While I am not going to discount Batman's genius, fighting skills, and ability to use underhanded methods--I have to say ... Captain America.
Not only is Cap stronger, faster, more agile, and doesn't tire as fast as Bats; he's a master combatant. Just because someone knows a lot of different styles doesn't mean that he can win against someone who just might be an expert in just one. In addition, Cap's fought plenty of opponents who use tools and gadgets ranging from whips to thrown projectiles and even the more conventional guns. And plenty of them have also used boomerangs, smoke bombs, knock out gas, flares, and what have you to try and grab an edge over the Sentinel of Liberty and none of them have really worked too well.
He's also fought people with superior agility and even people who have lightning fast reflexes and precognitive "danger sense" like Spider-Man; and Spidey has gotten his butt kicked because he couldn't keep up with the ricocheting shield coming at weird angles and Cap at the same time was too much for him! And Spidey has had years to see Cap use that shield in action to boot.
Just because Cap has only the one weapon; his shield doesn't exactly make it any easier to defeat. It's taken blows from Thunder Gods and energy blasts from mad Titans without a scratch. Even if he does have like a miniature Bat Bazooka is going to overcome that. Nope, I have to that physically; Cap has the edge.
Smarts, I will give you that Bats is Cap's acknowledged superior. He's a master detective and clearly not a chump when it comes to inventing machines or gadgets. However, Cap is no dummy either. He's acknowledged as a master strategist and tactician just the same as Bats and Cap has demonstrated that he can be just as underhanded and devious when he needs to be. His skill at predicting how his shield can ricochet off multiple surfaces and rebound back that would make any master of billards gape with envy would indicate that he knows how to think three or even four moves ahead; it's not that difficult to believe that he can do the same thing in a fight against an opponent so I have to say that they're about even here. Cap has fought TONS of smarter people from MODOK to the Red Skull so I have to say that Cap is no slouch in the smarts department either. Any edge that Bats has isn't that vast.
Technology is Cap's one weak point. He doesn't go around carrying a utility belt of gadgets stuffed in it. So he's going to be up against an opponent who has the technological edge and isn't afraid to exploit it from things like his Batmobiles or Batwings to try and overwhelm . But Cap has been fighting man against weaponry and war machines for years--and so far, he hasn't exactly been beaten too easily by tech and can improvise handily with whatever around. And it's not like Cap is an technological illiterate. If he's even remotely given a chance; he'll be sure to bring something to equalize the playing field. So I have to say that Bats would win at technology, but Cap is fully capable of neutralizing it with either his smarts or some ace up his sleeve of his own.
And here it comes down to the nitty gritty. Will. The will to win. To overcome your opponent. Bats has easily one of the strongest wills ever. Superman is a weak knee sissy compared to Bats. He has stared into the face of horror night after night and has never broken. Unfortunately, against anyone else I would say that he would win right off. But Captain America is a soldier. He was raised during the chaos of the Great Depression and he LIVED through World War II. He fought his way across Europe and he fully saw the horrors, the terrors, and nightmare of the battlefield itself. He saw the Nazis and their Death Camps and he survived. He saw friends, fellow soldiers die, he even lost Bucky--his partner and someone he considered like a younger brother. He was plunged like 40 years into the future and had to deal with the enormous guilt of having survived when so many died through the passage of time and had to adapt to this modern age. So yeah--Cap is doesn't have the most flexible spines either. Another weaker person might have cracked or broken, but not Cap. He endured. Advantage of Will: Cap.
Bats might get lucky. If he had the advantage of preparing his terrain in advance and loading it with all manner of traps to weaken Cap then he might be able to overcome the Star-Spangled Avenger. Otherwise, it would be a very close fight. But Captain America would beat Batman.
Log in to comment