Comic Vine News

86 Comments

Comic Book Question of the Week: 03/19/13 - Save a Comic Book Show

If you had the power to revive one of these shows, which would you save and why?

It has been an especially tough few years for comic book shows on television. We've had the luxury of watching some absolutely fantastic shows, but so many of them have been cut short. Sadly, we live in an era where topnotch quality just isn't enough. At the end of the day, this is a business product, and if it's not meeting the goals the company and network have set -- no matter how unfair or absurd they may be -- then the harsh truth is we'll see them fade away.

Spectacular Spider-Man was stunning yet was thrown on the chopping block. Now we have Ultimate Spider-Man instead and... well, I'll just plead the fifth on that subject. Cartoon Network fans have been hit particularly hard. Not only did we lose Young Justice and Green Lantern: The Animated Series, but Star Wars: The Clone Wars also wrapped up. Yes, that show was going to end anyway, but I figured since so many people want to see it stick around there's no harm keeping it as an option on this poll. Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes is being replaced, Transformers: Prime is being shut down and Wolverine and the X-Men only lasted one season.

You can only bring one back to life!
You can only bring one back to life!

Seeing a show we love bite the dust simply sucks. But, just for this week, let's pretend we have the power to revive just one of these programs. So, this 'Comic Book Question of the Week' is simple: which show would you save and why?

CLICK HERE TO VOTE! Voting will be open until Thursday morning (ET) and a feature with the results will go up on the homepage shortly after.

Remember, you need to click the above link to vote! Posting your vote in the comments section below will not count!

Gregg Katzman is a freelance writer for Comic Vine and IGN Entertainment. This is the part where he shamelessly plugs his Google+ and Twitter page in hopes of getting a new follower or two.

86 CommentsRefresh
  • 86 results
  • 1
  • 2
Avatar image for crazy_pan
Posted By Crazy Pan

Young Justice :)

Avatar image for mucklefluga
Posted By Mucklefluga

Didn't realize Transformers has been cancelled !!

Avatar image for kingdomenic
Posted By kingdomenic

Firefly

Avatar image for naylor11
Posted By naylor11

Save Young Justice!

http://youngjustice.wikia.com/wiki/Young_Justice_Wiki:Save_Young_Justice

Avatar image for neiliusprime
Edited By neiliusprime

@Mucklefluga said:

Didn't realize Transformers has been cancelled !!

well to be exact Its not being canceled, but the series will end. I think there is plans for another Transformes show on the horizon.

Avatar image for liveforever
Posted By LiveForever

I'm a Marvel guy (plus Batman and related) but am intrigued by the outpouring of love for Young Justice. I need to give that a shot. 
 
EMH all the way for me. Great story adaptations, not dumbed down like anything Loeb touches.

Avatar image for toastalchemist
Posted By Toastalchemist

Green Lantern, because it had the most potential. Young Justice ended with you-know-who, which was expected. I think another season would have been too much. Green Lantern seemed like it was building up to something bigger with Razor's possible new corps, the search for Aya, mentioning the creature living in the green power battery, and a few more lantern corps which were never touched on.

Avatar image for k4tzm4n
Posted By k4tzm4n

@kingdomenic said:

Firefly

lol.

@Mucklefluga said:

Didn't realize Transformers has been cancelled !!

Yes, the 3rd is the last season.

Moderator Online
Avatar image for mrarrogant
Posted By MrArrogant

Young Justice, definitely. It was a tough call between that and Spectacular Spider-Man (hey what a coikidink! both Greg Weisman shows), but with YJ I just felt there were more places the show could go, and more stories that could be told in the universe. It's a shame cartoon network is run by idiots that the cancelled both this and the spectacular Green Lantern.

Avatar image for liveforever
Posted By LiveForever

Related question: does Young Justice require (or is it enhanced by) viewing anything in advance? Like Justice League?

Avatar image for teerack
Posted By Teerack

Young Justice for sure.

Avatar image for durararaftw
Posted By DurararaFTW

Young Justice, after that Wolverine and the X-Men.

Avatar image for sobe_cin
Posted By Sobe Cin

 
The Show I want back..... 

The Clone Wars- I am more interested in knowing what will happen with Ahsoka than I am in most of the other shows. They left to much open not to have some sort of resolution with certain characters. I know that they wrapped up a lot of arcs with certain characters, but others are still left with me wanting more.... I know they have plans, but I would still like a sixth season.  
 
 
The ones I don't for whatever reason.
 
Avengers is turning into Avengers Assemble, I accept that now.  
 
Young Justice is great and I watched each weekend, but with who they ended with- I can deal without. Plus I am kind of excited to see Beware the Batman (I think I may be alone in this). 
 
Wolverine and the X-Men- It's too late for my desires to have this be rekindled. If a new X-Men show must be made, I will watch that. 
 
Green Lantern- Watched a episode, didn't care for it. 
 
Same with Transformers- watched an episode or two, but could not get into it. 
 
As for Spectacular Spider-Man- Like Wolverine, its a little late for a return, plus I like Ultimate Spider-Man now. 
  
Not on the list. 
 
 
GI Joe Renegades- I want this back or some GI Joe cartoon, they never last more than one season.

Avatar image for dmxn
Posted By DMXN

We as much as I want to see Avengers EMH, Wolverine and the X-men and Green Lantern I have to chose YOUNG JUSTICE. YOUNG JUSTICE was truly the best of them all. Good buy old friend.

Avatar image for ms__omega
Posted By ms__omega

Young Justice

Avatar image for apg103
Posted By apg103

I liked Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes, but I only saw up to about 2 seasons.

Spectacular Spider-Man was very good too.only saw up to about 2 seasons, even thoh it was on another channel.

I liked Wolverine and the X-Men, but I'm not sure how many seasons they had.

Young Justice was probably the best overall, So that who i will be voting for.

I haven't even watched Green Lantern: The Animated Series, Star Wars: The Clone Wars, and Transformers: Prime

Avatar image for stmichalofwilson
Posted By StMichalofWilson

Wait, wait, wait Transformers Prime is being cancelled?!

Avatar image for logan_reilly
Posted By Logan Reilly

No contest. It'd be Young Justice.

Avatar image for gundamheavyarms
Posted By GundamHeavyarms

@StMichalofWilson: No its not cancelled, the third and final season is starting friday.

Avatar image for wadey_wilson
Posted By wadey wilson

Spectacular Spider-Man... no true Spidey fan can like "Ultimate Spider-Man" and the worst part is that it's starting to affect the movies as well... I hate it. After that, Young Justice. I really enjoyed it. And The Avengers, the dub in my country was awesome.

Avatar image for rixec
Posted By Rixec

Just one? I'd take them all!

Avatar image for escgamer
Posted By EscGamer

I would love for Spectacular Spider-Man to come back. It was such a great show and it left doors open to explore which can get darker and deeper if need be. I will say this season 1 Ultimate Spider-Man wasn't so great but season 2 has gotten better, up until the sinister six episode. Drake Bell has gotten better with the voice but Josh Keaton will always be my favorite Spider-Man voice wise. I don't think we've seen the end of Young Justice and Green Lantern, just cause they haven't been renewed doesn't mean they're gone. YJ was on hiatus so much too and since DC nation is a hour long they probably got changed with the new line-up and come next seaon they make a return and the new line-up goes away. it would make sense to switch it up every time so shows get produced and avoid angering fans for hiatus or delays. Anyway my vote went to Young Justice because it has a shot at coming back, that's if it's truly canceled, since Spectac Spidey won't seem to come back.

Avatar image for frochez
Posted By frochez

I'm going to come out of left field here and say X-men: Evolution. Yes, it's not on the list. Yes, it was a while ago. And yes, it may not have aged that well. But it had a great mix of character development and action, combined with uneblievable artwork, that was lacking in the 90s x-men series, and it had a wide range of characters, unlike Wolverine and the X-men, which was all about short, hairy and clawy.

Avatar image for allstarsuperman
Posted By AllStarSuperman

definitely young justice

Avatar image for notoriousmistersims
Posted By notoriousmistersims

would have liked to see a 3rd season of yj coz he showed up same goes for w a x men coz apoc showed up and to see where it went

Avatar image for cafeterialoca
Posted By Cafeterialoca

Spectacular Spider-Man. Easily. It was the best Spider-Man show we ever had and it was progressing as a story. It is absolutely CRIMINAL that Ultimate Spider-Man, a show that's pretty awful, replaced it.

Why is it that creators who put a lot of effort and time in their shows get canceled while shows that go "It's Spider-Man! LOL! He doesn't even have to act like himself as long as he's RANDUMB! XD!!!"

Seriously, this world SUCKS.

Avatar image for evilvegeta74
Posted By evilvegeta74

love YJ, but Avengers EMH was my thing!

Avatar image for mcknight87
Posted By McKnight87

Young Justice. Easily. It has far better story lines and character development than any of the others listed here. I'm much more of a DC fan, so after that, it'd be Green Lantern. Sticking with Young Justice as my main choice, though.

Avatar image for druzod2501
Posted By druzod2501

In my mind it's a dead heat between GL:TAS and YJ, but I think I would go with GL in the end. The last half of the season showed why GL could be DC's Star Wars if they handled it properly, and the wealth of untapped potential storylines is vast:

1) the harnessing of the yellow light coinciding with the fall of Sinestro and rise of his Corps.

2) the Indigo tribe

3) War of the Light

4) Blackest Night

5) Destruction of Coast City and Hal Jordan's darkest hour

6) Introduce Kyle Rayner

just to name a few.

Avatar image for sora_thekey
Posted By sora_thekey

I can't choose between Spectacular Spider-Man and Wolverine and the X-Men!

Avatar image for gothamred
Posted By GothamRed

Isn't Clone Wars just moving to Disney XD? I'd say Spectacular Spider-Man or the two Yost-verse shows since I liked them all the most.

Avatar image for jacobin_wisdom
Posted By Jacobin_Wisdom

Wolverine and the X-Men

I liked it to the point that I brought the whole season on DVD.

Was very curious on how the second season would be :(

Avatar image for iaconpoint
Posted By iaconpoint

@neiliusprime said:

@Mucklefluga said:

Didn't realize Transformers has been cancelled !!

well to be exact Its not being canceled, but the series will end. I think there is plans for another Transformes show on the horizon.

Hasblo, the American company that licenses Transformers feels the need to "reboot" continuity every 2 to 3 years. Apparently, they have little faith in America's youth to be able to keep up with more than a few years of continuity. It's the cross we Transformer fans have had to bare for the last 15 or so years.

Avatar image for dark_vengeance_
Posted By Dark_Vengeance_

Young Justice.

Avatar image for wonderhunter
Posted By WonderHunter

Spectacular Spider-Man :'(

Avatar image for lostlantern13
Posted By lostlantern13

This was a tough call.

I initially thought "Young Justice," because I am pro-anything-DC-not-Batman-or-Superman. I honestly think DC, if it is serious about television and movies, needs to develop and invest in other franchises not named Batman or Superman. Young Justice was doing a great job with the Flash Family, Beast Boy, Blue Beetle, and, especially, Kaldur/Aqualad. DC needed that.

However, "Green Lantern: The Animated Series" was getting better with each passing episode. This was truly the mainstream media development that GL fans, like myself, had been waiting for. They did such a great job of building out the Lantern mythology and were really prepared to burst into the War of Light, Blackest Night, and beyond. Even new creations like Razer and Aya were well-received (and deservedly so). If I could save it, I would. This is what DC and the GL universe needs.

Avatar image for violetphoenix
Posted By VioletPhoenix

Torn between Young Justice and Wolverine & The X-Men, but I've made my peace with the latter being gone for 5 years. Young Justice is just so damn amazing. It wins out.

Avatar image for bonzi161
Posted By Bonzi161

no Teen Titans (sorry but Teen Titans go does not count)

Avatar image for yourcounterpoint
Posted By YourCounterpoint

The two DC Nation shows were the best. I loved Young Justice, but at the same time Green Lantern was getting really good and I was hoping for a War of Light story.

Avatar image for ramier
Posted By Ramier

today i would say wolverine and the xmen and young justice

Avatar image for ectoborge
Posted By ectoborge

You Can save Young Justice

http://youngjustice.wikia.com/wiki/Young_Justice_Wiki:Save_Young_Justice

Avatar image for thecommissar
Posted By TheCommissar

I'd have to go with Young Justice. While I like almost all the shows up there (save TCW, since it's one of the worst things to happen to Star Wars, second only to Karen Traviss, and Transformers, which while decent, isn't something I care much for), I feel like it has the most potential. Specifically that it could lead to a new DCAU, which I've wanted for a while, whereas I feel Marvel just doesn't know how to handle its animated shows enough to establish a decent Marvel animated universe.

Avatar image for fantasgasmic
Posted By Fantasgasmic

Batman Beyond?

Avatar image for caseyjustice
Posted By CaseyJustice

Boy, I'll never understand the love for Spectacular Spider-Man. It seemed to me like the laziest, dullest possible retelling of the same Spidey stories we'd been reading/watching for decades. At least USM is trying something new with the character.

Tough one between GL and YJ, but GL's ending was too perfect to mess with. YJ had lots more stories to tell.

EMH was excellent, but by the end of season 2 I think it was winding down in quality anyway.

Avatar image for threadpool
Posted By ThreadPool

In this order:

1. Young Justice

2. Green Lantern

3. Spectacular Spider-man

4. Wolverine and the X-Men

5. Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes

I think Clone Wars had a nice looooong run. Especially for good a Cartoon Network action show. (let's not speak of Ben 10.) And it has a better chance than any of these at any kind of continuation.

Transformers Prime feels too much like the movies. I will give it another shot though. That may just be the earlier episodes.

Avatar image for threadpool
Edited By ThreadPool

@CaseyJustice: WHAT?!?!? SSM was a breath of fresh air coming off of Spider-Man 3. Although I wasn't a fan of the character designs.

USM is okay for little kids. That's about it.

Avatar image for laabitres
Posted By laabitres

young justice :) better story and better animation than the rest of the other shows

Avatar image for dementedtheclown
Posted By dementedtheclown

STATIC SHOCK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Avatar image for answerman
Posted By Answerman

Young Justice Hands down.

In many ways the new 52 should have made choices closer to what was done with YJ, like with the Flash legacy for instance.

  • 86 results
  • 1
  • 2