@Vance Astro said:
@Umbraa said:I don't think you did because you keep reposting Hickman's words as if to suggest they contradict my own but they don't. There has been several Avengers teams over the last 5-6 years and there has always been a reason for leadership change. I thought that the New Avengers would simply be a superhero team like they had been in the past I didn't know the roster. I only heard that Cap and Black Panther were both on the team but Black Panther was leading. The only reason I could assume they would let Black Panther lead is because Cap is already a member of another team that he leads and wouldn't be able to divide the time. Now that I know they are the Illuminati and knowing what I know about how the group is structured from their previous incarnation under Bendis, it makes sense to me that, someone with T'Challa's intellect and his experience as king would assume a leadership role there, otherwise it DOESN'T make sense, WITHOUT a proper explanation. No writer takes a over a team book and makes a character the leader without a valid explanation.I read what you are saying. I'm saying it's a opinion. Why? because it is. Again, Captain America HAS been on teams where he was not the leader, including Avengers teams. NEW Avengers is a team and as Hickman said Cap and Stark are building that team based on things going on in NEW Avengers and to face the large threats.
So your opinion is that it would not make sense. Mine is that it doesn't matter.
@Mykhael said:That was never anyone's logic. My logic was, if there was going to be an Avengers team with Captain America on it that he's not leading, there should be a logical explanation for it.Flawed Logic: A has always been the leader so B can’t lead.
@Mykhael said:This is flawed logic because in the case that the effective leader is still effective, why would the team change leaders?Explanation of Flaw: Just because A has been the leader and is effective doesn’t mean that B can’t be just as effective or even more so.
@Mykhael said:Nobody ever said that Cap has always lead every team he's been on.Just because A has been leader doesn’t mean that he can’t follow, especially if he HAS been a soldier who follows orders.
@Mykhael said:Which is obvious and nobody ever said the opposite.Explanation of Flaw: Leading before does not mean always leading.
Sadly...he's doing just that. Cap may not even have a huge role...but he is on the Illuminati. T'challa is bring them together and leading. End of topic. Besides, Cap is going to have a reduced role.
Log in to comment