James Gordon (Gotham) vs Rick Grimes (TV series)

• Round 1: Just hand to hand.
• Round 2: Gordon and Rick get their pistols.
• Battle takes place in Abandoned Place.

As of right now Grimes has experience advantage. Grimes takes this.

James wins H2H.

Rick wins in a gunfight.

Gordon is much better in a fist fight. I've only seen a little Gotham but he's beaten three bloodlusted guys bigger than him, when they were using various improvised weapons.

Rick wins a gunfight. I haven't seen Jim do anything overly impressive, whereas Rick is a fine marksman.

@navajaz: I like this battle.

I would say that Gordon would win the first round. Rick jobs too much lol. His fights with Shane, the Governor and his most recent brawl with Pete proves that he's just an average fighter with a poor h2h track record. Gordon, on the other hand, has had better showings (albeit very few )skilled against characters who appear to be just as skilled as everyone Rick has fought thus far.

Round 2 goes to Constable Rick. He has better showings with firearms and a lot more of them.

I feel like Rick should be far better at H2H than he has shown in TWD TV considering he's a cop, what did he skip police training that day?..Sheesh.

Going Gordon for Round 1 cause Rick only wins if he starts biting people.

And round 2 goes to rick

Gordon destroys Grimes at H2H.

Grimes might beat him at gun fight.

Gordon is far too skilled h2h so he takes round 1.

rick is a marksman and more likely to kil so he takes round 2.

Grimes bites his neck.

Grimes out shoots him.

Grimes both rounds.

Gordon isn't likely to kill so he's at a major disadvantage as Rick is a crazed beast right now.

@ssjbatdan: Is Gordon used to fighting people who fight dirty though? Bite people's necks, gauge out eyes, etc? Because that's how Rick fights in character, he's gonna go to whatever crazy extremes to win. I've only seen clips, but I dont think I'm missing any thing major from Jim combat wise?

He fought even with a Doctor with zero combat skill. Rick is a punk.

Gordon wrecks guys way bigger than him. He'd stomp Rick H2H.

I think the gunfight is closer than people say, Gordon has a few good shooting feats that are probably as good as Rick's average feats, but Rick definitely has more, so I'd still back him for the win.

Round 1 Gordon all the way Rick has no decent hand 2 hand showings except for biting someone's throat out. In round 2 I have to give it to Rick he is a way better marksman than Gordon.

@ssjbatdan: @black_arrow: **** you guys!!! Cries himself to sleep, because Rick's last fight sucked.

Rick is never shown as being a great h2h fighter, while James has better showings. Rick's savage fighting could give him a few wins, but not enough.

Ican't remember James ever being too impressive with a gun, and Rick has more experience here. Not to mmention he gets those crazy headshots lol. Round 2 is Rick.

Rick flat out kills him.

Gordon is much better trained and less psycho.

Commissioner 7/10

The Truth hurts.

Rick is savage!

However, he lost almost every single one of his fights where he didn't get help or some kind of distraction.

I would say Rick if he is allowed to get the advantage for even a moment though. The guy is as brutal as they come when he has decided you have to die.

Otherwise, Gordon every time he is on his A-game.

Might as well get with the program since it's the only truly correct answer.

Didn't watch much of Gotham, but I recall Gordon soloing three guys all fighting for their lives (and I also think all of them were armed), then immediately fought Black Mask and won

@ostarion: Cool. I'm actually gonna get more into Gotham and give it a chance. But, I'm more into Powers right now.

@lukehero: it started off slow and there are a few things that arent great but some of the characters are amazing. its enjoyable

Rick Grimes.