Now that she is revealed to be in the dark illuminati do you think that she is bad ore dose she have a another motive being in that group.

I think she's still good.

As if this conversation hasn't taken place in countless other threads and the same exact conclusion hasn't been drawn.............

SHE"S GOOD JOHN

"

SHE"S GOOD JOHN

Good.

]="

She's good,In fact she's alot better than some other X-men.

Just because she went to that meeting doesn't make her evil.

"She's good,In fact she's alot better than some other X-men."

"Vance Astro said:

"She's good,In fact she's alot better than some other X-men."

Especially Collosus, seedy Russian."

"Vance Astro said:

"She's good,In fact she's alot better than some other X-men."

Especially Collosus, seedy Russian."

"John Valentine said:

"Vance Astro said:

"She's good,In fact she's alot better than some other X-men."

Especially Collosus, seedy Russian."

And that Jean Grey woman i've heard so much about
[="

I heard her drapes didn't match the curtains

"John Valentine said:

"Vance Astro said:

"She's good,In fact she's alot better than some other X-men."

Especially Collosus, seedy Russian."

And that Jean Grey woman i've heard so much about
[="

LOL how harsh.

"pixelized said:

"John Valentine said:

"Vance Astro said:

"She's good,In fact she's alot better than some other X-men."

Especially Collosus, seedy Russian."

And that Jean Grey woman i've heard so much about
[="

What a whore.
Frank Miller, should write X-Men, bring her back and retcon her origin as a meth abusing lesbo."

"John Valentine said:

"pixelized said:

"John Valentine said:

"Vance Astro said:

"She's good,In fact she's alot better than some other X-men."

Especially Collosus, seedy Russian."

And that Jean Grey woman i've heard so much about
[="

What a whore.
Frank Miller, should write X-Men, bring her back and retcon her origin as a meth abusing lesbo."

Frank Millers hands should be cut off and a layer of skin should be cut off of his back and then beat with a bat with a cheese grater tied to the end."

"LOL how harsh."

"John Valentine said:

"pixelized said:

"John Valentine said:

"Vance Astro said:

"She's good,In fact she's alot better than some other X-men."

Especially Collosus, seedy Russian."

And that Jean Grey woman i've heard so much about
[="

What a whore.
Frank Miller, should write X-Men, bring her back and retcon her origin as a meth abusing lesbo."

Frank Millers hands should be cut off and a layer of skin should be cut off of his back and then beat with a bat with a cheese grater tied to the end."

"Vance Astro said:

"John Valentine said:

"pixelized said:

"John Valentine said:

"Vance Astro said:

"She's good,In fact she's alot better than some other X-men."

Especially Collosus, seedy Russian."

And that Jean Grey woman i've heard so much about
[="

What a whore.
Frank Miller, should write X-Men, bring her back and retcon her origin as a meth abusing lesbo."

Frank Millers hands should be cut off and a layer of skin should be cut off of his back and then beat with a bat with a cheese grater tied to the end."

WOW, serious hatred. He's done some good stuff.

"Vance Astro said:

"John Valentine said:

"pixelized said:

"John Valentine said:

"Vance Astro said:

"She's good,In fact she's alot better than some other X-men."

Especially Collosus, seedy Russian."

And that Jean Grey woman i've heard so much about
[="

What a whore.
Frank Miller, should write X-Men, bring her back and retcon her origin as a meth abusing lesbo."

Frank Millers hands should be cut off and a layer of skin should be cut off of his back and then beat with a bat with a cheese grater tied to the end."

WOW, serious hatred. He's done some good stuff.

She's a bad character, but she's not evil.

i think shes good
undercover perhaps?

"i think shes good
undercover perhaps?"

"Kid Anarchy said:

"i think shes good
undercover perhaps?"

good theroy. who can tell that she lying or read her mind?"

Pretty sure Emma is just there to make sure they don't screw over mutants. Stark let mutants stay neutral - I doubt Osborn would treat them the same way, especially if Emma had turned down the invitation.

"John Valentine said:

"Vance Astro said:

"John Valentine said:

"pixelized said:

"John Valentine said:

"Vance Astro said:

"She's good,In fact she's alot better than some other X-men."

Especially Collosus, seedy Russian."

And that Jean Grey woman i've heard so much about
[="

What a whore.
Frank Miller, should write X-Men, bring her back and retcon her origin as a meth abusing lesbo."

Frank Millers hands should be cut off and a layer of skin should be cut off of his back and then beat with a bat with a cheese grater tied to the end."

WOW, serious hatred. He's done some good stuff.

Good Stuff? He wrote one good thing...ONE! Dark Knight returns is his legacy.His Daredevil stuff sucked,All-Star Batman sucks,His Marvel team-ups sucked,Sin City sucks and so does 300 and if they weren't movies they would be forgotten easily."

i think she does do things that will benefit her, but lately i see she's seriously trying to do things that are better for mutants

I think she should remain good and stay with x-men, personalley I don't remember her being bad, she wasn't a great villian. It's when she turn good she became interesting.

"I think she should remain good and stay with x-men, personalley I don't remember her being bad, she wasn't a great villian. It's when she turn good she became interesting."

I never said i hated emma, i just find her ignoring at times. She doesn't compare to likes of jean  grey or Psylocke. She not better than rogue or storm. I think she is a good character, i liked her more then kitty, beast, angel and bishop now. I like her as much as I like archangel.

"I never said i hated emma, i just find her ignoring at times. She doesn't compare to likes of jean  grey or Psylocke. She not better than rogue or storm. I think she is a good character, i liked her more then kitty, beast, angel and bishop now. I like her as much as I like archangel."

• Emma Frost.
• Jean Grey.
• Rogue.
• Kitty Pryde.
• Mercury.
• Dust.
• X-23.

"Vance Astro said:

"John Valentine said:

"Vance Astro said:

"John Valentine said:

"pixelized said:

"John Valentine said:

"Vance Astro said:

"She's good,In fact she's alot better than some other X-men."

Especially Collosus, seedy Russian."

And that Jean Grey woman i've heard so much about
[="

What a whore.
Frank Miller, should write X-Men, bring her back and retcon her origin as a meth abusing lesbo."

Frank Millers hands should be cut off and a layer of skin should be cut off of his back and then beat with a bat with a cheese grater tied to the end."

WOW, serious hatred. He's done some good stuff.

Good Stuff? He wrote one good thing...ONE! Dark Knight returns is his legacy.His Daredevil stuff sucked,All-Star Batman sucks,His Marvel team-ups sucked,Sin City sucks and so does 300 and if they weren't movies they would be forgotten easily."

Batman: Year One.
The Dark Knight Strikes Again."

"John Valentine said:

"Vance Astro said:

"John Valentine said:

"Vance Astro said:

"John Valentine said:

"pixelized said:

"John Valentine said:

"Vance Astro said:

"She's good,In fact she's alot better than some other X-men."

Especially Collosus, seedy Russian."

And that Jean Grey woman i've heard so much about
[="

What a whore.
Frank Miller, should write X-Men, bring her back and retcon her origin as a meth abusing lesbo."

Frank Millers hands should be cut off and a layer of skin should be cut off of his back and then beat with a bat with a cheese grater tied to the end."

WOW, serious hatred. He's done some good stuff.

Good Stuff? He wrote one good thing...ONE! Dark Knight returns is his legacy.His Daredevil stuff sucked,All-Star Batman sucks,His Marvel team-ups sucked,Sin City sucks and so does 300 and if they weren't movies they would be forgotten easily."

Batman: Year One.
The Dark Knight Strikes Again."

Those weren't all that good either."

My Faverite X-Woman are :

1 Rogue
2 Jean Grey
3 Storm
4 Psylocke
5 Then emma frost, i think she to similar to psylocke & jean grey, she reminds me of them and she is not as good as  them or as powerful.
6 Domino
7 Mstique 
8 Jubilee, from the 90's  

My Faverite X-Males/X-characters are :

1 Wolverine
2 Gambit
3 Cable
4 Cylops
5 Magneto
6 Shatterstar/ Warpath 
7 Colossus
8 Iceman/Charles  
9 Archangel, not angel from uncanny x-men, Just from the x-force, the angel of death.
 
It was a close call between cylops & cable.

I hate kitty & I hate beast at the moment.

There are many good female X-Characters, but there not all used in today comics and the ones that are, are not used probley

Its when she became good, she became  a good character, she was a crap villian. I don't think she better then some of x-men.

"Its when she became good, she became  a good character, she was a crap villian. I don't think she better then some of x-men. "

Scient said:

"time said:

"Its when she became good, she became  a good character, she was a crap villian. I don't think she better then some of x-men. "

No."

no to what, she was never a good villian

"time said:

"I never said i hated emma, i just find her ignoring at times. She doesn't compare to likes of jean  grey or Psylocke. She not better than rogue or storm. I think she is a good character, i liked her more then kitty, beast, angel and bishop now. I like her as much as I like archangel."

Fair enough. The thing is that there are many good female X-Characters.
My favorites are:

• Emma Frost.
• Jean Grey.
• Rogue.
• Kitty Pryde.
• Mercury.
• Dust.
• X-23.

 

"

she is good and so is Namor

Emma= good.

Now Marvel, will you please put her in Ultimate Alliance 2 already? 

Her X-men legends stint was awful.

"Vance Astro said:

"SUNMAN said:

"Vance Astro said:

"SUNMAN said:

"she is good and so is Namor"

No he's not.Namor hasn't been good since Cap was alive."

What are you talking about Namor has always been one of the good guys! "

He's been fighting on the right side.I don't ever remember him being an actual good guy."

????????? What?!       Than explain to me why he is not a good guy. He fights on the right side, like you said. He does everything in his power to protect his people. He is almost never the aggressor. He maybe annoying at times, but he is an honorable guy. Are you saying he is bad, because he was not pro-registration? If you are using that logic that makes the New Avengers and a good chunck of American heroes bad guys."