Persian army vs. Orc army

persians from 300 against Orcs from lord of the rings who can win in a war?

the orcs by a landslide......are we talking about the army as a whole or what

the_haunter says:

" the orcs by a landslide......are we talking about the army as a whole or what"

Whole or not, Orcs can overwhelm Persians, especially in an open field. Just look at what they did while in Minas Tirith and Osgiliath: they came in immense war-bands and just took over due to their numbers. If they can take down something like Minas Tirith in a few days, imagine what they can do to Persians who got pwned by 300 Spartans.

Warsman says:

"the_haunter says:

" the orcs by a landslide......are we talking about the army as a whole or what"

Whole or not, Orcs can overwhelm Persians, especially in an open field. Just look at what they did while in Minas Tirith and Osgiliath: they came in immense war-bands and just took over due to their numbers. If they can take down something like Minas Tirith in a few days, imagine what they can do to Persians who got pwned by 300 Spartans."

i was asking if the worgs and cave-trolls were involved......

the_haunter says:

"Warsman says:

"the_haunter says:

" the orcs by a landslide......are we talking about the army as a whole or what"

Whole or not, Orcs can overwhelm Persians, especially in an open field. Just look at what they did while in Minas Tirith and Osgiliath: they came in immense war-bands and just took over due to their numbers. If they can take down something like Minas Tirith in a few days, imagine what they can do to Persians who got pwned by 300 Spartans."

i was asking if the worgs and cave-trolls were involved......"

Then that would be overdoing it a bit, don't you think?

Warsman says:

"the_haunter says:

"Warsman says:

"the_haunter says:

" the orcs by a landslide......are we talking about the army as a whole or what"

Whole or not, Orcs can overwhelm Persians, especially in an open field. Just look at what they did while in Minas Tirith and Osgiliath: they came in immense war-bands and just took over due to their numbers. If they can take down something like Minas Tirith in a few days, imagine what they can do to Persians who got pwned by 300 Spartans."

i was asking if the worgs and cave-trolls were involved......"

Then that would be overdoing it a bit, don't you think?"

just covering the bases.......i did'nt know if he was including the elephants and rhinos(like it would make a difference) and those magician guys

the_haunter says:

"Warsman says:

"the_haunter says:

"Warsman says:

"the_haunter says:

" the orcs by a landslide......are we talking about the army as a whole or what"

Whole or not, Orcs can overwhelm Persians, especially in an open field. Just look at what they did while in Minas Tirith and Osgiliath: they came in immense war-bands and just took over due to their numbers. If they can take down something like Minas Tirith in a few days, imagine what they can do to Persians who got pwned by 300 Spartans."

i was asking if the worgs and cave-trolls were involved......"

Then that would be overdoing it a bit, don't you think?"

just covering the bases.......i did'nt know if he was including the elephants and rhinos(like it would make a difference) and those magician guys"

With the Mumakil it would be a simple massacre. Those things turned 6,000 Rohirrim, the best horseback riders in Middle-earth at the time, into arrow-ridden pulp. With just one of those monsters, the Persians won't stand a chance no matter how hard they tried.

Post Deleted.

Post Deleted.