imperiousrix's Captain America #1 - American Dreamers Part 1 review

    Avatar image for imperiousrix

    War Days

    This post was originally from my Wordpress blog.  That, and other long-winded musings, can be found HERE. 
     

    Captain America's stock in the world of comics has always been relatively high.  Considered a top tier character in his own right, it may surprise the casual observer (and those that just recently peeped the fantastic Captain America film by Joe Johnston) that Steve Rogers hasn't actually been Cap for quite a while now.  In fact, aside from being DEAD for a while, Steve's been more of an administrative type in this, Marvel's "Heroic Age".

    That changes in the new series by Ed Brubaker (considered by many as THE definitive writer for Captain America) and Steve McNiven.  Not only is Steve back to being the "star-studded man with a plan", but he's wielding the shield and going up against classic villains and shadow organizations dating back to WWII.

    • THE GOOD
    If there's one person who knows Steve Rogers, his mythos, and how the character behaves, it's Ed Brubaker.  From page 1, his writing for Cap embodies the character's selfless spirit and wholesome attitude.  It certainly helps that Brubaker immediately pulls heart strings by having Cap and his buddies attending the funeral of Steve's first real love, but that's very much beside the point.  The point here is to re-establish Steve Rogers as Captain America and start him off against characters that are both wholly familiar without seeming like the same old "been there, done that" storyline.

    It's also worth mentioning (if not overtly obvious) that Steve McNiven's art is excellent.  He's always been an extremely solid artist with a penchant for drawing action scenes in amazing detail, but I was doubly impressed by his use of unique paneling in this first issue.  There's a particularly striking image in where Dugan, Fury, and Carter are placed in circular panels above a sprinting Cap (wearing a black tuxedo) that would be awesome to have print of.

    • THE BAD

    Although Brubaker's new Captain America series certainly starts off with a bang, there is a sense of simplicity with the initial set-up that feels a bit incomplete.  With juggling WWII flashbacks and current events, it's not at a lack for content, but other than the "bad guy is out to get Cap, BIGGER bad guy is helping", there's not a ton drawing you back for the second issue.  You're going to come back because of the page-turning qualities of this FIRST issue, not because any super-compelling looks to be coming down the pike.  That's not really a BAD thing by any stretch, but this intro is just a wee too basic for me.  I really want a series' opening issues to rope me in.

    • THE VERDICT
    Despite any complaints I may have, Captain America #1 is an easy comic to pick up and love.  Cap fans are not going to want to miss it, the characterization is spot on, and the artwork is fantastic.  It might not be a blockbuster story to open up the series, but it's one that, if nothing else, is a page-turner packed with enough heroics to justify the price of admission.  If you've got the smallest interest in Captain America, this is a better place than any to jump on.

    Other reviews for Captain America #1 - American Dreamers Part 1

      Keep Dreaming About Those Movie Readers, Marvel 0

      In time for the movie, Captain America relaunches with a new number one but the same great writer, who delivers an issue that anyone should be able to jump into and enjoy. Kicking off with the funeral of Peggy Carter, this new series starts with the classic kind of Captain America story that takes place partially in the present and partially back in the World War II era.  For the record, I don't believe comic book movies, however good, bring any substantial numbers of new customers to comic shop...

      10 out of 10 found this review helpful.

      Brubaker & McNiven - 'Nuff Said! 0

      As a long time Captain America subscriber I kinda rolled my eyes when reading that his series was being split up into two titles including a renumbered book. But once seeing that Ed Brubaker would be teaming up with Steve McNiven, I was instantly intrigued.   In this first issue Brubaker gives us what feels look a classic Captain America story. We get some fantastic moments between characters and a story which perfectly blends everything from touching emotional moments to flashbacks to cinemati...

      5 out of 5 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.