Percy Jackson vs. Eragon

@Jezer: Fair enough I can agree with that. But Murtagh only beat him because in their sword fight Eragon was already exhausted from using too much Magic. And Murtagh beat him by using the Eldunari to become more powerfull.

@TheMightyAvenger said:

@Jezer: Fair enough I can agree with that. But Murtagh only beat him because in their sword fight Eragon was already exhausted from using too much Magic. And Murtagh beat him by using the Eldunari to become more powerfull.

Okay... Been a couple of years since I read that book in the series.

@Jezer: Yeah me too. but I remember Eragon saying that the guy he was fighting ( he didn't know it was Murtagh ) was not as strong or fast as an elf, but that his skill was really good, he also said the way the stranger was fighting seemed familiar, and then when Murtagh revealed himself he was overwhelmed by his magica power.

@TheMightyAvenger said:

@Jezer: Yeah me too. but I remember Eragon saying that the guy he was fighting ( he didn't know it was Murtagh ) was not as strong or fast as an elf, but that his skill was really good, he also said the way the stranger was fighting seemed familiar, and then when Murtagh revealed himself he was overwhelmed by his magica power.

So Murtagh fighting at non-elf speed was able to keep up with an exhausted Eragon due to fighting skill?

@Jezer: He already had some enhancements, but he was not at elf levels yet. So yes you are correct, Murtagh has always been a better fighter than Eragon in my opinion.

Percy. He's invulnerable, what's Eragon gonna do?

Percy would win if he can get earagon of the dragon or kill it.

@CitezenBane I believe both have graphic novels

Eragon.... 
Breaks into his mind, uses a death word. If that doesnt work, he presses harder, causing percy unbearable pain. Once he finds the reason his death word didnt work, he walks over to percy and stabs him in the part where he's vulnerable. Or, if Saphira is present she could simply douse percy in fire, which would work since it would cause full body damage, eventually reaching percy's weak point. 

Eragon or Saphira could solo imo..

@buttersdaman000 said:

Eragon.... Breaks into his mind, uses a death word. If that doesnt work, he presses harder, causing percy unbearable pain. Once he finds the reason his death word didnt work, he walks over to percy and stabs him in the part where he's vulnerable. Or, if Saphira is present she could simply douse percy in fire, which would work since it would cause full body damage, eventually reaching percy's weak point.

The main problem with these scenarios is that you don't explain them while considering the fact Percy isn't gonna stand around twiddling his thumbs while Eragon "walks over to percy and stabs him in the part where he's vulnerable" or gets doused in fire.

Percy can control water....he's seriously gonna just chill while's he's being burned alive?

@buttersdaman000 said:

Eragon.... Breaks into his mind, uses a death word. If that doesnt work, he presses harder, causing percy unbearable pain. Once he finds the reason his death word didnt work, he walks over to percy and stabs him in the part where he's vulnerable. Or, if Saphira is present she could simply douse percy in fire, which would work since it would cause full body damage, eventually reaching percy's weak point.

The main problem with these scenarios is that you don't explain them while considering the fact Percy isn't gonna stand around twiddling his thumbs while Eragon "walks over to percy and stabs him in the part where he's vulnerable" or gets doused in fire.

Percy can control water....he's seriously gonna just chill while's he's being burned alive?

I'm an avid fan of both and I can tell you this is horrible spite. Eragon annihilates. Not sure why you'd even put Saphira in there, just overkill.

Eragon has the speed and strength of an elf. Percy's combat feats don't even touch Eragons.

Percy can control water, but Eragon is a powerful spellcaster and can control most things. Add on top of that him knowing the true name of the ancient language.

Eragon has SOLID telepathy feats. He took control of minds of standard spellcasters with relative ease.

Add onto that Saphira, a huge dragon trained well in combat and also capable of powerful spellweaving.

Percy Jackson is so outmatched its a joke. Trust me, I'm VERY familiar with both characters.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

For Eragon to win it's as simple as him taking over Percy's mind and making him walk outside of the river. Eragon is free to have Saphira melt him, stab him in the face or use a simple death word.

@BlueLantern1995: ah ha! How will he stop saphira?

Percy should win, in the so of neptune he was able to create small cyclones, large waves nearly the size of tsunami, control water to a very powerful extent ...

@CalamitySam HAHAHAHA in water Percy has the strength and speed of a titan. Titans>>>>Elves. And all those things you said at the bottom would have no effect. He's invulnerable. Plus... and this has been done before (demigod files) Percy's mind was taken control of by Phobus the god of fear and he easily snapped out of it cause the fish in water can communicate with him and help him escape mind control. So yeah if there's a river around telepathy won't work, swords and fire won't work....... are you actually a fan of Percy, or had you read Eragon and you're making assumptions about Percy.

With morals off Eragon could just break into Percy's mind and drain all his energy.

@buttersdaman000 said:

@Jezer said:

@buttersdaman000 said:

Eragon.... Breaks into his mind, uses a death word. If that doesnt work, he presses harder, causing percy unbearable pain. Once he finds the reason his death word didnt work, he walks over to percy and stabs him in the part where he's vulnerable. Or, if Saphira is present she could simply douse percy in fire, which would work since it would cause full body damage, eventually reaching percy's weak point.

The main problem with these scenarios is that you don't explain them while considering the fact Percy isn't gonna stand around twiddling his thumbs while Eragon "walks over to percy and stabs him in the part where he's vulnerable" or gets doused in fire.

Percy can control water....he's seriously gonna just chill while's he's being burned alive?

That's the thing, Percy wont have a chance. Eragon will almost immediately go for the telepathic assault, leaving Percy open for anything. He won't have a chance to fight back. And, it wouldnt really matter if he can control water because, as it was proved in another thread, once that spot gets injured, Percy is dead.

You make a good point, I completely forgot that telepathic assaults in Eragon paralyze the person assaulted.

@Jezer said:

@TheMightyAvenger said:

@Jezer: Percy is not invulnerable anymore.

I'm almost positive the Percy in this thread is the invunerable one that was featured throughout most of the last book.

@TheMightyAvenger:

It was meant to be when he was invulnerable. During the first five.

I am not sure why Eragon would need morals off to attack Percy's mind. Attacking the mind is standard operating procedure in Eragon's worlds. He should find out about said weakpoint and especially the boost Percy gets in water. Also where is the prove that Percy is immune against internal attacks. Why can Eragon not pinch off a few nerves?

@BlueLantern1995: Saphira could just throw him out the water and then claw his entire body until she hit his vulnerable point. I think we get to use current versions cos the OP doesn't specify otherwise..

PJ wins he has complete control over the waters he can create huge waves, has water solidification , Water Propulsion, water immuntity, healing, water breathing,etc... he can also create tornadoes and controls the air, can cause earthquakes and with the achilies curse he held up the cosmos so yeah he stomps

@justleader: No.

@BlueLantern1995: Out of water he isn't strong enough to break free from Saphira's grip IIRC..

@BlueLantern1995: Just by being a dragon she is already strong enough, add on her magic (despite its unpredictability) she will get him out.

@justleader said:

PJ wins he has complete control over the waters he can create huge waves, has water solidification , Water Propulsion, water immuntity, healing, water breathing,etc... he can also create tornadoes and controls the air, can cause earthquakes and with the achilies curse he held up the cosmos so yeah he stomps

One word can kill Percy. One. Word.

@BlueLantern1995 said:

@The_Thunderer Well first off we play like it is when he is invulnerable till otherwise noted. Problem with what you said about Sapphira is Percy won't stay still for it and so could dodge attack slash, dodge slash so on. All Percy needs to do is dodge attack until one of them is down and he wins.

Percy may be physically invulnerable, but i do believe that only applied to his exterior. Eragon can simply close off every nerve ending/vein in his brain, rendering him practically dead. That, or break into his mid, leaving him a driveling, broken fool.

All in all, horrid spite. Eragon stomps effortlessly.

@JediWaffles: Eragon could quite easily just get Percy to work out and tell Eragon his true name using TP then this battle becomes redundant.

@JediWaffles: Percy isn't physically invulnerable. Like Achilles' weakness was his heel, Percy's back was his weakness.

@The_Thunderer: Yeah this battle should have been dead a long time ago

^^^This fight is quite debatable.

@logy5000: not really.

If there's water around and it's book 5 percy, than he's above the level of gods and titans. The gods and titans are above the level of the elves.

Percy wins this.

The fight says that there's a river 10 feet from Percy. Percy wins as long as he stays in that river. Eragon and Saphira win if they can get him out of the water.

percy wins and can yall comment on my Spider Man vs Iron Fist thread please

Who's iron fist?

a marvel superhero well you want to comment

Eragon wins for reasons already stated. Multiple times. 

Percy wins for reasons that should be obvious. Death words won't work, swords won't work. Percy (in water) is faster and stronger. He is without a doubt more durable. I don't see Percy winning. And compare the villains. Galbatorix vs Kronos? Kronos would own him.

Correction. I don't see Eragon winning.

The only way to kill him is to hit the only mortal part of him, his back. Anything in the brain won't work. Percy has defeated people with telepathic abilities, such as ares, phobus, hyperion, and kronos. His mind has been taken control of before, and he snapped out of it cause fish aided him in breaking out of it. There will be fish in a river. Percy won't sit there and count sheep while Eragon walks up to stab him. Percy has much better control of water, he can create hurricanes and earthquakes. Hurricanes and earthquakes > telepathy.

I feel like a champ when I see an old post and that it's still really popular. :D

^^^Lol

@logy5000 said:

The only way to kill him is to hit the only mortal part of him, his back. Anything in the brain won't work. Percy has defeated people with telepathic abilities, such as ares, phobus, hyperion, and kronos. His mind has been taken control of before, and he snapped out of it cause fish aided him in breaking out of it. There will be fish in a river. Percy won't sit there and count sheep while Eragon walks up to stab him. Percy has much better control of water, he can create hurricanes and earthquakes. Hurricanes and earthquakes > telepathy.

Again where is the proof that Eragon cannot pinch a few blood vessels and kill Percy?

How do death words work exactly?

Percy jackson wins for me cuz his film was better and has water so he wins

@Skaddix Because that wouldn't work. The only mortal part of him is his back. If it was that easy kronos would have done it.

PJ

Now that all of you have gone on and on about death words and blood vessels. How about you take into consideration that Percy has defeated more powerful opponents than Eragon has.

I haven't read the Percy books but, assuming Eragon could break into Percy's mind and find the spot, I'm betting he could reach it with the Elf speed, strength and agility. And even if he couldn't effect Percy directly...maybe he could do something to the water???