 James(logan) was like number 7 on marvels top ten martial artists of all time, which frank was not on, and in official stats james has a 7 out of 7 in fighting skill, while frank has a 5 out of 7. 
this is completely avoiding the fact that wolverine is at least 100 years older, was a samurai, and that daken, wolverine's son killed the punisher
Avatar image for mercy_
#45 Posted by Mercy_ (94500 posts) - - Show Bio
@Lunacyde said:
" 1. Wolverine2. Wolverine....but close3. Wolverine4.Punisher "
Moderator
Avatar image for jasraj
#46 Posted by jasraj (4923 posts) - - Show Bio

wolverine wins all
Avatar image for battleheiz
#47 Posted by BattleHeiz (693 posts) - - Show Bio

Frank
Frank
Logan
Frank

Avatar image for saiyan_earthling
#48 Posted by saiyan_earthling (5889 posts) - - Show Bio
  1. Logan
  2. Logan
  3. Logan
  4. 50/50
Avatar image for lends
#49 Posted by lends (1 posts) - - Show Bio

wolverine has the agility strength and fighting style. punisher is only a normal human but wolverine is a mutant and wolverine is much stronger than a ordinary person.

Avatar image for nefarious
#50 Posted by Nefarious (32416 posts) - - Show Bio

Wolverine wins all of the rounds.