Tony lost.

Anti-reg all the way

If Captain America hadn't realized the wrong he was doing, he would have won.

" anti reg for me they had a better cause and far more powerful teams Cap shouldnt have surrendered "

" @TheEverLovinThing: cap wasnt in the wrong tony and the government were  "

anti reg would have won if cloak didnt teleport them to the civilians

The North, definitely. We've all seen what happens in Alternate History where the South won the Civil war. :) 
 
 Sorry couldn't resist. >.> 
 
Anti-registration, the information would be too dangerous in the wrong hands.

ANTI-REG!!

" Pro reg, and for good reasons.  You can't beat up Iron Man, turn to congress and say,  " see I won. Change the law" "

I think all of the characters who weren't involved in the Civil War should have teamed up and slapped both sides silly.

If Captain America presented the evidence that Tony Stark was the mastermind behind the Civil War (check Frontline - Sally Floyd and Ben Urich knew the truth, but decided to sit on it), he could have moral victory even if his side lost the war.

 In short they should both win. Story wise Iron Man should have won. Then they could have this whole story arc portraying how it effects Superheroics in general, then Captain America could go back in time and fix the time line allowing Capt. America to win.  
 
It's funny. I'm looking at what's happening in the middle east and it makes me think Iron Man should have won, but only because he was right. Technically if Captain America didn't want to register he should have staged a peaceful protest, not go to all out world. But would that have made a good story, maybe?  

The end of Civil War was horrible. Cap surrendering because it wasnt the American way? STUPID ending.

If cap had beaten Tony it wouldn't have changed anything, the anit-reg movement would have had to start a guerrilla campaign against the government in hope of ether a comprise or an eventual regime change

the anit-reg movement would have had to start a guerrilla campaign against the government in hope of ether a comprise or an eventual regime change 

Well if the people didn't barge in like animals and restrained Captain America, then Steve would've made his point and I think Tony would've heard what he had to say. The people were stupid because they knew damn well Steve isn't a murderer, and wasn't going to kill Stark. So, had Steve finished what he was about to do at the end of Civil War #7, I think the whole assassination and whatnot would've never happened. All Tony had to do was get off his high horse and listen to what the hell was going on around him.  
 
And if you ask me, the whole SHRA was a dumb idea... At least the way they were going about it. Should vigilantes be illegal in the Marvel U? Absolutely, but just because you have powers doesn't mean you should have to sign up for anything. Just the people with powers (or not in the case of some heroes) who intend to put their lives on the line and "fight the good fight". And if you wanted to continue to be a superhero, just tell SHIELD your information. It's not like they don't have it anyway. The public shouldn't have to know the name and background of the superheroes,  they should just be thankful that they're even saving them at all. The people in the Marvel U were so ungrateful.