Avatar image for ronin_alexsnder
#1 Posted by ronin alexsnder (7747 posts) - - Show Bio

okay heath vs jack as the duo of jokers who wins.

who is the better joker.

in a fight who wins.

who was more sadistic.


Avatar image for unbelonger
#2 Posted by Unbelonger (1801 posts) - - Show Bio

You could compare them accurately if it was the same movie, which is not the case.


zzzzzzzz

Avatar image for thisisgonnahurt
#3 Posted by ThisIsGonnaHurt (38319 posts) - - Show Bio

Jack

Heath

Heath

Avatar image for thedrifter
#4 Posted by TheDrifter (24811 posts) - - Show Bio
caption
caption

















Jack has always been my favorite (However I have not seen TDK)
Avatar image for ronin_alexsnder
#5 Posted by ronin alexsnder (7747 posts) - - Show Bio
Unbelonger said:
"You could compare them accurately if it was the same movie, which is not the case.


zzzzzzzz"
huh? im really trying to make sense of what you just said!
Avatar image for king_saturn
#6 Posted by King Saturn (220733 posts) - - Show Bio
I think Heath Ledger may have been a better Joker than Jack... but the margin of victory is very slim
Avatar image for korg
#7 Posted by Korg (11351 posts) - - Show Bio

Heath, easily. Jack just played himself, as he does in most of his movies. Ledger immersed himself in the character.

Avatar image for king_saturn
#8 Posted by King Saturn (220733 posts) - - Show Bio
Korg said:
"Heath, easily. Jack just played himself, as he does in most of his movies. Ledger immersed himself in the character."
Thats Correct Korg...
Avatar image for ego
#9 Posted by Ego (2528 posts) - - Show Bio
Korg said:
"Heath, easily. Jack just played himself, as he does in most of his movies. Ledger immersed himself in the character."

agreed. eventhough i love jacks version of the joker... that is.... just how he is natually. but heath was increadible! i couldn't even recongized him.

anyways that's just acting skills but in a fight between the two i don't know. one is serious pychopath that wants his targets to look like a fool.. while the other was a joking laughing stock pychopath that wanted his taargets to "die with a smile"

Avatar image for sesaw
#10 Posted by SeSAW (3694 posts) - - Show Bio
Korg said:
"Heath, easily. Jack just played himself, as he does in most of his movies. Ledger immersed himself in the character."
that's true but i say jack only because he set the standard for all jokers and Heath has compounded on what jack did.
Avatar image for we_are_legend
#11 Posted by We Are Legend (4769 posts) - - Show Bio

Heath Ledger's performance was Oscar Worthy.

The new Joker shows more combat and intellegent strategies.

Heath Ledger  completely embraced the joker and is more relatable to the comics in my opinion. He is just insane.

 

Avatar image for korg
#12 Posted by Korg (11351 posts) - - Show Bio

 SeSAW said:

"that's true but i say jack only because he set the standard for all jokers and Heath has compounded on what jack did."
All Jack did was act like Jack. He didn't do jack. Even comparing his performance to Ledger's in my eyes is demeaning.
Avatar image for we_are_legend
#13 Posted by We Are Legend (4769 posts) - - Show Bio

I gotta say watching the pencil trick was hilarious.

Avatar image for nightfang3
#14 Posted by NightFang3 (12106 posts) - - Show Bio

Heath is the best Joker.

Avatar image for the_time_lord
#15 Posted by The Time Lord (274 posts) - - Show Bio

seeming as Heath has helped brake a box office record(or summin like that), has been nominated for an Oscar for his performance(even though he's dead ='{ ) and has mind swept the great Michael Caine with his performance, I think he wins all =]

don't get  me wrong, Jack's great too, but watching his movie, I really didn't get the feel for the true joker.

Avatar image for warlock360
#16 Posted by warlock360 (28181 posts) - - Show Bio
  
Avatar image for perfect_cell
#17 Posted by Perfect Cell (3719 posts) - - Show Bio

The pencil "trick" was awesome.

Avatar image for warlock360
#18 Posted by warlock360 (28181 posts) - - Show Bio

yea epic^^

Avatar image for perfect_cell
#19 Posted by Perfect Cell (3719 posts) - - Show Bio

And also loved the way he lied. Telling Two Face that he wasn't a scheamer, but a mad dog let loose. The Joker was the ultimate scheamer. He made a fool out of everyone in that movie: even Gordon!

Avatar image for warlock360
#20 Posted by warlock360 (28181 posts) - - Show Bio

yea (even batman) and btw, comming to think that two face was known as the white knight, the movie was probably not about batman being the dark knight but jokers manipulation of harvey becomming two face

Avatar image for darth_balls
#21 Posted by Darth Balls (751 posts) - - Show Bio

i saw the dark knight and heath ledger was an aMAZING JOKER. FLAWLESS PERFROMANCE.

Avatar image for lboy
#22 Posted by lboy (583 posts) - - Show Bio

Did he turn into tywo face in TDK?

Avatar image for ronin_alexsnder
#23 Posted by ronin alexsnder (7747 posts) - - Show Bio

yes he did.

Avatar image for zoom
#24 Posted by Zoom (14751 posts) - - Show Bio
Korg said:
"Heath, easily. Jack just played himself, as he does in most of his movies. Ledger immersed himself in the character."
What makes this statement even better is how it completely demeans Jack as a person.

I love it.
Avatar image for t_j__magnum
#25 Posted by T.J. Magnum (25922 posts) - - Show Bio

every one is entitle to there opinions


mine is that heath was best joker,he is what i thought joker should be

Avatar image for the_gotham_knight
#26 Posted by The Gotham Knight (496 posts) - - Show Bio

Heath Ledger in all catagories

Avatar image for batfan1939
#27 Posted by batfan1939 (402 posts) - - Show Bio

Both fit their roles perfectly, but Ledger was simply a better actor. In a fight? H2H? Ledger. With weapons? Nicholson. As to who was more sadistic? I dunno. They're pretty equal.

Avatar image for cylondorado
#28 Posted by CylonDorado (1880 posts) - - Show Bio

I liked Jack better. Ledger was better for like, "oooooh, serious movie". It was great and all, but I think "Jack acting like Jack" is closer to how I like the Joker.
Avatar image for maikel
#29 Posted by Maikel (379 posts) - - Show Bio

Cesar Romero would step in and dehydrate them both: 

No Caption Provided
Avatar image for subject_30
#30 Posted by Subject 30 (211 posts) - - Show Bio

The pencil trick was good, but I still prefer Jack.

No Caption Provided
Avatar image for jedixman
#31 Posted by JediXMan (37491 posts) - - Show Bio

Heath
Heath
Heath
 
I think Heath was the better Joker. He would win in a fight as well (he won the fist fight. Yeah he cheated a lot, but THAT. IS. The Joker). 
 
He was certainly more sadistic.

Moderator
Avatar image for joshmightbe
#32 Posted by joshmightbe (27423 posts) - - Show Bio

i love the movie with jack but heath is way better

Online
Avatar image for lt1085
#33 Posted by LT1085 (3677 posts) - - Show Bio
@Perfect Cell said:
" The pencil "trick" was awesome. "
It's not like he improvised the whole thing. give that credit to the writer/director etc. It sounds horrible but Heath Ledger tends to get extra votes in his favor because he died. 
Avatar image for slacker_the_hacker
#34 Posted by slacker the hacker (10314 posts) - - Show Bio

i think heath was good but he did not laugh enough and his skin was not bleached witch is why perfer jack but if you add those to heath then i would pick him